Recent comments in /f/books
Trick-Two497 t1_j6picoe wrote
Reply to comment by Erebus172 in Simple Questions: January 31, 2023 by AutoModerator
Typos are the job of proofreaders, not editors. It's the last step in the process.
There are several kinds of editors. The kind of editor that catches the issues you're talking about is a developmental editor I believe. They make sure the story is hanging together. If you're really interested, here is an article about all the different people involved in the editing/proofing process. https://www.gcu.edu/blog/language-communication/types-editors
Probably if you're not working with one of the big houses, your book isn't getting the full treatment. And if you're an indie, you're paying out of pocket. I proofed a book for a gal whose book needed 3 levels of editing it didn't get. Plus fact checking. She used quotes that weren't real or were paraphrased. I flagged those for her (she wasn't paying me for that). When she sent me a copy of the book, she hadn't fixed them.
Astrid-Wish t1_j6pi351 wrote
Reply to comment by DeborahJeanne1 in Which sequel are you thirstiest for? by Bookanista
Yes there is. If ya Google it you can see the covers for first editions and the one meant for mass production.
Reacher is awesome. So is Will Trent.
eschuylerhamilton t1_j6pi1pl wrote
Reply to What subject matter is so ghastly / triggering that you won’t read a book that delves into it? by jenna_grows
There’s nothing I’ll flat out to refuse to read. (Except romance.)
LifeInThePages OP t1_j6pi0do wrote
Reply to comment by mittenknittin in What Moves The Dead by T. Kingfisher by LifeInThePages
Ooh, jump scare in a book, you say? Adding both to my Goodreads TBR! Thanks!
Yanowknow t1_j6phf9m wrote
Reply to comment by FNG_Red in Why is 5 stars the go to rating? by iamwhoiwasnow
The review you had on "Shark Sandwich", which was merely a two-word review, just said "Shit sandwich."
[deleted] t1_j6phclc wrote
Reply to comment by noknownothing in Why is 5 stars the go to rating? by iamwhoiwasnow
[deleted]
plantnativemilkweed t1_j6pha1h wrote
Reply to So many mixed feelings on Colleen Hoover by blabbouther
I am so glad I saw this post. I am a huge reader of books and also listen to lots of audiobooks. I am always looking for audiobooks to listen to when I go jogging. I had never heard of Colleen Hoover and I saw this audiobook Verity by her that had thousands of amazing 5 star reviews. I could not believe how awful it was in so many ways. I could not finish this book it was so ridiculous. Even though it was supposed to be a thriller- I had no interest in even finding out how it ended.
I was curious how this book could be so popular, so I looked up the author. Turns out she was a YA writer and also wrote romance books. I have never read a romance book in my life (I'm 67) and have no interest in them.
LizzyWednesday t1_j6ph6ir wrote
Reply to comment by Bookanista in Classic literature that’s also very readable. by MinxyMyrnaMinkoff
I went through a phase in upper elementary school/middle school where "only Classics" was kinda my motto, so I gravitated towards Dickens because the complicated syntax made me feel smarter.
I'll absolutely have to read Pickwick, though.
GroundbreakingWing48 t1_j6pgzqy wrote
Reply to comment by KansaisDorayaki in Classic literature that’s also very readable. by MinxyMyrnaMinkoff
Hunchback of Notre Dame was pretty easy. The abridged Les Mis I read in 9th grade, so it can’t be that hard/bad. The key to the French literature is that there’s a bit of everything. Action! Adventure! Romance! Revenge! Sewer thieves!
TheMudbloodSlytherin t1_j6pgi5p wrote
Reply to comment by yokai__ in So many mixed feelings on Colleen Hoover by blabbouther
That’s the only book I’ve ever read that made not want to read anything else by the author.
Conscious_Issue2967 t1_j6pg5h9 wrote
Reply to Which sequel are you thirstiest for? by Bookanista
The next book by Richard Osman in the Thursday Murder Club series.
