Recent comments in /f/askscience
maineac t1_j5ohv48 wrote
Reply to comment by alexm42 in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Thank you.
[deleted] t1_j5ohtv9 wrote
Reply to comment by cecex88 in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
[removed]
FootballImpossible38 t1_j5ohryp wrote
Reply to comment by Cobra800089 in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
thanks. i must have mis-read recent news articles that stated that the core had reversed its spin and was now spinning in the opposite direction. this implied to me that the field reversal must have already happened in short order and so we would have seen the effects of that weakening here on the surface.
Cobra800089 t1_j5oh81s wrote
Reply to comment by FootballImpossible38 in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Yes, and yes. The magnetic field has flipped before, and during the transition the magnetic field is very weak.
However IIRC it takes on the order of hundred to thousands of years, so probably not something we'll have to worry about. Although the timeline in the article OP is referring to seems to state it's happening faster than we previously thought. (IIRC, In the 90's the core was spinning faster than the planet, by 2009 it was spinning slower)
jabask t1_j5ogzt6 wrote
Reply to comment by mathologies in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
So if the oceans boil away, will the earth just become a smooth marble of rock with a bunch of fog over it?
[deleted] t1_j5ofwuk wrote
[deleted] t1_j5ofl2a wrote
[removed]
CrustalTrudger t1_j5oemhv wrote
Reply to comment by seeriktus in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
By far the two major sources of heat are primordial heat and radioactive decay. Changes in pressure can cause changes in temperature, but largely static pressure with depth does not generate heat. Tidal heating is not relevant for the Earth (though it's important for other planetary bodies in the solar system).
CrustalTrudger t1_j5oe1dg wrote
Reply to comment by dukesdj in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
This seems to ignore the literature stream suggesting that there is a fundamental hemispheric anisotropy of the inner core and that this may relate (in part) to the super-rotation of the inner core (e.g., Dumberry & Mound, 2011, Wazek et al., 2011, Deuss, 2014, Lythgoe et al., 2014, Yu et al., 2017, etc). Is that no longer valid?
[deleted] t1_j5oco15 wrote
[removed]
seeriktus t1_j5oced4 wrote
Reply to comment by BoIshevik in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
The moon is tidally locked so it always faces the earth, but the earth doesn't always face the moon. It rotates unequally to how the moon orbits. There is also drift between the number of orbits and the ultimate position the moon ends up in a year. One month is roughly equal to a lunar month, but not exactly.
BoIshevik t1_j5obutc wrote
Reply to comment by seeriktus in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Earth and the moon are tidally locked aren't they? Interesting answers here and I actually had some keywords to use too lol thank you.
GodEmperorBrian t1_j5obooj wrote
Reply to comment by willirritate in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Like, human extraction of oil? No, we don’t dig up anything that isn’t sitting in the crust of the earth. The mantle, sitting between the crust and the outer core, is something around 75x thicker than the crust. We have no impact on what happens to the core.
[deleted] t1_j5obidp wrote
Reply to comment by willirritate in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
[removed]
willirritate t1_j5ob7j2 wrote
Reply to comment by PerspectivePure2169 in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Does the extraction of oil take the lubricant out of the equation?
cecex88 t1_j5oatsj wrote
Reply to comment by maineac in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Nuclear reactions happening in the Earth are all radioactive decays. These produce heat, and it's in fact the main contribution (I've written another comment here with a bit more detail) but most of it happens in the continental Crust and in the Mantle.
This nuclear process is not generally dependent on pressure, in fact it mainly happens in the external layers of our planet. The distribution of radiogenic heat depends on where the element that may undergo beta-decay are located. If you are curious, the main elements responsible for this on Earth are Uranium, Thorium and Potassium.
Despite there being large uncertainty, geochemical studies show that these element are not much soluable in the liquid core. Radioactive decay contributes to the heat production in the core for 0.2 TW, while the the total amount of heat produced by the core is around 10-15 TW.
