Recent comments in /f/Music

galvanizedrocknroll t1_jaes0mk wrote

This seems like a shitty way to enjoy music. No offense op. Instead do the same album for a week. See what you learn. (I'm being a little over dramatic. You do you. This just seems like an exercise in quantity rather than gaining any insight to artistic ability or nuance.)

0

ACAB_FOR_CUTIE_ t1_jaeomhq wrote

I started this challenge last year to fill in gaps in my music knowledge since I grew up on grunge and later and only know a little about previous eras.

I've found it very enjoyable but the editor is biased against some alt music and rails against emo music in a paragraph in the book. Some omissions include Weezer, Tool, Modest Mouse, Death Cab, 3EB, Jimmy Eat World and probably more I can't think off at the moment. Full list with all editions if you're curious

1

DeadEyeMetal t1_jaenogs wrote

>Leonard cohen 🔥, nick drake 🔥, Velvet underground,🔥 miles Davis🔥, the kinks🔥, john coltrane,🔥 Nina Simone, townes van Zandt🔥

I pretty much agree with your fire rating for all the above. However, both your rating and mine are subjective and not based on a universal consensus of what makes good or interesting music. Different people value different things.

Furthermore, the parameters are very different. You're not comparing like with like. 'A Kind of Blue' can't be held up against 'Sgt Pepper' and a winner chosen. That's like comparing Usain Bolt and Pele and declaring Bolt better.

TBH, your post had L written all over it from the moment you hit send.

2

Devayurtz t1_jaen27f wrote

Reply to comment by kp_centi in An album a day by The_Flying_Dog

What a wild thing to say. I understand where you’re coming from but pop music, the popular song, song form, and recorded music is inherently western. Sure it grew throughout the later half of the 20th century but to think that ANY list of pop music won’t be predominantly western is willfully ignorant.

0