AggressiveBowl t1_j6pg2kf wrote
Dan Wells' I am not a Serial Killer. Somehow got convinced that it would be a dark exploration of the deranged mind of a teenager on his path to become a serial killer, some sort of We need to talk about Kevin. Then monsters popped out of nowhere and it turns out that baby Bundy is actually not that much of a bad guy.
CrazyCatLady108 t1_j6pfk8j wrote
Reply to Confusion on Priory of the Orange Tree by HumanBeeing76
Please post 'Should I read X book''What do I need to know before I read X' questions, in our Weekly Recommendation Thread.
CrazyCatLady108 t1_j6pfjp4 wrote
Reply to Read only manga for my entire life by MulkyShevel
Apologies, but your post does not contain enough for people to engage in conversation. Do you have something else to say about the book that you could edit into the text? Let me know if you edit it and I will reinstate your post.
Or, if you would prefer to share quick/brief reactions to a book you are currently reading or recently finished, you can comment in our weekly What We're Reading thread, accessible from our header atop the sub. Your book may even appear in the sub banner! Thank you.
CrazyCatLady108 t1_j6pfcwy wrote
Reply to audiobooks by eutychiia
Hi there. This subject has been very popular in the past. Please use reddit search and/or check the /r/books/wiki/faq.
MorriganJade t1_j6pf82d wrote
The first thing that comes to mind is the ridiculous translation of the title of The girl with all the gifts by Carey to Italian into The girl(as in teen) who knew too much. The girl is a child (and I see this mistake way too much in translation, it seems people forget that girl can mean child) and she actively knows too little for the whole book. I've wanted to suggest the book to multiple people in Italy and the translation is always annoying
Also the loosening skin by Aliya Whiteley, while I like the cover it looks like horror and the author is known for some horror, but it's literary fiction
Taters0290 t1_j6pf18c wrote
Reply to Did you ever love a book so much you had trouble finishing it because you didn't want it to end? by Kousaroe
A lot. The first time was when I was about 9, and I was given Cinchfoot, the Story of a Range Horse. I read it 10 times in a row I loved it so much. I’d finish the last page, flip it back, and start page 1 again. Obviously, I hated for it to end, so my 9-year-old answer was to simply read it again.
Benvolio--_ t1_j6pey8d wrote
That's the magic of Cormac Mccarthy where you feel like hitting a brick wall when you finish reading. He makes an allusion to the life itself where nothing matters.
[deleted] t1_j6pepqm wrote
Reply to comment by GengerbreadMan in Classic literature that’s also very readable. by MinxyMyrnaMinkoff
[deleted]
MorriganJade t1_j6pe4zx wrote
Reply to audiobooks by eutychiia
I love audiobooks, some of them are read so beautifully and it's such a fun activity while walking. I only use them to reread though, I prefer to read with my eyes first
Em367 t1_j6pe3sg wrote
Reply to comment by Lefty1992 in Classic literature that’s also very readable. by MinxyMyrnaMinkoff
Also Bram Stoker's Dracula. I though I would find it silly because it was old, turns out it is actually pretty chilling and engaging, just as a modern novel.
[deleted] t1_j6pdxz5 wrote
Reply to comment by hannaeus in What books do you feel have been "falsely advertised"? by switchonthesky
[deleted]
silverkiki0527 t1_j6pdtyl wrote
Call Me By Your Name because it is advertised as good and it's awful.
Timely-Huckleberry73 t1_j6pdrxg wrote
Reply to comment by jerbear3 in Classic literature that’s also very readable. by MinxyMyrnaMinkoff
Apparently some people really like the p&v translations. They are supposed to be a very faithful and direct translation from Russian. However, I think this results in a text that reads very unnaturally in English. Constance Garnett on the other hand is criticized by some for taking too many liberties with the text. I prefer her method though because it reads so naturally and feels like it was written in English in the first place.
LifeInThePages OP t1_j6piiyw wrote
Reply to comment by WintersChild79 in What Moves The Dead by T. Kingfisher by LifeInThePages
Yesss, I heard the Mexican Gothic comparisons on Goodreads, but I haven't read it! I'll definitely add that, The Twisted Ones, and The Hollow Places to my TBR. Thanks!