Recent comments in /f/books

BrunoEye t1_je4rgeg wrote

I was made to read it when I was around 14 and absolutely hated it. I remember finding it very cumbersome to read and slow paced. A few years later I had the same issue with Lord of the Rings, though I found Jekyll and Hyde somewhat enjoyable.

2

MinimumProcess1346 t1_je4rat9 wrote

You are reading for yourself, not for anyone else. You can consider it being read. However, I've been doing a project in my diary drawing a bookshelf full of the books I've read. Tho I only draw the fully finished books in them 🤷‍♀️ I could draw the unfinished books on it as well, bit I would feel like some kind of an impostor tbh

1

junjunjenn t1_je4q90f wrote

I really didn’t like this book. But I also abhor reading about the lazy lifestyles of upper class Europeans of this time. They literally just sit around eating and drinking for hours and I feel nothing towards them.

16

Zeltene t1_je4pd25 wrote

I meant, after she ran away from Mr. Rochester when the truth was revealed about his mad wife in the attic. She almost died in the field when a clergyman found her, and it turned out to be her cousin Saint John. I mean, what are the odds.

7

bmtri t1_je4p8sx wrote

I bring this up every time this series is mentioned, but my biggest problem with this "trilogy" is that it isn't written like a continuous story, it's written like he wanted to turn it into a TV series. It's sooooooo episodic (or "side quests" as you say) instead of an epic narrative. Reading about Rothfuss shopping it around constantly makes me think that he purposely wrote it to turn it into television, and since he isn't getting a deal, he's not going to bother finishing it. It's an interesting story, but it grates on me a bit.

5

eat_vegetables t1_je4otua wrote

Phuc Tran does an amazing job in the prologue to “Sigh, Gone” (Prologue is entitled The Picture of Dorian Gray) in extending the themes of identify and allusion to the admittance of another Vietnamese refugee in his small-town.

After years, of dire-less attempts at American assimilation, the presence of Hoang Nyguyen (new refugee) takes on the fun-house mirror reflection of everything Phuc Tran attempted to discard in building new identify; thus the new student reflects the underlying (self-perceived) ugliness of his soul as a refugee.

> Hoàng was a fun-house mirror’s rippling reflection of me, warped and wobbly. I was Dorian Gray beholding his grotesque portrait in the attic, and I was filled with loathing. My disgust for Hoàng was complicated and simple at the same time: I was the Vietnamese kid at Carlisle Senior High School. Just me. Fuck that new Vietnamese kid.

> When Dorian Gray beholds his portrait in the attic and shows his friend Basil the horror of the painting, Basil is sickened. The portrait reflects the rot of Dorian’s soul, and it repels Basil just as I was repulsed by Hoàng.

2

Zeltene t1_je4o9sp wrote

I have always been curious how other people perceived the Jane's name floating on the air to her which caused their reunion. Also her accidentally ending up in the care of her only blood relatives after she ran away from Mr. Rochester. Gothic mysticism or slightly annoying trope? I also wonder difference in perception between modern reader and her contemporaries, especially regarding those scenes. Perhaps you could look up some reviews from her time, and compare with opinions of your book club?

11