Recent comments in /f/askscience
StuartGotz t1_j6devtz wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in What makes it difficult to determine whether nutrient deficiencies are implicated in mental-health issues like ADHD? by LinguisticsTurtle
This is an important philosophical issue. There are 4 Ds in whether something is diagnosed or considered a dsiorder:
- Deviance: Varying from the norm, the average of society. This is useful in come situation, like diagnosing memory decline in possible Alzheimer's disease. However, by itself it can overemphasize conformity, which is a problem.
- Distress - Is what the person,s experiencing creating some kind of distress or suffering. People used to think of schizophrenia as a “sane response to an insane world”, but really they are suffering horribly as a result of this.
- Dysfunction - Does it interfere with a person's ability to get through their day, support themselves, accomplish the things they would like to accomplish.
- Dangerousness - This is more of a consideration in forensic settings
ADHD is a spectrum on which we all fall, but the extreme cases that are diagnosed meet the distress and dysfunction criteria.
Choosyhealer16 t1_j6deqgy wrote
Reply to comment by Beginning_Cat_4972 in where does epinephrine comes from? The one used for people with allergies because Google only says It comes from glands so I don't understand if it's donated or sintethized by other means. by SALAMI_21
Ah, thanks for the info! I reckon it's wasteful due to the energy used to incinerate animals and the amount of animals wasted due to the process?
gingerbread_man123 t1_j6de29l wrote
Reply to comment by kolyambrus in What makes it difficult to determine whether nutrient deficiencies are implicated in mental-health issues like ADHD? by LinguisticsTurtle
There are two aspects to his statement:
-
ASD/ADHD are neurodevelopmental rather than mental health issues. Substantively provable
-
ASD/ADHD is mostly genetic. I agree with you that we're not yet in a position to discard all environment factors.
Using the term "mental health" isn't appropriate in this context. General treatments for mental health conditions (CBT, antidepressants etc) have almost no overlap with treatments for neurodevelopmental disorders, unless there is a comorbidity that leads to separate mental health issues.
[deleted] t1_j6ddz0i wrote
Reply to comment by cervicalgrdle in Has a new animal species evolved since mankind’s existence? by coding_ac
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j6dd8y6 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Has a new animal species evolved since mankind’s existence? by coding_ac
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j6dcxjp wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in What makes it difficult to determine whether nutrient deficiencies are implicated in mental-health issues like ADHD? by LinguisticsTurtle
[removed]
eldude2879 t1_j6dcsew wrote
Reply to comment by piklester in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
this was back in the day when booti killed a few every year
many things were different, back then they said the children are the future
we were so clever with computers and stuff
nobody says that anymore, kids are dum as rocks
SleepyHead32 t1_j6dco7b wrote
Reply to comment by Hot_Flan1220 in What makes it difficult to determine whether nutrient deficiencies are implicated in mental-health issues like ADHD? by LinguisticsTurtle
Plenty of other mental health issues have a genetic component lol. ADHD is a mental health issue, spoken as someone who has it.
PBlueKan t1_j6dc98y wrote
Reply to comment by lordbubax in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
No. One of the most common pathways infants are infected with C. botulinum spores is through honey.
The bacteria goes dormant in spores which are incredibly hard to kill. Sugar has nothing to do with it.
[deleted] t1_j6dbwxr wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Has a new animal species evolved since mankind’s existence? by coding_ac
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j6dbvf7 wrote
Reply to comment by Mammoth-Corner in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
[deleted]
piklester t1_j6dbtc6 wrote
Reply to comment by eldude2879 in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
Assuming it was an unopened can, freezing it could cause the can to 'explode' . You see it happen with drink cans a lot because of the thinner material and the carbonation in lots of drinks but it can happen with any sealed liquids without room to expand.
https://youtu.be/t5mdZD00POs this guy demonstrates it by freezing a sealed pipe with liquid nitrogen to spread up the process
[deleted] t1_j6dbnra wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in What makes it difficult to determine whether nutrient deficiencies are implicated in mental-health issues like ADHD? by LinguisticsTurtle
[removed]
Gerryislandgirl t1_j6db47r wrote
Reply to comment by marmosetohmarmoset in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
I just want to point out that an infant given antibiotics is at greater risk.
[deleted] t1_j6dajgo wrote
Reply to comment by pathoj3nn in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j6d9hu9 wrote
Reply to comment by pzzia02 in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
[removed]
eldude2879 t1_j6d88tl wrote
Reply to comment by Mammoth-Corner in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
I sorta remember putting a plastic bag over can as child and putting in the cooler and I got scolded like I was a terrorist gonna take out the whole block
this was a real fear
[deleted] t1_j6d7y1b wrote
Reply to comment by pathoj3nn in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
[removed]
kkngs t1_j6d7qz7 wrote
Reply to comment by Hot_Flan1220 in What makes it difficult to determine whether nutrient deficiencies are implicated in mental-health issues like ADHD? by LinguisticsTurtle
ADHD doesn’t go away when you each adulthood. It’s a mental health disorder. “Mental Health” includes having access to medical treatment for underlying mental disorders.
Most mental health disorders don’t have cures, just treatments.
[deleted] t1_j6d7ca5 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
[removed]
ilovemybrownies t1_j6d76m0 wrote
Reply to comment by SerialStateLineXer in What makes it difficult to determine whether nutrient deficiencies are implicated in mental-health issues like ADHD? by LinguisticsTurtle
It wouldn't be as airtight of an experiment to show causality, especially since again no evidence points to vitamin deficits being a direct mechanism. You'd probably have to track prenatal health, and you'd have to measure known genetic ADHD markers to account for ADHD being highly genetic when running statistical analyses.
But good luck getting the cash to fund it if there isn't already compelling evidence that vitamin deficit is directly linked to ADHD. Investors usually don't like "taking risks for the sake of exploration" unfortunately
[deleted] t1_j6d758w wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j6d6y3c wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
[deleted]
[deleted] t1_j6d6w9q wrote
Reply to comment by lordbubax in Why can an adult’s GI tract expel C. botulinum spores while an infant can’t? by curiousnboredd
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j6dfmp9 wrote
Reply to What makes it difficult to determine whether nutrient deficiencies are implicated in mental-health issues like ADHD? by LinguisticsTurtle
[removed]