Recent comments in /f/books
Wadsworth_McStumpy t1_j8ecaxp wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
Of course. That's what the cover is for. I usually look for a title or picture that looks interesting, and for the name of an author that I've heard of. If any of those catch my attention, I'll pick it up and see what it's about. If it sounds interesting, then I'll buy it.
Sometimes the book sucks in spite of a cool cover, but books are cheap, so that isn't a big deal. And I'm pretty sure I've probably missed a few good books because the covers sucked, but maybe I'll see it again and I'll recognize the author's name the second time.
Also, "rent" or buy? Do you mean "borrow" or buy? I'm not familiar with renting books.
CrazyCatLady108 t1_j8e8hgx wrote
Reply to comment by 312Michelle in What are you reading right now? by 312Michelle
The message about the removal was posted at the same time the post was removed. Reddit has been having errors for the last couple of days, so there may have been a delay in you seeing the message but there is nothing we can do about that.
You can make a post about Sherlock Holmes in our sub or you can post in /r/Holmes. We do not have dedicated sections for any authors no matter how popular because there are just too many of them. But you are always welcome to make a thread discussing your favorite Holmes stories.
If you want to find out what others are reading right now, you can check our weekly "What did you start/finish this week" thread. If you make a standalone thread it will just be removed and you would be redirected there.
In the future you can modmail us if are not sure what sort of posts we allow, before you make a post. This may save you the frustration. Let us know if you have any other questions. Have a great day!
Itchy-Lingonberry-84 t1_j8du4xd wrote
I loved this collection so much, but as others said, some of it can be emotionally visceral. I’ve picked up In The Dream House, but haven’t started it because I’m afraid of being emotionally wrecked again lol.
mayor_of_funville t1_j8dt7qz wrote
I just finished this up this weekend too. I agree with you that the first two stories were the strongest, but the rest fell mostly flat to me. The Resident had some redeemable qualities but fell off a cliff at the end.
thegaybookfox t1_j8de0f9 wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
I go by how much people like them (reviews on Goodreads), their cover, the summary, the author (sometimes) and just overall writing style tbh
xXDestinyX t1_j8d6r8u wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
I definitely judge it by its cover even if it is the greatest book if the cover is these cute/cringy animations of two characters i will pass
Loud-Fairy03 t1_j8d0vqf wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
Honestly, always I think. There’s certain covers or titles that I vibe with way more than others, and that’s what makes me wanna check the synopsis. The synopsis is always what determines my final choice though.
Scat_fiend t1_j8czko5 wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
If they made a movie from the book and then the book cover has a picture from that movie I will absolutely be put off.
lisap17 t1_j8cz4cn wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
A good cover will definitely pull me in, or at least trigger my interest in reviewing the book's synopsis, if I haven't heard anything about it prior to seeing the cover. But a bad cover alone will not make me not read a book, since I mainly read in digital format or listen to the audio version anyway. A synopsis though can absolutely make it or break it for me. Most of the time these days I discover books from social media or friend recommendations, so I might still get the free version (the audio snippet or the first 20-30 "sample" pages) even if I'm on the fence after seeing the synopsis, but if it's something I found myself, I can totally skip it if I didn't like the summary or the reviews were overwhelmingly bad.
[deleted] t1_j8cryml wrote
[removed]
BlindStargazer t1_j8cmuy8 wrote
Yesterday I saw an edition of Carmilla edited by Carmen Maria Machado and bought it, I didn't quite like Her Body and Other Parties but I still felt creeped by it.
I also recommend Mariana Enriquez and Maria Fernanda Ampuero, especially Cockfight, it gave me nightmares.
FeloniousSausage t1_j8ciqgz wrote
Reply to Is Hannibal Lecter a villain or an anti-hero to you in the novel/film The Silence of the Lambs? and why? by pablohax
In the film The Silence of the Lambs, Lecter is definitely an anti-hero. The sequel film (Red Dragon, which was actually an earlier book...) paints him as more of a villain or neutral evil character. He does let Dolarhyde get free and attack Will Graham again, which is more evil than anti-hero.
b0xcard t1_j8chmgr wrote
Reply to Is Hannibal Lecter a villain or an anti-hero to you in the novel/film The Silence of the Lambs? and why? by pablohax
Anti-hero. The primary antagonist is Buffalo Bill. Lecter is evil, but he serves more as a mentor for Clarice, and is the only one who really respects her as a person. And while he isn't afraid of killing non-villains, he'll rarely go out of his way to kill and eat anyone just to satiate his appetite.
312Michelle OP t1_j8cfaml wrote
Reply to comment by CrazyCatLady108 in What are you reading right now? by 312Michelle
>I am not sure what you mean by "You could have said that earlier." Did you send us a message that you did not get a reply to?
