Recent comments in /f/books

priceQQ t1_jdrzf7f wrote

Reply to comment by breitfuture in brothers karamazov by breitfuture

Yea it’s also loooong (at least it was when I first tried to read it at 17).

The Grand Inquisitor is somewhere in the middle and is a stand alone section that originally got me interested, and you see its influence on other works and is one very good reason to read Brothers. There is a similar section in The Border Trilogy by Cormac McCarthy, for example.

1

NoisyCats t1_jdry18h wrote

Reply to comment by breitfuture in brothers karamazov by breitfuture

I think it’s overrated and regardless of what many say it’s not that complex of a plot. It’s made more difficult than needed because each character is referred to by different names and at least after translation, is very poorly written. My opinion. It’s good to have different viewpoints.

−1

anthonyjg12 t1_jdrxuro wrote

I think you’re putting too much pressure on yourself. You shouldn’t be feeling any anxiety when your reading for pleasure. You can just keep going and if it turns out you missed an important detail, you can always go back later. And I wouldn’t worry about time investment. It may take you longer to get thru the book, but you shouldn’t worry about that if your reading for fun anyways. Go at your own pace.

1

breitfuture OP t1_jdrwse9 wrote

Reply to comment by priceQQ in brothers karamazov by breitfuture

This is a very good perspective imo. I feel as though the author really tries to explain the characters in lots of depth but it’s so much information to absorb at once. took me quite a long time to just distinguish the different personality traits of alyosha dimitri and ivan lol

1

anthonyjg12 t1_jdrwiv7 wrote

One of my favorite books. There’s so many characters packed into this book and everyone is given a pretty in-depth storyline. Trying to keep track of everything can be a bit of a challenge. I found myself having to flip back and forth re-reading certain chapters or sections to understand it all. But it’s worth is because the book is so good.

The fact that each characters had multiple names was a bit confusing at first. It helped to just think of them as having legal names and nicknames. I think my copy also had a name reference guide in the front of the book so that might have helped as well.

1

striker7 t1_jdrvvnw wrote

I'm about halfway through right now. I've read a fair bit of Russian lit so the names and language aren't confusing to me, I'm just finding it very dull. Lots of debates and rants about religious concepts which, again, having read a fair bit of these and other works from the period, I just don't find those conversations interesting anymore.

I know the story is still building but so far I've been disappointed, considering how much the book has been hyped.

1

cerebellum0 OP t1_jdrs71w wrote

I haven't read Things my son needs to know yet, but I also really enjoyed the other ones you mentioned. A Man Called Ove was so sweet and heart breaking. Anxious People was disarming in its heavy subject with cooky sweet characters. I just love the way he writes about people so much.

2