Recent comments in /f/books
cliff_smiff t1_j7vh9p1 wrote
Reply to comment by icarusrising9 in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Why were true accounts at the time censored?
Edit- I still don't get why a city name would be withheld. Names, addresses, etc. sure those make sense. Are the place names in fiction imitating place names in true accounts being censored? Were other kinds of information censored in true accounts instead? What kind of things are the true accounts, like newspaper articles or something else like an autobiography?
cliff_smiff t1_j7vgzhy wrote
Reply to comment by Bubble_James_Bubble in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Whose going to want rights?
Bubble_James_Bubble t1_j7vg6l0 wrote
Reply to comment by runningstitch in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Once they start thinkin, well by God they're going to want rights
Whatstheretosay44 t1_j7vdg2z wrote
It’s to make it seem real. It was standard in the era of classic novels. But when I see it done by new hip contemporary authors, I find it pretentious, and it takes me out of the story.
CrazyCatLady108 t1_j7vcatb wrote
Reply to Rewriting Project Gutenberg book? by JcBravo811
Hi! Your post is more appropriate for a writing sub. Check out /r/writing, please check their rules before posting. Good luck!
ytman t1_j7vc73f wrote
Reply to comment by runningstitch in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Its wild. A manuscript of a indepth analysis of movie no one has seen or heard of is found by some guy who assembles it together and intersperse journal like entries of their life throughout footnotes. Oh and the manuscript was written by a blind man.
runningstitch t1_j7vbrxo wrote
Reply to comment by ytman in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Ok, now I need to read House of Leaves.
MerrickFM t1_j7vbcl6 wrote
Reply to comment by TugboatThomas in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Let me ask you a question: why would a gentleman whose cigarillo case is inscribed "Genius at Work" spend all his time reading a frivolous work of prose fiction?
Prometheus357 t1_j7vavo3 wrote
Reply to comment by vivahermione in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Indeed it did
vivahermione t1_j7vanf9 wrote
Reply to comment by Prometheus357 in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
That's right! Jane Austen did that, too. I guess it made the gossip in Emma that much juicier.
SophiaofPrussia t1_j7v99hj wrote
Reply to Rewriting Project Gutenberg book? by JcBravo811
I think it’s a bit more complicated than just the copyright on the written work (particularly if the work is “public domain” because of a Creative Commons license) so it’s best to consult a lawyer. I believe Project Gutenberg does have a page of policies outlining how material can be used and under what conditions attribution is required. Adaptation for personal use is generally far less onerous than adaptation for personal use. But most of your questions can’t be answered without knowing more details about the specific work and what your plans are for the work which is why you’d need to hire yourself a lawyer who can give you a more definitive answer than anyone on the internet can provide.
ytman t1_j7v8x38 wrote
Reply to comment by runningstitch in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Hah. So House of Leaves is basically the logical conclusion of the Scarlet Letter?
JcBravo811 OP t1_j7v8tih wrote
Reply to comment by reddit455 in Rewriting Project Gutenberg book? by JcBravo811
So the book was a collection of Greek myths I tied together and added dinosaurs and buffalo cause thats what the kids liked. A lot of it is the same as in the original text. Would that still be fine or is that plagiarism or some sort?
​
And by difficult wrapping my head around, I guess the issue is more taking an expired copyright book or media and being to resell it. IDK lol.
runningstitch t1_j7v8lcc wrote
Reply to comment by creaturecomforts13 in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
The newly literate female reader is also why so many early novels are moralistic in nature. Richardson couldn't help but jump at the chance to warn women against... well, having a thought of their own.
Disparition_2022 t1_j7v6x2j wrote
Reply to comment by ed_212 in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Sometimes when a person's name was blanked out it's to imply that they are some significant figure or aristocrat and the implication is that it would be "scandalous" if this story were known about them or associated with them. Adds to the mood.
reddit455 t1_j7v6abr wrote
Reply to Rewriting Project Gutenberg book? by JcBravo811
>I admit, I find it hard to wrap my mind around the idea.
when does something enter the Public Domain? author must be dead for 70 years.
​
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain_in_the_United_States
The claim that "pre-1928 works are in the public domain" is correct only for published works; unpublished works are under federal copyright for at least the life of the author plus 70 years.
​
>Do I need to attribute it to them or if I rewrite it?
it might be a common courtesy.. or "standard practice".. but it's their great, great grandchildren or the estate who were responsible for maintaining/extending copyright (if they wanted to) they had 70 years to get it done.
​
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's last Sherlock Holmes book to enter public domain in 2023
​
Sherlock Holmes joins a first Oscar winner and the 'ice cream' song in the public domain
https://www.cnn.com/style/article/public-domain-2023-sherlock-films-books-songs-cec/index.html
jezra t1_j7v5rg8 wrote
Reply to Rewriting Project Gutenberg book? by JcBravo811
that is why public domain exists
creaturecomforts13 t1_j7v4tw0 wrote
Reply to comment by runningstitch in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
Yes! It was explained to me when I studied "the novel" as part of my English Lit degree. When the novel first emerged, they were seen as frivolous because they were fictional (and also because they were popular with women). A lot of authors tried to get around that by framing them as epistolary, retellings of stories they heard from a friend of a friend of a... or cautionary tales.
It's one of my favourite little known facts!
sllafreburg t1_j7v49no wrote
Reply to Rewriting Project Gutenberg book? by JcBravo811
That is a good question for a lawyer. Or I'll say, yea, perfectly fine, and take a cut.
Biotic_Factor t1_j7v3kzq wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in How damaged would a new book have to be for you to return it? by [deleted]
When I see someone's bookshelf full of completely new books in perfect condition it paints a picture of someone who doesn't actually read their books. Well used for me = well loved. Also I just don't like buying new books in general, I prefer buying used. I also don't like keeping my books past when I've read them. I donate them.
Liath-Luachra t1_j7uwnam wrote
I’ve noticed this with dates as well, sometimes a letter in a book will have something like ‘3rd May 18–‘ written at the top
PangeanPrawn OP t1_j7uuflq wrote
Reply to comment by evilfazakalaka in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
haha too good.
evilfazakalaka t1_j7utl4m wrote
I remember being confused by this in Black Beauty, and I decided as a kid that it was because Beauty was bad at spelling...
Prometheus357 t1_j7urc5q wrote
Reply to comment by SirZacharia in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
I think House of Leaves is very much a modern example of this form of writing (and every other work in that genre) Right? HOL is a compilation of various notes and sketches of a persons experience in a house that appears to be haunted. It’s supposed to leave us the reader curious if what is being read real.
jenh6 t1_j7vhys7 wrote
Reply to comment by cliff_smiff in Why do some books blank out arbitrary place names? by PangeanPrawn
It’s to protect privacy at the time. The same way certain court cases don’t reveal names