Recent comments in /f/Music
Otherwise_Interest99 t1_ja2pnxw wrote
Reply to What genre is Steely Dan? by Sniperizer
It is rock indeed.
sorengray t1_ja2plyo wrote
Reply to What genre is Steely Dan? by Sniperizer
Adult contemporary jazz rock
huge_mclarge t1_ja2pc42 wrote
theivery corporation - saudade
[deleted] t1_ja2pbw6 wrote
[deleted]
huge_mclarge t1_ja2p4sr wrote
Reply to I need a new band to get into!! by Ashamed_Ad_8235
rock: queens of the stone age, mastodon, mudvayne, gojira
indie: spoon, the shins, the kills, arcade fire
old school alternative: pixies, the cure, siouxsie & the banshees, the smiths
rap/hip hop: tribe called quest, de la soul, prof, kendrick lamar
treetreestwigbranch t1_ja2p0c9 wrote
Reply to I need a new band to get into!! by Ashamed_Ad_8235
Thrice
onemoretwat t1_ja2oc9r wrote
Jack White - ‘Fear of The Dawn’ and ‘Entering Heaven Alive’ are both incredible albums.
RZAxlash t1_ja2n7mx wrote
Reply to comment by mirrorsaw in I don't like Lana Del Rey but I don't know why by JunFerra
Same here, but songs like blue jeans are on another level
GalleonStar t1_ja2mkgu wrote
Reply to comment by HumanJenoM in With AI music, who gets credit for composing and/or performing? by wangw01
You can if you programmed the AI, or if the AI user agreement signs over ownership of the completed work to the user.
GalleonStar t1_ja2mhnv wrote
Reply to comment by DeadEyeMetal in With AI music, who gets credit for composing and/or performing? by wangw01
You absolutely are the composer. You can hit a keyboard randomly and write down the notes and call yourself a composer, using a tool that requires your input is more involved than that.
Ok-Impress-2222 t1_ja2m7fc wrote
Reply to I need a new band to get into!! by Ashamed_Ad_8235
Deftones.
[deleted] t1_ja2ks5j wrote
[deleted]
Dcoonery t1_ja2kjkg wrote
Reply to Who are your top 5 favorite songwriters? Count lyricists’ and composers’ teams as one. by GeorgeHowland
Neil Tennant and Chris Lowe
Dcoonery t1_ja2kh7k wrote
Reply to comment by Blinkth3dog in What line from a song lyric has made the most impact on you? by jso85
Love this
Dcoonery t1_ja2kan5 wrote
I am not afraid to keep on living I am not afraid to walk this world alone
-Famous Last Words by My Chemical Romance
Dcoonery t1_ja2k67h wrote
Reply to I need a new band to get into!! by Ashamed_Ad_8235
If you want to go down a rabbit hole of weirdness unlike anything you’ve heard before check out Coil
Sniperizer OP t1_ja2k4wd wrote
Reply to comment by Kallisti7 in What genre is Steely Dan? by Sniperizer
I'm dad, but dont have a yacht :D
Sniperizer OP t1_ja2k1pz wrote
Reply to comment by jayboyguy in What genre is Steely Dan? by Sniperizer
Wow, first thanks for the informative reply. Second, thanks for implying about American musical history. I think its market or trending music forces tend to influence bands or musicians trying to stay relevant to please business execs. That I do understand. So me growing up in 70;,80,90 decades kinda have a messy streaming playlist.
Kallisti7 t1_ja2jrvb wrote
Reply to What genre is Steely Dan? by Sniperizer
Dad/yacht rock
[deleted] t1_ja2jr0m wrote
Reply to comment by BDOKlem in What genre is Steely Dan? by Sniperizer
[deleted]
kekcuk_13 t1_ja2jp7j wrote
Reply to I need a new band to get into!! by Ashamed_Ad_8235
A perfect circle
jayboyguy t1_ja2jibt wrote
Reply to What genre is Steely Dan? by Sniperizer
Your question perfectly illustrates why genres are useful as a means of discussion of sounds and styles, but useless for actual categorization of artists, bands, albums, songs, etc.
Historically in America, the people responsible for innovating music did so because they didn’t give a crap about fitting within a particular sound. They made the sounds they heard, that grew out of what they knew, and made newer things from them. From Duke and Charlie Parker to D’Angelo and Erykah Badu, people who push music deliberately eschew the constraints of traditional labels. And perhaps Steely Dan isn’t so influential as the people I’ve named, but they pushed the capabilities of their sound for sure.
Ultimately, trying to pigeonhole artists into singular genres is often not only impossible, but harmful. I’ve talked to many a friend who had difficulty properly getting their music out there because they didn’t write it with a specific genre in mind, yet streaming services tried to get them to define their sound under a singular banner.
Which, if you didn’t know, is how many genre distinctions came about in the first place. For the most part, it was not musicians who first labeled genres; it was execs and managers who wanted to slap labels on things to make it more easily marketable.
All that said, you’ve actually answered your own question here. You’ve defined the elements you hear in their stuff, and that’s as far as it’s gotta go.
JunFerra OP t1_ja2jd4e wrote
Reply to comment by yesimextra in I don't like Lana Del Rey but I don't know why by JunFerra
I think you hit the nail here: a lot of people here in this thread think that I don't like the """"uncomfortable"""" song topics, the melodrama or the character, and I don't think that's the case. The problem is the connection. She's a great artist, but I can't connect to her.
Ur4FartKn0ck3r t1_ja2ih63 wrote
Reply to What genre is Steely Dan? by Sniperizer
They're considered lame.
Otherwise_Interest99 t1_ja2pqkg wrote
Reply to comment by Sniperizer in What genre is Steely Dan? by Sniperizer
Well said.