Recent comments in /f/askscience
[deleted] t1_jabdsxb wrote
sir_jamez t1_jabcnhu wrote
Reply to comment by fletch44 in Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
Could have evolved to be an environmental variable?
Like when sea turtles lay a clutch of eggs in the sand, the ones closer to the surface sand might be warmer, the ones in the middle might be warmer, ones that hatch closer to dawn might be warmer, etc.
Might just allow for randomness in the sex mix of any individual batch of eggs, that gets smoothed out by the variation across any breeding season.
amador9 t1_jabcer8 wrote
Reply to comment by MrinkysAnimalSide in Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
No “y” chromosomes in fish?
PatrickKieliszek t1_jabbvo8 wrote
Reply to comment by Ieatadapoopoo in Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
One thing about adaptations is that one mutation away from the parent needs to be at least as good if not better than other siblings.
If it's going to take three generations of mutations to get to an advantage, they probably won't make it.
[deleted] t1_jab9iu8 wrote
Ieatadapoopoo t1_jab9bkv wrote
Reply to comment by fletch44 in Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
Is it an advantage or just “this happened to work out slightly better than the alternatives present at the time”? It’s mostly randomness and a matter of “not so awful it’s untenable” which, over billions of iterations, tends to end up somewhat efficient. To assume that something happens purely because it’s advantageous in a general sense doesn’t really work though. I mean, look at human nasal passages. Horrible, but not so bad it’s untenable.
Edit: to be clear, I say this only to mean that it’s not inherently going to be a logical conclusion we can easily discern. I’m mostly supporting your point.
rogert2 t1_jab8o2e wrote
Reply to comment by Gravemonera in Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
Clownfish are one such fish. Another species is mentioned in the BBC Earth series, but I'm afraid I don't recall the name or even which episode.
redditor50613 t1_jab6af0 wrote
Reply to comment by Gravemonera in Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
When researching how to sex my pseudomugil illuminatus fry, i came across this article, which talks about one person's experience with different temps. https://www.pvas.com/forum/breeder-s-award-program/spawning-report-pseudomugil-luminatus-red-neon-blue-eyes
MrinkysAnimalSide t1_jab5vz6 wrote
Reply to Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
Temperature dependent sex determination is fascinating! Just remember, mammals and birds use chromosomal sex determination (meaning sex is genetic) but other mechanisms are quite common across all organisms! Check out the cool graphs at tree of sex http://treeofsex.org/.
There is still a lot of work left to be done on mechanisms of how temperature during incubation leads to different sex ratios. This is a good scientific review on red-eared sliders https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2695493/. The ultimate mechanisms, or why temperature sex determination occurs, is also an interesting evolutionary question. Here is a good starting point for further research: https://sites.utexas.edu/crewslab/files/2016/06/CrewsDVLGen.pdf.
Finally, it’s important to remember that sex is a complex phenotype with many components and is really a shorthand for biologists to describe a common suite of traits. But thanks to sweet, sweet variation there is no one size fits all! In fact, it’s not uncommon for sex to be broken down into at least 5 levels of animal sexuality but that’s just the beginning. Not to mention human-specific levels, such as gender. Just a fun aside, the genderbread person is a nice primer on gender https://www.genderbread.org/
[deleted] t1_jab5urc wrote
Reply to comment by Snatch_Pastry in Is there a genetic disease where the heterozygote has more severe disease symptoms than the homozygote? by Altranite-
[removed]
[deleted] t1_jab4902 wrote
[deleted] OP t1_jab38l2 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_jab37kq wrote
[deleted] t1_jaaycab wrote
fletch44 t1_jaaxck5 wrote
Reply to Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
Temperature affects the rate of chemical reactions.
Complex biological pathways result in more or less of particular hormones being produced at different temperatures. This is useful in cold-blooded organisms, because if the chemistry of some biological function tends to shut down beyond a particular temperature threshold, the organism can incorporate other biological systems that kick in to replace it.
The advantage of having offspring's sex affected in such a way is open to discussion.
Gravemonera t1_jaavr5t wrote
Reply to Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
Many species of fish do this, in that the temperature will determine the sex of the eggs. Some fish species will also change sexes depending on environmental pressures. Unfortunately I don’t have sources on this for you at the moment.
[deleted] t1_jaavlv4 wrote
marieterna t1_jaasxym wrote
Reply to Is there a genetic disease where the heterozygote has more severe disease symptoms than the homozygote? by Altranite-
Fatal Familial Insomnia (FFI) is a genetic disorder caused by a mutation in the PRNP gene. The PRNP gene codes for the prion protein, thought to be involved in copper signaling and cell adhesion. For the mutation itself, at position 178, asparagine (N) replaces the wild type aspartic acid (D); D178N is the correct notation. However, what determines if someone shows the pathology of FFI or familial Cruetzfeldt-Jakob (fCJD), depends on another position on the mRNA that’s translated. The D178N mutation must be coupled with a methionine at position 129; this site is the valine/methionine polymorphism site.
Homozygotes at codon 129 show a shorter disease duration, more severe insomnia, and the disease is mostly restricted to the thalamus.
Heterozygous at codon 129 show a longer disease course and other symptoms, such as ataxia and dysarthria; the disease is not restricted to the thalamus, and can spread to other parts of the brain, such as the cerebral cortex.
[deleted] t1_jaao2dc wrote
Reply to comment by Cute_Consideration38 in Is it true the humans could breathe and live in the atmosphere of Venus? by Impossible_Mine_1616
[removed]
MaygeKyatt t1_jaaccl4 wrote
Reply to comment by Germanofthebored in Is there a genetic disease where the heterozygote has more severe disease symptoms than the homozygote? by Altranite-
It’s just a problem with the interactions between cells, it sounds like. You’re correct, X Inactivation virtually completely disables one X chromosome, it just happens after cells have divided several times, so some clusters of the developing embryo have one X chromosome while other clusters have the other chromosome.
Droopy1592 t1_jaa720x wrote
Reply to comment by jubears09 in Is there a genetic disease where the heterozygote has more severe disease symptoms than the homozygote? by Altranite-
This is so damn interesting. I would have never seen anything like this in my normal studies. I never would have thought heterozygous could be worse.
Retepss t1_jaa6xnx wrote
Reply to comment by Goldenslicer in How is radioactive dating used to determine historical greenhouse gas levels and temperatures? by pog_irl
There are lots of clues. One of the simpler ones is counting seasons. I've only seen ice cores from the Arctic, which don't go as far back, but just looking at them you can tell summer ice from winter ice. Counting the layers give you years. There are also more accurate ways to measure the difference (you can look into what delta 18Oxygen means).
You will lose count if there was a period where summers got warm enough to melt more ice than was formed during the winter, but you can then use the other methods to try and correct for that.
Even so, being of by a 100 years isn't too bad when you are counting 100000.
angradillo t1_jaa6oi7 wrote
Reply to comment by wanna_be_doc in What is the origin of Ebola? by suckmymastercylinder
More terrifying. Ebola Zaire had a 90% case fatality rate when discovered.
[deleted] t1_jaa44ns wrote
Reply to comment by zk3033 in Is there a genetic disease where the heterozygote has more severe disease symptoms than the homozygote? by Altranite-
[removed]
ke_marshall t1_jabe17i wrote
Reply to comment by amador9 in Why does temperature determine the sex of certain egg laying animals like crocodiles? by insink2300
It depends on the species. Some have them, some don't: https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article/figures?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.1001899
My favorite fun fact is that sex determination in birds is exactly opposite to mammals: the females are heterogametic. They are ZW, while males are ZZ.