EDIT: well, not all nuclear reactions in the earth are decays. A few occurrences of natural fission reactions have been found, where particular conditions, like more abundance of a certain uranium isotope and different amount of oxygen in the atmosphere, made the fission reactions possible. The only few occurrences known happened in the far geological past in Oklo (region of Gabon).
seeriktus t1_j5oarvl wrote
Reply to comment by BoIshevik in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Heat retained from the formation of the earth, and compressive forces.
Insulation from the thick layers above.
Tidal heating - Continual squeezing and squashing of earths core by the moon orbiting around the earth. Though note that this doesn't occur with moons that are tidally locked.
Having a relatively warm surface from heating by the sun and thick atmosphere, though this is of lesser effect than say Venus. By having a warmer surface, the temperature differential is lessened, so less thermal energy moves across the gradient.
mxjuno t1_j5o9qej wrote
Reply to comment by MartiniBikini7777 in Do other animals have dangerous pregnancies just like humans? by Level_Shift_7516
Definitely heard of it. I haven’t had as much time as I like to respond to comments but the most efficient way to say this is that we have not been selecting for characteristics that will create conditions for more dangerous or difficult births in such a concentrated way.
We are selecting for babies and moms who will survive the process of gestation and birth, which has changed in a way more nuanced way (ie we have lost some ways of moving and feeding ourselves which create more dangerous birth conditions, and we have gained a lot of tools that have increased survival of pregnancy and birth). That won’t change the mortality rates of pregnancy and birth in a huge way within a few generations of c sections and other more modern interventions.
alexm42 t1_j5o9pyn wrote
Reply to comment by maineac in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Not caused by the pressure (that's what stars do and the Earth isn't one) but rather the heat of radioactive decay. It's also believed that tidal forces from the Moon create some heat.
[deleted] t1_j5o8y2u wrote
[removed]
maineac t1_j5o8q5e wrote
Reply to comment by cecex88 in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Aren't there continuous nuclear reactions also that help keep the heat going? Likely caused by the pressure.
mathologies t1_j5o8iud wrote
Reply to comment by BoIshevik in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Core is molten for two reasons:
Initial formation of Earth generated a lot of thermal energy, because a lot of stuff smashed together
Continued decay of radioisotopes has contributed additional thermal energy-- without this, the core would have cooled by now
Thermal energy is lost from the core through heat transfer to the mantle, which brings it to the crust by way of convection; this is what ultimately causes plate movement, earthquakes, volcanism, subduction, etc. on Earth. Once the core is cool enough that mantle convection stops, tectonic forces will subside and uplift processes will cease. From that point, weathering and erosion will gradually erase all land above sea level, giving us an ocean planet. I think the Sun will be hot enough to boil our oceans well before that happens, though (solar brightening over geologic time).
PlotRatio t1_j5o8h0c wrote
Reply to comment by silent_cat in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
Sure, I agree with all of that.
>Gravity causes the pressure. It’s the weight of everything above pressing down, which naturally increases the deeper you go which really isn't the case as no work is being done.
I just read the above as suggesting that a static pressure will result in an increase in temp.
Implausibilibuddy t1_j5o6ohb wrote
Reply to comment by Aethyx_ in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
> the pressurised can analogy kind of works if you scale it up?
It did 4 billion years ago when the debris in our Sun's accretion disk coalesced to form our planet, and again when whatever planet sized object hit us to form our Moon, but since then we've been cooling off like a pot of old coffee. Fortunately there's a lot of mass left to cool off, and it's stored in the best Thermos ever created...
spec2re t1_j5oiof2 wrote
Reply to comment by PerspectivePure2169 in What are the forces on Earth’s Inner Core that change its speed? by BayRunner
The sun. Electromagnetic forces of our nearest massive fusion generation body are very strong and affect all kinds of things in our planet including earthquakes, weather, and... Rotation speed.