Recent comments in /f/askscience
imyourzer0 t1_je3zxzb wrote
Reply to comment by adamginsburg in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
I recall reading elsewhere that the elements themselves (not compounds, per se) are distributed throughout the observable universe according to Zipf’s law (or something like it), so that they get less common as the atomic number increases. So, would it be a reasonable extrapolation to estimate compounds’ prevalence, then, by the chemical reactivities of their forming elements?
[deleted] t1_je3z5wq wrote
Reply to comment by MurkyPerspective767 in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
[removed]
craftsycandymonster t1_je3yzl7 wrote
Reply to comment by creepcrank in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
[deleted] t1_je3yeh7 wrote
Flimsy_Repeat2532 t1_je3xvo9 wrote
Reply to comment by ObligatoryOption in Why are there multiple species of various life forms, but humans only have one? Are there other complex single-species organisms? by CyberOGa3
One definition of species is that they can't interbreed with fertile offspring.
But in many cases, they are distinct because they live too far apart.
It seems that lions and tigers can interbreed, but normally live too far apart.
The offspring, ligers and tigrons, depending on which one is the mom and which is the dad. But humans have spread all over the world.
Otherwise, we have carefully defined species such that there is only one of us!
creepcrank t1_je3vu43 wrote
Reply to comment by AllHailCapitalism in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
Sounds like fun, source?
[deleted] t1_je3vob5 wrote
Reply to comment by adamginsburg in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
[removed]
MurkyPerspective767 t1_je3vfmy wrote
Reply to comment by adamginsburg in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
Are all salts NaCl? I was under the assumption that salts were a family of compounds, of which NaCl is merely the most common?
[deleted] t1_je3vbkt wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_je3uy49 wrote
Reply to comment by AllHailCapitalism in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
[removed]
AllHailCapitalism t1_je3unss wrote
Reply to comment by low_altitude_sherpa in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
Reminds me of the story where a woman has a discussion with some guy at a conference. He mansplains to her that her theory is wrong, and she should really read a recent publication on the subject by X, who is considered a top authority in the field. She then tells the guy to take a look at her badge, because she's X.
[deleted] t1_je3tupw wrote
Reply to comment by adamginsburg in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
[removed]
[deleted] t1_je3sf7e wrote
Reply to comment by adamginsburg in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
[removed]
[deleted] t1_je3sa3t wrote
Reply to comment by low_altitude_sherpa in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
[removed]
[deleted] t1_je3qmpw wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_je3qdbd wrote
Reply to comment by kompootor in Do large language models effectively compress their training dataset? by samyall
[removed]
low_altitude_sherpa t1_je3q35h wrote
Reply to comment by icansmellcolors in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
Now we need some armchair scientist to tell him he is wrong, citing his own paper.
[deleted] t1_je3op0k wrote
Reply to comment by Paaaaap in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
[removed]
platoprime t1_je3oiud wrote
Reply to comment by Gutsy_Bottle in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
It is absolutely insane the amount of information that can be extracted from the "color" of incoming light. They're talking about trying to see the light from a distant star but not just any light. Specifically they are looking for light from that distant star when it passes through the atmosphere of a planet orbiting that star. The difference between that light and the light of the star can tell you about the chemical composition of the planet's atmosphere.
Aggravating_Paint_44 t1_je3nw38 wrote
Reply to comment by adamginsburg in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
Would it be fair to say that you see it where you can and at rates you’d expect but don’t want to extrapolate because of the lack of direct evidence.
InterestedListener t1_je3n20j wrote
Reply to comment by adamginsburg in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
I just want to say you are incredibly smart and I really enjoy reading your explanations even though a lot of it is over my head. Thank you for sharing so much!
[deleted] t1_je3n0np wrote
Reply to comment by StupidPencil in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
[removed]
Welpe t1_je3mau9 wrote
Reply to comment by I_eat_staplers in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
Scales get weird in physics. A week or two ago I was explaining just how cold helium needs to be to display superfluidity and ended up describing something like 25K as “balmy”, which it is compared to 2.1K or whatever it was for helium.
Paaaaap t1_je3m2p8 wrote
Reply to comment by zarrel40 in Is NaCl relatively common in the galaxy/universe? by PHealthy
Well... still stars but not with conventional fusion, they happen during much more extreme events such as supernovae explosion
mfb- t1_je40csp wrote
Reply to comment by pewpewbrrrrrrt in How does an ideal vacuum have a dielectric breakdown voltage of 10^12 MV/m? If there is nothing there, then how can electricity pass through it? by skovalen
You can have an electric field strength of zero, that is commonly called "no electric field". You could argue that zero is the strength of the existing field, but that's just semantics. In practice you won't achieve a field strength of exactly zero, of course, but that's just an experimental limit.