Recent comments in /f/askscience

omgwtfbbqgrass t1_j2pb29x wrote

Reply to comment by Krail in How do galaxies move? by modsarebrainstems

It's not that gravity causes the expansion of space to stop, it's just that on relatively "small" scales we can safely ignore the expansion of space. Gravity still dominates even at the scale of galactic superclusters (for now). But increase the scale by comparing entities billions of light years away, and it's the expansion of space that dominates over gravity.

0

omgwtfbbqgrass t1_j2pb1nu wrote

Reply to comment by Krail in How do galaxies move? by modsarebrainstems

It's not that gravity causes the expansion of space to stop, it's just that on relatively "small" scales we can safely ignore the expansion of space. Gravity still dominates even at the scale of galactic superclusters (for now). But increase the scale by comparing entities billions of light years away, and it's the expansion of space that dominates over gravity.

10

Wroisu t1_j2p7dn0 wrote

Yes, but in the case that the universe is just the 3D surface of a hypersphere, it would also be expanding, expanding faster than you could move to come back all the way around again.

This is what Carl Sagan meant by “finite but unbounded”

1

Wroisu t1_j2p747l wrote

The 3D universe can be thought of as the surface of an expanding hypersphere. If the universe weren’t expanding, you could go all the way around and come back to where you started.

But since it’s expanding, you’ll never be able to move fast enough to come all the way back around again.

A “finite but unbounded universe”

−1