Recent comments in /f/books
Transformwthekitchen t1_j691lol wrote
Reply to comment by angelojann in Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
More like countries where close relationships between unmarried men and women are socially unacceptable. Middle east, india etx
stile99 t1_j691ae3 wrote
Reply to Seeking passage to use for Eulogy from Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. by cavillchallenger
Just as long as it ends with "he was a hoopy frood who really knew where his towel was".
Drag0nfly_Girl t1_j690yao wrote
Reply to comment by DeusExLibrus in Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
You're correct, but missing an important factor: there was no need to be "obsessed with not being perceived as gay" in Dickens' time, because homosexuality was closeted and considered unacceptable. Affection between men wasn't sexualized.
Fear of being perceived as gay only became an issue with the increasing visibility of homosexuality & its gradual social acceptance. Normal affection between boys was sexualized. The visibility of homosexuality had a direct negative effect on the expression of intimacy & affection between heterosexual men, just as it also put a damper on things like girlfriends holding hands while they walk (something I remember being normal & common when I was a kid but which gradually ceased when girls started getting called lesbians for doing so).
The sexualization of same-sex affection is what killed it.
BigBoxOfGooglyEyes t1_j690n5v wrote
Reply to comment by History_fangirl in 1st case by James Patterson are all his books like this? by History_fangirl
You'll have to wait until March for what I'm sure is a riveting story of an elephant learning important life skills. Toddlers will be on the edge of their potties.
I will say that his method of having ghost writers that get credit on the cover seems to help aspiring authors get a foot in the door because I've noticed a lot of them go on to publish their own books.
angelojann OP t1_j690m54 wrote
Reply to comment by zumera in Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
Which cultures are still open with physical affection between men? I guess in some European countries?
Amariel777 t1_j690kjz wrote
Reply to Seeking passage to use for Eulogy from Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. by cavillchallenger
Possible conclusion: "Dad, on behalf of all of us down here we'd just like to say: 'We apologize for the inconvenience.' "
​
Also, condolences on your loss.
julien_et_mathilde t1_j690hhn wrote
Reply to comment by L1zar9 in Caste, Society and Politics in India, by Susan Bayly by tolkienfan2759
Of course you wouldn't expect an equal number of mixed race marriages as intraracial ones. You would, however, expect a high percentage of the minority group to eventually be married to partners outside of their group. We see this with Jews in the West, who marry non-Jews at high rates now that religious rigor is relaxing and anti-Jewish sentiment is less normal.
Insularity is common among immigrants, but it normally does not last more than a few generations due to assimilation. The exceptions seem to happen when the group is legally made into a racial underclass or when insularity is a tenet of the group's religion.
angelojann OP t1_j690hds wrote
Reply to comment by Thornescape in Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
I agree with this. I also don't 100% believe that "Men/women are wired to act the way they do because of (biological) reason"
What people fail to realize is that cultural norms have greatly shaped the way we think too.
zumera t1_j690dh8 wrote
Reply to Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
There are still many cultures in the world where non-sexual/non-romantic physical affection between men is commonplace. Some Western cultures have just lost that aspect of platonic male relationships.
TheJester0330 t1_j69079u wrote
Reply to comment by jimmbolina in What is the meaning of the depth Patrick Bateman goes into about music in American Psycho? by ChairmanUzamaoki
I disagree, his opinions on the music are shallow, and often miss the point. To use Hip to Be Square, Patrick sees it as a song about conformity, about how it's better to fit in then be an individual or buck the status quo.
Huey Lewis wrote the song satirically, it's meant to make fun if "squares" as it comments are people losing what makes them unique. Patrick doesn't understand this though because like everything ss he can only understand the surface level interpretation
[deleted] t1_j6905mk wrote
Thornescape t1_j69032j wrote
Reply to comment by angelojann in Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
It's one thing that I often think about when people go off saying, "All men/women like (thing) because that's just how they have always been wired."
