Recent comments in /f/books
octaviosiepi t1_je74jjn wrote
I am from Argentina and read it in english last year. I really liked it, Scott Fitzgerald certainly had one of the most beautiful prose of his generation. The way he describes the city, the docks or when he talks about the midwest during winter in one of the last chapters, really powerful images. It is one of those books in which the plot isn't really the main course though. The story itself is pretty simple, it is the way it is told and the character study that makes it captivating. It is obviously very critical of the vapidness and materialism of the roaring 20's but it's never heavyhanded, even Gatsby you can't help but feel a little sorry about him, he's apparently living the dream, but behind the façade he's really insecure and lonely.
YeahWTF20 t1_je74jdy wrote
I'm Irish and I found it quite dull and everyone was absolutely awful! I didn't find anything admirable or aspirational in any of their ideals at all, tbh.
Different-Carpet-159 OP t1_je741wp wrote
Reply to comment by GrudaAplam in non United States folks: what do you think of The Great Gatsby? by Different-Carpet-159
Interesting. But ur right I have no idea what u are referring to. Will Google tonight!
SparklingSarcasm99 t1_je73kyg wrote
Reply to comment by little_carmine_ in Need some help from Jane Eyre fans... by poohfan
Equally logical and stupid just about sums up the English language. A complete mess. Haha
chortlingabacus t1_je737fp wrote
Reply to Literature of Argentina: March 2023 by AutoModerator
(Stupid update, stupid broken Typio lost remarks about each book in first post.)
Four good novels:
Thursday Night Widows, Claudio Pineiro.
The Past, Alan Pauls.
Open Door, Iosi Havilio.
The Incompletes, Sergio Chejfec.
I hugely enjoyed the Pinero & wd re-readit before the Pauls but list is inorder of increasing regard for the books.
peachneko0 t1_je72j4b wrote
Reply to Do you guys create monthly tbr’s? by thegayboy__
I have a small pile of unread books and I usually have an idea of what I'm feeling next, but I do change my mind, so I never 'schedule' specific books as it were, but I have a general goal of 2 books a month. I'm just generally trying to push myself to read more and not buy any new ones, so the pile is dwindling, which is nice! (am excited to go on a book shopping spree once I hit the bottom of the pile)
PeterchuMC t1_je727kt wrote
Reply to Do you guys create monthly tbr’s? by thegayboy__
I've just got a pile that I put newly bought books onto. If it's an especially interesting book, it goes right next to my bed, to be read after the current one.
taystinyworlds t1_je725wb wrote
Reply to Do you guys create monthly tbr’s? by thegayboy__
I do a tbr stack of more than I can possibly read. That way, I have options- like if I start something and I'm not feeling it, i can swap it out for something else.
sdurflinger t1_je722qr wrote
Welcome to "the great wait".
peachneko0 t1_je721so wrote
Reply to comment by thecaledonianrose in Looking for cheap or free books! by MinisterofSandwiches
>ThriftBooks.com
This is lovely, I wish there was a UK equivalent!
vivahermione t1_je71yfu wrote
Reply to Do you guys create monthly tbr’s? by thegayboy__
No, but I wish I could. Alas, I'm a mood reader. I could write the tbr of my dreams, and it wouldn't matter in the least, because I'd end up doing something completely different! 🤷♀️
anachronic t1_je71sxl wrote
Reply to comment by CptPope in Post book depression by bertiewoooster
Don't you even start with that... LOL :)
poohfan OP t1_je71rwa wrote
Reply to comment by SparklingSarcasm99 in Need some help from Jane Eyre fans... by poohfan
With the great ideas everyone is giving me, I think we're going to have a really good one!!
[deleted] t1_je71f8d wrote
Reply to Literature of Argentina: March 2023 by AutoModerator
[deleted]
Dr_Vesuvius t1_je71dyb wrote
Reply to comment by chelrachel1 in London book shop recommendations? by 3rd-eye-blind
I think Gower Street is much better. Piccadilly is just a big shop. Gower Street is slightly smaller by shelf space, but it is full of nooks and crannies which give it an atmosphere of wonder.
Handyandy58 t1_je71bit wrote
When I'm not enjoying what I'm reading, I just put it down and move onto the next thing.
GrudaAplam t1_je7198o wrote
I read it recently. Most likely you won't understand my references but I do find eerie contemporary echoes with Nadia Bartel's lockdown parties, Bec Judd's Brighton crime wave and the Micheal Clarke/Jade Yarbrough/Karl Stefanovic kerfuffle.
So, yeah, to some extent Australia resembles The Great Gatsby 100 years later.
lydiardbell t1_je713vo wrote
Reply to comment by Different-Carpet-159 in non United States folks: what do you think of The Great Gatsby? by Different-Carpet-159
Historically, not as obsessed with status, certainly not as obsessed as Gatsby was. Those who have and flaunt it are (or, were) seen as a bit foolish. "Tall poppy syndrome" means that people will be cut down to size if they don't stay humble, although that's been changing since the 2010s.
Plus NZ didn't really have anything quite as extravagant as the Jazz Age was in the US.
pilesofcleanlaundry t1_je712rn wrote
Is is only 740 pages? I remember it being longer than that, but it’s been a while since I read it.
Dr_Vesuvius t1_je7128z wrote
Reply to comment by Napoleon64 in London book shop recommendations? by 3rd-eye-blind
I actually think it has worse variety than a comparable Waterstones - for whatever reason they stock extremely large quantities, rather than a large variety.
South_Honey2705 t1_je70ysy wrote
Reply to Do you guys create monthly tbr’s? by thegayboy__
I literally have piles of tbr in my bedroom and just choose from the top one at a time
South_Honey2705 t1_je70ta9 wrote
Reply to comment by GrudaAplam in Do you guys create monthly tbr’s? by thegayboy__
Person after my own heart
AvoidThisReality t1_je70mf7 wrote
Reply to comment by GrudaAplam in does anyone like roald dahl's short stories by EatLikeAHippo
I've got the same! Just recently read the one about the sick baby...
AvoidThisReality t1_je70jnr wrote
I like his short fiction. I have read the one about a mother giving birth to a baby struggling with health problems. Gosh. The f* end had me thinking
Different-Carpet-159 OP t1_je74ny7 wrote
Reply to comment by lydiardbell in non United States folks: what do you think of The Great Gatsby? by Different-Carpet-159
True, you need a very wealthy society to even have that to aspire to. Remember that Gatsby's mansion was built by a beer tycoon, so he was really just replacing an older generation of wealth.