Recent comments in /f/books

windingtime t1_je0dnd5 wrote

I was reading James Crumley’s The Last Good Kiss and watching the first season of HBO’s Perry Mason contemporaneously, and Matthew Rhys just kind of became CW Sughrue in the process. Paul Giamatti was once linked to a film adaptation of the character, if that gives you any indication.

3

chickzilla t1_je0dhh4 wrote

Yeah I've been on AO3. That's not what I'm talking about. I've a few published fan fictions out in the world myself.

That's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about a way to log what you're reading on FF sites. Like GoodReads or Storygraph. I know that the sites themselves have ways of marking favorites, leaving reviews, etc... but I want to be able to have a list, make a challenge for myself, things like that. Without having to use a spreadsheet.
This is how I feel about podcasts as well. I keep neglecting podcasts and fan fiction because there's no way to keep track of what I've been through unless I go through a LOT of extra work myself. Whereas on GR or SG it is just a matter of a few clicks to update my progress whenever I finish or DNF or want to review something.

1

forgetme-nots t1_je0c1lw wrote

To me it's like a portal to another world just closed and you'll never see those characters again, like saying goodbye to some good friends. Of course you can reread the book but it's not the same. Going back to that world is no longer possible...

2

Altruistic_Day_2332 t1_je0bffs wrote

Second for Foyles. Although it is these days a fairly standard chain bookstore it is such an important historical building: the literary luncheons that played such a key role in the Bloomsbury set, the queues round the block to buy DH Lawrence before the ban came down etc...

Although it has to be said the thing Foyles was mostly famous for was what an incredibly bad bookshop it was to the 1950s to the 1980s where, under the management of the eccentric Christina Foyle who loathed her staff so much she refused to allow them to handle money, you could only buy a book through an exasperating triple queue system (order, invoice, collect), books were only sorted by publisher and date of publication, and acquisition choices were eccentric in the extreme (making it a great place to stumble across a rare book by accident but a terrible place to find anything you were looking for). It's now much much more normal, but what's the point in that? Would you buy soup from the soup nazi if he was nice now?

13

theequallyunique t1_je0bf0u wrote

I’ve read that tv show finales are often leaving viewers in similar states as breakups. So the same can surely be said for books. You build a relationship to the protagonist and environment and lose all of that in a short time, so it’s understandable.

5

HeroIsAGirlsName t1_je0a403 wrote

I thought your post was funny OP and I'm not sure why everyone is getting so upset when you are just sharing your observations about the book without trying to cancel or boycott it in any way. It was clearly written in a lighthearted tone and I'm sorry people are missing that. There's a review site called SmartBitchesTrashyBooks, which your style reminds me of. I think you might enjoy it and honestly I would read longer book reviews from you, if that was something you were interested in producing.

While it's unreasonable to expect books from previous time periods to conform to modern social norms, it's as unreasonable IMO to shame modern readers who decide that the book is outdated and even perhaps write a lighthearted post making fun of it.

7