Recent comments in /f/books
[deleted] t1_j6k9mku wrote
Reply to English Translation of Dante Inferno by BerrylarryL
[removed]
DevinB333 t1_j6k9l4g wrote
Reply to comment by trowwaith in The letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale that were kept sealed from 1956 to 2020 have been released for free online by RunDNA
It would be. I’ll let you know if it works out.
daedelus23 t1_j6k9jx1 wrote
Reply to comment by chuckletits in The letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale that were kept sealed from 1956 to 2020 have been released for free online by RunDNA
I didn’t read his statement as he “never loved her” more of he loved her at one time but had changed and realized he was in love with who she was, and who he was, back when he first fell in love with her. Can confirm this happens and it can be heartbreaking to realize and difficult to admit to one’s self.
Ilathariel t1_j6k9eop wrote
Reply to English Translation of Dante Inferno by BerrylarryL
Dante uses a lot of terms, expressions and ways of saying that italian has and english doesen't. It's not simple to translate something that old, in a language that was half latin and half vulgar.
He also said many silly things. "Ed elli avea del cul fatto trombetta", devils just farted
lucia-pacciola t1_j6k8pk2 wrote
Reply to comment by Bladewing_The_Risen in The 10 Inalienable Rights of the Reader by swedish_librarian
Saying I think someone has the right to read a text for themselves, and decide for themselves what they think it means, is not the same as saying I think all interpretations are equally valid and correct.
There's also a huge difference between reading comprehension, where you correctly or incorrectly understand the explicit statements of the text, and interpretation, where you reach conclusions about the implicit themes and subtexts of the text.
reachedmylimit t1_j6k8kma wrote
Reply to English Translation of Dante Inferno by BerrylarryL
I like John Ciardi’s translation. It’s the one I read in college many years ago.
Maxtrix07 t1_j6k7z88 wrote
Reply to comment by metromesa in Stephen King and short fiction by metromesa
Glad to hear!
Also, his son made a few short story books. Full Throttle is definitely worth picking up. Its interesting because he has a similar style to King, but I do enjoy his writing more than King for some reason. Definitely look out for Full Throttle as well, I haven't read much from his other shirt story books, "20th Century Ghosts" and "Strange Weather"
Hey_free_candy t1_j6k7rp6 wrote
Reply to The letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale that were kept sealed from 1956 to 2020 have been released for free online by RunDNA
your butt….
quakes. like summer leaves in preparation
fall
down
booty call
zguyny t1_j6k7qtg wrote
Reply to I just finishes Of Mice and Men! by VravoBince
This was my favorite book from high school. There is a movie version from 1939 with Burgess Meredith & Lon Chaney Jr. That was good as well.
lucia-pacciola t1_j6k7nsz wrote
Reply to comment by ElegantVamp in The 10 Inalienable Rights of the Reader by swedish_librarian
Interesting. I tend to think of it in binary terms: Either you're allowed to interpret yourself, or you're not.
To what extent do you think it's allowable?
armchairplane t1_j6k7ep6 wrote
Lupin. He just seems like such a good and understanding and down to earth person.
trowwaith t1_j6k7bhb wrote
Reply to comment by DevinB333 in The letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale that were kept sealed from 1956 to 2020 have been released for free online by RunDNA
Yes but it might be interesting if you were able to correspond after your death.
ElegantVamp t1_j6k6oqh wrote
Reply to comment by lucia-pacciola in The 10 Inalienable Rights of the Reader by swedish_librarian
Ehh I agree to an extent
Bladewing_The_Risen t1_j6k6h0o wrote
Reply to comment by lucia-pacciola in The 10 Inalienable Rights of the Reader by swedish_librarian
To an extent.
We've all read Harry Potter, right? You don't get to say "Harry defeated Voldemort because love always conquers evil!" when the text explicitly says "Harry defeated Voldemort because Voldemort wasn't the true owner of the wand in his hand and the series established in the first book that wands choose their owners and don't work right for just anyone."
It's one thing to have your own interpretation when the text is intentionally vague, but if the text explicitly says something--or very obviously implies something--you don't just get to say, "Well that's what I think, so that's how it is."
That kind of attitude doesn't promote critical thinking or thoughtful analysis of evidence and I don't think it should be encouraged or supported.
IHateFaile t1_j6k65j1 wrote
Reply to comment by Erebus172 in Who's your favorite underrated character in the Harry Potter books? by ireeeenee
>underrated
Everyone loves Luna.
7ootles t1_j6k5ysk wrote
Reply to comment by Negative-Net-9455 in Just me, or was IT really too long? by KnightOfPanda
I will say I had to roll my eyes a little at how much of a Mary Sue Charlie was. Like I said, it's not my favourite book - but I enjoyed it as just another story.
informedinformer t1_j6k5tkt wrote
Reply to comment by geeeffwhy in The letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale that were kept sealed from 1956 to 2020 have been released for free online by RunDNA
Did he dare?
7ootles t1_j6k5r6f wrote
Reply to comment by Negative-Net-9455 in Just me, or was IT really too long? by KnightOfPanda
You're not the person I commissioned.
Also, editors don't charge per hour. They usually charge per thousand words or per page.
TamagotchiGirlfriend t1_j6k4w5v wrote
Reply to comment by ISayISayISay in Who's your favorite underrated character in the Harry Potter books? by ireeeenee
JK Rowling has explicitly said that she interprets support and fandom for the harry Potter series as support for her hateful and damaging views. It's worth calling out.
Two_Hearted_Winter t1_j6k4twh wrote
Reply to I just finishes Of Mice and Men! by VravoBince
The winter of our discontent is one of my favorites by Steinbeck. Very different than of mice and men
ISayISayISay t1_j6k4l7x wrote
Reply to comment by TamagotchiGirlfriend in Who's your favorite underrated character in the Harry Potter books? by ireeeenee
They're quite entitled to ask here. No-one is forcing you to participate.
shillyshally t1_j6k4l7h wrote
Reply to comment by Vorpishly in Just me, or was IT really too long? by KnightOfPanda
If you go back to the golden age of editing and look at Hemingway and Fitzgerald and Maxwell Perkins and take a look at the manuscript pages, the relationship is obviously collaborative. Both those authors are noted for their brevity - that is not an accident!
The self-publishing that has blossomed with Amazon is terrific but man, there is no substitute at all for a good editor.
SonnyCalzone t1_j6k4iyd wrote
Reply to comment by Geetright in The 10 Inalienable Rights of the Reader by swedish_librarian
Well-said. I'm much happier solo than I ever thought possible during my 20s and 30s. It also helps that I have no spouse, no kids, no pets, few distractions and even fewer responsibilities.
dance-song-97 t1_j6k46hn wrote
Reply to comment by chuckletits in The letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale that were kept sealed from 1956 to 2020 have been released for free online by RunDNA
Could be a little of both.
Randym1982 t1_j6k9zi0 wrote
Reply to comment by missfishersmurder in Just me, or was IT really too long? by KnightOfPanda
I felt that It had a bit more highs than lows, but the lows were kind of "wtf?" and a bit stupid. The highs?
>!The whole backstory on Derry. THe Lumbermill massacre. The gangsters getting shot to death while Pennywise dances in the background. Pennywise basically turning into 60's and 70's type monsters while tormenting the kids. !<
That stuff was the best parts of the book to me. Some of the other stuff was a bit of a slog to get through.