Recent comments in /f/books
prss79513 t1_j5u5iux wrote
Reply to Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
ABC murders is still my favorite
lokilady1 t1_j5u5gts wrote
Reply to comment by Purdaddy in Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
Start at the beginning
Grace_Alcock t1_j5u4uv5 wrote
Reply to comment by OhSoManyQuestions in Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
It’s not just the period. If you read other Golden Age mysteries, she stands out as particularly racist and classist.
Grace_Alcock t1_j5u4mjj wrote
Reply to comment by FigFromHell in Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
In her 20s books, she uses the n word and about half a dozen variations on anti-semitism. Not to mention the classism, or the fact that adoptive parents and children are almost invariably evil or insane. She’s pretty awful—and worse than a lot of her contemporaries were, in fact. But her books are so damned skillfully written that I still love them. I just don’t like HER much.
brynnecognito t1_j5u4h3g wrote
Reply to comment by Kenobi_01 in Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
We read ATTWN in grade 9 and it still haunts me, I loved it so much. That’s when I fell I love with mystery
Bagpuss45 t1_j5u4f8y wrote
Reply to Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
And then there was none and Murder on the Orient Express are the 2 greatest pieces of crime fiction ever written.. followed closely by the ABC murders...
KINGGS t1_j5u3afj wrote
Reply to comment by __DraGooN_ in Rereading Russian Classics in the Shadow of the Ukraine War by zsreport
You wrote a lot for someone who couldn’t have possibly read the article.
scolfin OP t1_j5u15h9 wrote
Reply to comment by Rick_101 in The People Who Don’t Read Books by scolfin
And, of course, a lot of monsters were voracious readers. Stalin was particularly famous for his library and throughput.
That said, the three people in question weren't exactly proclaiming other avenues of high-quality thought, but we both know how differently people react to anything openly castigating the young women who take pride in consuming social media or YA instead of literary or analytical works.
lucia-pacciola t1_j5u0lm9 wrote
Reply to How do you read non fiction books? by Retep_Rup
Depends on the book.
Reference books: I read what I want, when I want. That's the point.
Textbooks: Chapter by chapter. First, I skim the section headings of the chapter, to get a sense of what the chapter is about and how it's developing the ideas and concepts. Then I skim again, but with more attention to the sidenotes, figures, and other supplementary material. Then I go back and skim each paragraph. This is where I start making notes, relating what jumps out at me in each paragraph to the themes established by my previous skims. Then, I go back and read some or all of the chapter paragraphs in detail. Finally, if the book includes quizzes or study prompts, I read those, compare them against my notes, and decide if I need to re-read the chapter to pick up something I may have missed.
Histories other than textbooks (biographies, popular histories, etc.): I read them just like fiction. Beginning to end, as a linear narrative.
SonnyCalzone t1_j5u0dxg wrote
Reply to Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
During my late teens and early twenties, I was easily a bigger fan of Agatha Christie's works than any of my so-called peers who also fancied themselves as readers-for-pleasure (very different from the readers-for-academia, I might add.)
Death On The Nile was a book I always refrained from reading because I had already seen the 1978 film adaptation (incredible cast including Peter Ustinov as Hercule Poirot) and the film had always been satisfying enough for me. I really ought to just pick up that damn book already. I think it's been long enough. Evil Under The Sun falls into that same category for me, for the same reasons. I ought to read that too.
And Then There Were None remains my favorite of her books, and I also greatly enjoyed Cards On The Table. Highly recommended.
scolfin OP t1_j5u02aq wrote
Reply to comment by BairnONessie in The People Who Don’t Read Books by scolfin
Basically, he's writing how books are the only worthwhile form of the humanities in a respected journal of thought with a strong history of literary, philosophical, and analytical output.
The second part is that he seems oddly hostile toward the idea that altruism should be judged by what it does for the world, which may be because it very much discounts the benefit of a monastic lifestyle of self-sacrifice, which is how academics often see themselves.
_PrincessOats t1_j5tzzra wrote
Reply to comment by dumbdotcom in Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
Being fair, that was only the US title.
Rick_101 t1_j5tzzol wrote
Reply to The People Who Don’t Read Books by scolfin
This is a complex topic, reading extends beyond books. And even then a lot of great people achieved and achieve immeasurable things without reading a whole lot.
