Recent comments in /f/books

WartimeHotTot t1_j4eyfu9 wrote

It’s crazy to me how many people in this subreddit go absolutely gaga for this book. To me, it was perfectly fine, but utterly forgettable. Just a silly little story about a guy and a silly little spider creature. But every week someone posts about how it was a life-changing book.

8

hajenso t1_j4esb69 wrote

That last sentence was similar to my immediate thought after finishing the story just now: Never mind the ones who walk away from Omelas, why aren’t there ones who attempt Scapegoat-Child-Rescue Crimes in Omelas? This to me is a major practical problem with the conceit: There could never be a society 100% free of violence and oppression but for a single scapegoat whose suffering is known and accepted by all, because there would always be a few who would try to wreck the bargain by direct action, and now we have a conflict which motivates violence.

One could say "It's part of the premise that nobody decides to do that." But:

  1. The story already concedes that not everybody accepts the bargain; that's the entire point of having ones who walk away. What's stopping some of them from dealing with those same feelings by willfully violating the rules (child rescue attempt; attempt to remove the scary mops), instead of walking away? I see nothing except possibly authorial fiat.
  2. If the beings in this story include not even a tiny minority of individuals who attempt a rescue of any kind, then this story is about a different species, not ours.
1

Not_l0st OP t1_j4equua wrote

If only my book club would read faster 🙎 I do need a new side book. My preferred way of reading is via audio books and often after I finish a good book I'll spend a day or two listening to music instead of 'read'. I need something familiar while I am in the post-book melancholy before I can get to know new characters and stories. I'm definitely going to be the person who listens to certain books over and over again to fill this void.

3

ruin-and-rising t1_j4ce935 wrote

I almost exclusively read in English, but it is not my native language and - same as you - I’m reading on a slightly slower pace than when reading in my native one. I think it’s completely normal to read slower if it’s not your native language. (Also shoutout to you for not seeing reading as a competition. I have to remind myself of that often enough when seeing others, mostly native speakers, flying through mindblowing amount of books.) As long as you have fun, everything is fine 😊

1