Nope. You removed my post and didn't tell me why until like 15 minutes later so the hell was I supposed to know? Also, I thought this subreddit was about talking about what we're reading and you removed my post and said I had to post it tomorrow in some other thread. You don't even make these things clear from the get go and you expect people new to this subreddit to know about them? It's just confusing and frustrating. Why do I have to post my post in the weekly "What did you start/finish reading this week" thread? Why can't I start my own original post/thread where I will get only replies to my own post instead of having to post my post in an already existing thread where the replies won't be only about my own post?
People should be allowed to start their own thread and not have to post their stuff in an already existing thread that's overcrowed and that will contain a ton of replies to posts other than their own original post which makes it hard to keep track of which ones are replies to your own post, keep the discussion focussed on your original post, and even have control over what goes and what doesn't go in the thread/discussion (like being able to delete your own original post/thread along with all its comments if a bunch of bullies and trolls try to bash, attack, harass, verbally abuse, doxx you in the comment section, which everyone should be allowed to do for their own safety and sanity), etc.
I want to start my own original post/thread/discussion, that's my point. And that's why I'm frustrated and angry, because my post was removed and I was told to go post in an already existing thread which is not what I wanted and because the mods on this subreddit didn't make things clear from the get go and the lack of communication is frustrating 'cause my post was removed without so much as an explanation and the explanation came AFTER the post was removed and my desire to start my own original post/thread/discussion (especially one entitled "what you reading right now?") was not even taken into account and I wasn't given the opportunity to start my own.
Also, I'm very disappointed that there doesn't seem to be a section of this subreddit or a thread or a space dedicated to people who want to talk about/discuss Sherlock Holmes novels (some of the greatest classics of all times). I wanted to start a discussion about Sherlock Holmes novels and even shared video book discussions about some of those great books with other bookworms. There aren't that many all genre book/novel subreddits on Reddit (let alone one dedicated solely to book discussions about Sherlock Holmes novels), so I was hoping that THIS subreddit would let me start my own original post/thread/discussions on "what are you reading right now?" and/or on Sherlock Holmes novels. Surely that is feasible.
WackyWriter1976 t1_j8cekkb wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
I'm doing my best to focus solely on the premise and blurb/summary, but it's challenging not to consider the book cover. When they're good, I'm in, and when they're bad, I know I am missing out on an entertaining story, but I cannot buy.
whisky_in_your_water t1_j8cck05 wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
- Read the summary
- Read a few Goodreads reviews
- Maybe skim a few pages to see if the style is my thing
That's really it. I don't care much about cover art, I mostly care about character development and good enough writing to not be distracting. The reviews largely give me the first, and skimming the book a bit gives me the second.
Ok_Aioli1990 t1_j8caaqw wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
Sometimes if cover art catches my attention I will look at the title and author then synopsis. Usually it's title and/or author. Sometimes subject matter or just fatness of book that looks well thumbed and previously loved.
Lrx125 t1_j8ca8dt wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
I frequently judge books by their titles so I suppose I do to an extent.
WendellSanders01 t1_j8c6jcb wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
I go mostly for a book that's either strange, obscure, rare, or a classic. Rare as in not a lot of available copies. Obscure as in not well known, strange as in a little bit mystifying. And classics to me are mainly anything from the 20th century and before. However, I stay away from mass produced books, and contemporary authors who are only in it for the money. I don't bother with modern series books, just because it's a well known modern author really means nothing to me most of the time. But that's ok, we all have our preferences. Anyway, the cover of the book doesn't matter, usually for me it depends on the title. And I flip through the book and see if anything stands out to me. I look at the date the book was printed, what edition it is, and the table of contents. But anyway, all of this doesn't matter really. Over time you'll determine your own opinions that matter to you. Maybe you care more about a book's cover, I suppose that's understandable.
ImperialTiger3 t1_j8c267u wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
When I was younger, all the books I read had cool covers. Either that or they were the longest books in the library that were of interest to me.
ImprovementNo2585 t1_j8c0n0x wrote
I read the Husband Stitch during a very intense bout of PMS/period pain and it was quite an experience...
Especially Heinous is still one of the best things I've ever read. Like you, it took me a couple of pages but after that other stories felt boring and safe lmao
IndigoBlueBird OP t1_j8bzir7 wrote
Reply to comment by pussycatzzzzz in Just finished Her Body and Other Parties by IndigoBlueBird
That one fell somewhere in the middle for me. I loved the build-up of subtle dread throughout — I could feel myself getting more and more nervous as the MC lost her mind. But I didn’t like how abruptly it ended, and the whole Girl Scout part was a bit murky
[deleted] t1_j8bvjxn wrote
No_Poet_7244 t1_j8btgt3 wrote
Reply to Do you judge a book by its cover? What do you look at when deciding whether to rent or buy a book? by KittyLord0824
I judge every book by its cover, and I’m not ashamed. If someone I trust recommends a book to me and the cover is awful, I’ll read it because I trust the person—but I won’t ever choose to read a book with an awful cover of my own accord.
GreatInChair t1_j8ejti3 wrote
Reply to What are you reading right now? by 312Michelle
Killers of The Flower Moon.