_PrincessOats t1_j5tzusf wrote
Reply to comment by PapaBear12 in Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
I just read And Then Were None as my first Christie book and I was absolutely blown away by it. Cannot recommend enough. I’ll be tackling Poirot novels next but wanted to start with a standalone.
scolfin OP t1_j5tz5d1 wrote
Reply to comment by tedyasso in The People Who Don’t Read Books by scolfin
More noting an interesting implication in the premise and an oddly vitriolic aside about something basically everyone else would say is harmless at worst.
cookerg t1_j5tz1bj wrote
Reply to comment by Purdaddy in Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
I don't have a firm recommendation. I just think the Roger Ackroyd book and Poirot's Last Case in particular, were written after she had amassed a following who were very familiar with her books, and she had honed her craft. So personally I would go roughly in chronological order even though each book is independent with no overarching story line.
LizzyWednesday t1_j5ty6of wrote
Reply to comment by yt-_spark_-yt in Can anyone help me by yt-_spark_-yt
Folks with learning disabilities, especially folks in environments where there's a lot of shame associated with "different," get really good at masking symptoms & struggles.
It's way easier when you're younger (elementary/grammar school age; not sure what the term would be in your country) but as the work gets more difficult, your old coping skills and masking techniques start to fall apart.
You're not stupid; your brain just works differently.
Getting diagnosed really should help you figure out how to work with the way your brain works; no shame, just support.
Dismal-Canaryz t1_j5txycd wrote
Reply to Just finished The Silent Patient and have only one nagging question… *contains spoilers* by playboypink
I did notice a few holes or cheesy moments in this book, but overall enjoyed reading it.
I took this moment as Jean-Felix trying to isolate Alicia and keep her reliant on him as a support system. I didn't think he new Gabriel was cheating or anything at this point.
SonnyCalzone t1_j5txj6q wrote
Reply to comment by Kenobi_01 in Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
LoL it certainly led to a fun film called THE CONDEMNED starring Stone Cold Steve Austin and Vinnie Jones.
LizzyWednesday t1_j5txez9 wrote
Reply to How do you read non fiction books? by Retep_Rup
It depends on the type of nonfic I'm reading; I don't often take notes, but sometimes I'll snap photos of paragraphs that strike me as especially relevant - I did this several times while reading books about the 1918 Influenza pandemic (or I will annotate them on a re-read if it's a purchased/personal copy, like my Mary Roach books) - and text or share them with friends on social media.
For me, the best way to remember what I've read is to talk (or type!) about it with other people, either folks who've read the same book or friends I'm trying to convince to read it, because I connect my excitement about something cool/interesting/maddening I learnt from the book to that conversation.
Oh, and I read some nonfic at a much slower rate than I read fiction, so it may take me months-and-months to finish a "heavy" subject with a lot of technical language but I'll blow through a 400pp novel in like a day. I don't worry; I don't judge.
joejoefashosho t1_j5txex2 wrote
Reply to comment by PapaBear12 in Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
Many consider this to be a proto-slasher story.
BairnONessie t1_j5twqzv wrote
Reply to comment by scolfin in The People Who Don’t Read Books by scolfin
It must be too late cause I'm not making head, nor tail, of anything you wrote...
tedyasso t1_j5twlre wrote
Reply to comment by scolfin in The People Who Don’t Read Books by scolfin
So you posted a link to an article about people who don't like to read books, and then took the time out of your day to take a shit all over the article's writer and his career choice to be a writer because you disagree with one of his points? Fascinating. *slow clap*
scolfin OP t1_j5tuk1f wrote
Reply to The People Who Don’t Read Books by scolfin
I will say that it's deeply ironic for this argument that books are the reading format of record taking the form of an essay in The Atlantic Monthly, although to say that would be an admission that I should probably subscribe to Ploughshares like I've been planning to for several years (they had just finished selling a bundle with several other journals I'm interested in when I last checked and haven't had another these last few years).
There's also remarkable vitriol for effective altruism buried in the later part of the essay, which I somewhat suspect is due to his identifying his low-paid career providing privileged young adults with lessons in recreation as his main form of altruism.
Wonderful-Elk5080 t1_j5u5y6o wrote
Reply to Death on the Nile by Agatha Christie by starrynight179
Agatha Christie is one of my favourite authors, and 'Death on the Nile' is one of my favourite books of hers! :) I'm glad you like it. Some of my other favourites are 'The Murder of Roger Ackroyd', 'Murder in Mesopotamia' and 'Murder at the Vicarage' (this one is a Miss Marple book). Definitely recommend you read any book written by her though :)