Okay, that would only be true if it was true across all cultures, for all of history. Typically it's something only present in a small number of cultures that has been true for less than a century, therefore there's no way it's just part of human nature.
KingSram t1_j68zz3f wrote
Reply to comment by OneTrickRaven in What’s the longest wait you’ve seen for chekhov's gun to be used? by I_Am_Slightly_Evil
Noted. I'll have to set a calendar reminder to come back to this thread.
History_fangirl OP t1_j68zlge wrote
Reply to comment by BigBoxOfGooglyEyes in 1st case by James Patterson are all his books like this? by History_fangirl
That’s hilarious - especially as I’m potty training my 3 year old at the moment 😂
st-griff t1_j68zhxi wrote
I read this book in high school after an acquaintance had finished it and said it made her so upset she just didn’t want it on her bookshelf anymore.
It hit very close to home, while I didn’t move around as often, my family was always struggling for money, and my parents made a lot of bad, selfish decisions. I was really parentified and I still have a complicated relationship with my parents, but they remain in my life despite everything, even if it’s at arm’s length. I think at the time I was probably a little young to have read this book, but I appreciated her story and it definitely left an impact on me. I remember thinking if she was able to pick herself up and become something, I knew I was definitely going to be okay.
I think I might go back and reread this, now that I’m older and have a little more space from the situation I was in when I originally read it.
BigBoxOfGooglyEyes t1_j68zg46 wrote
I'm in charge of collection development for a public library and the reason Patterson stays on top of the popular authors list is quantity over quality. I swear it seems like he has something published weekly. Last week I was reading through a list of upcoming titles and came across a toddler board book he wrote about using the potty.
angelojann OP t1_j68zbge wrote
Reply to comment by Thornescape in Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
it's kind of fascinating how culture and society can change. Luckily classic books can give us a glimpse of how people lived in the past.
Thornescape t1_j68yzml wrote
Reply to Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
I remember this strongly from War and Peace as well. They didn't have the same stigmas as are popular these days.
thegooddoktorjones t1_j68yt11 wrote
Reply to comment by angelojann in Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
It also depended strongly on class. All classes had less 'no homo' kind of bullshit, but upper classes in particular did not need to pose as manly in order to be powerful and respected. Working class folks still needed to prove dominance over each other and had less tolerance for genteel behavior.
pertobello t1_j68yse9 wrote
Reply to comment by Pancakesandbooks in I’m finish up reading “The Glass Castle”, and my blood is boiling. by Avaunt
I always recommend it when someone asks me what to read
angelojann OP t1_j68xsk3 wrote
Reply to comment by RomanStashkov in Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
that's also truee
vivahermione t1_j68xos1 wrote
Early on in The Moon, the Stars, and Madame Burova, Billie, a woman who's looking for her biological parents, makes friends with a piano player. In the last couple of chapters, she learns that >!he's her father!<.
RomanStashkov t1_j68xjq0 wrote
Reply to comment by angelojann in Dickens' David Copperfield: Were men more affectionate with each other in the 18th century? by angelojann
Everyone had same sex relationships. There is no human culture that has ever existed where they aren't present.
However men being affectionate for each other and complimenting each is other is not the same thing
L1zar9 t1_j68x88l wrote
Reply to comment by julien_et_mathilde in Caste, Society and Politics in India, by Susan Bayly by tolkienfan2759
Racism probably plays some part but there’re also like more than 5 times as many white people as there are black people in the US so it’s not like it’ll ever even be physically possible for intermarriage rates to reach close to the same levels as others. Also other aspects would have an impact, like how different ethnic groups tend to form more insular communities and probably at least a few others that aren’t coming to my mind atm
StephanXX t1_j69275y wrote
Reply to Getting better at DNFing books by deepug9787
Why is there a DNF thread nearly every day? Enjoy a book, or don't. It's a hobby, not a career.