Recent comments in /f/books

ehuang72 t1_j2f84zz wrote

It’s the same answer I’d give to - why do I read any book? It makes no difference whether it’s fiction or non-fiction. I never think to myself, I’m in the mood for whatever. Just whatever strikes me as interesting at the moment. I’m actually surprised by the question and by anyone who can answer it.

Edit: As if you can’t escape into non-fiction and you can’t learn stuff from fiction.

27

Raindrops_On-Roses OP t1_j2f7gz6 wrote

Reply to comment by ehuang72 in Firefly Lane by Raindrops_On-Roses

I mean, if I immediately decided I didn't like it on page one, I wouldn't care. The issue is you can't really know if you'll enjoy it that soon, and by the time I'm like, "this is irredeemable," it's too late, lol. So essentially, the first page, I guess.

1

Hadespuppy t1_j2f7c48 wrote

Absolutely. An adaptation is an adaptation, there are always going to be changes when you translate a work to an entirely new medium. A direct point for point translation almost never works. And you have to consider the audience, which is again going to be different from that of the original.

All media is a product of the cultural context in which it was produced. Even the most faithful adaptation still reflects those choices, and what the creators were trying to say. So an adaptation that updates some things and shifts a few others around in order to both make it a watchable product and to make it palatable and relevant to a modern audience is both something to be expected, and probably a better show than one that fails to consider either of those things.

1

CleaverHand t1_j2f7b0f wrote

Finished it this morning! Took me a bit to get in to but I enjoyed it. As for the title it references Hig making up his own constellation and naming it Jasper. It’s a very subtle maybe two sentence explanation on the last page or two.

3

George_Askeladd t1_j2f76kd wrote

It's so annoying because it's so damn predictable and boring. In every of the last 8 thrillers I read, the romance always followed the same scheme. First the protagonist falls in love with the first pretty girl he sees, she rejects him and he's pissed and then he falls in love with the not so beautiful but mysterious girl that somehow opens up to him very quickly. Usually she has a bad backstory too and pretends to be tough but after they get together, she's super vulnerable. Only exception I saw was when the protagonist not only fell in love with the mysterious tough girl but also with his damn teacher. It's annoying when the good story is getting ruined by the forced romance. Why can't the protagonist be single or at least have an unpredictable love story. As soon as that kind of girl is introduced, I immediately know she's going to be his love interest. Sooo boring...

2

ehuang72 t1_j2f752w wrote

LOL - how much of a book do you need to have read that makes you feel I MUST FINISH!!

I lied before, I still feel the need to finish but these days I only feel that way if I’ve read like at least half.

1

-1_2_3 t1_j2f6yk8 wrote

CORRECTION: per PeterAhlstrom “It’s significantly lower than 45% of retail when you use a credit” end correction

As a customer of libro my only complaint is getting sucked into the monthly credits & then I learned from Brandon Sanderson’s team libro only gives authors 45%.

Could you offer instruction how to link the comment here? I’m not sure how to do it.

Edit: “Unfortunately, Libro.FM pays a very low royalty (based on the retail price) when you use a credit. That makes sense when you set the retail price high, but not when we set it at $15 because that's what people actually pay. So we (I'm Brandon's VP of publishing) had to pass on listing the books on Libro.FM. If they change their royalty for cheap books we'll happily change that.” From /u/peterahlstrom

6

Raindrops_On-Roses OP t1_j2f6uhg wrote

Reply to comment by ehuang72 in Firefly Lane by Raindrops_On-Roses

That's the thing, though. I know I'm not getting anything out of it simply because I'm not enjoying it. It just feels like something I NEED to do. It doesn't feel like a choice. If I have a book that I've started and haven't finished, it gnaws at me like a sink full of dishes. Idk why, but it sucks, lmao. The bright side is that I'm a fast reader, always have been. So, at least it doesn't take me too long. The worst was The Shining. I despised that book! I found it soooo boring. I was losing my mind!

1

HobGoodfellowe t1_j2f6rxn wrote

I'm in the middle of re-reading Lord of the Rings at the moment. It's been about a decade between each re-read. What I find fascinating about the book is how I've taken away very different (but enjoyable) experiences each time I've read it.

Reading it as a teenager, the excitement and adventure dominated, and I was probably more interested in characters like Frodo and Aragorn. As I've aged, I've found more depth in the book, more complexity... and eventually come to see Sam as more interesting and heroic than I ever did as a teenager.

It's just interesting to me how much the book has different things to say, depending on one's life experience when reading it.

2