Recent comments in /f/books
Sumtimesagr8notion t1_jeegd85 wrote
Reply to comment by TheSSChallenger in Why do some books/authors get away with "purple prose" by [deleted]
Idk I enjoy prose like that. If I have to slow down a little and really focus, it's usually an enjoyable book. Nabokov, McCarthy, Pynchon, Joyce, all fantastic authors.
Septymusmyth t1_jeeg2fw wrote
Reply to comment by greenchix in What crime / thriller book has the most frustrating ending in your opinion? by FormerFruit
Because it satisfies average readers.
greenchix t1_jeefyx6 wrote
Reply to comment by Septymusmyth in What crime / thriller book has the most frustrating ending in your opinion? by FormerFruit
Agreed, the Paris apartment was terrible. I cant figure out why everyone is so hyped to read it. I wouldn't reccommend it.
Adler221 t1_jeeftcu wrote
Reply to comment by Artistic-Accident-98 in What crime / thriller book has the most frustrating ending in your opinion? by FormerFruit
This! Everybody raved about how amazing this book was but I struggled and was very put off with that ending!
Emergency_Revenue678 t1_jeef8cq wrote
Reply to comment by storytroupes in Do you think it's still possible to create new genres? by DiagonallyStripedRat
Epic Fantasy will almost always refer to a work that takes place in its own secondary world. There would be a lot of appropriate genre tags for Greek Epics, but Epic Fantasy ironically isn't one of them.
Y_Brennan t1_jeeevkd wrote
Reply to comment by boofoodoo in Pendragon by DJ MacHale is one of the best series I've ever read. by nucleartaco130
People get attached to books from thier childhood. And they don't want to hear that people didn't like the series when in the targeted demographic.
TheSSChallenger t1_jeeelb5 wrote
Reply to comment by farseer4 in Why do some books/authors get away with "purple prose" by [deleted]
Sure, a certain author's writing can be too difficult for some readers.
But that's why we have the concept of reading levels, which measures an individual's ability to handle complex writing.
But reading skill is kind of weird because the speed and ease with which we read is very much determined by our ability to recognize patterns--a good reader doesn't even have to look at every word in a sentence before their brain has picked out the important words and anticipated what is being said based on comprehension and convention. That's why, for example, we don't even notice most small typos.
So, if a writer's prose doesn't follow language conventions--if their sentence structure is weird or they go way too heavy on the euphemisms--then even a very skilled reader is going to have to grind to a halt and start unpacking each sentence piece-by piece, which is exactly what you don't want good readers to have to do.
Of course there is also variation in language convention. It's going to be easier to read a Regency-era novel if you're familiar with how English was spoken in the Regency Era... but those are still conventions, which a skilled reader can learn and adapt to.
Whereas "purple prose" (this term showed up in dictionaries in 1598, by the way) doesn't quite follow any particular linguistic population's language conventions--it's just that author ignoring the rules and writing whatever sounds good to them.
boofoodoo t1_jeeela1 wrote
Reply to comment by Y_Brennan in Pendragon by DJ MacHale is one of the best series I've ever read. by nucleartaco130
Why are people downvoting this? It’s just your opinion.
GraniteGeekNH OP t1_jeeeez2 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Do you skip or skim when reading fiction? by GraniteGeekNH
Yup. Looking at you, Elvish tunes in LOTR
MetricJester t1_jeeedto wrote
Reply to How do you make a habit of reading for leisure, not only for university studies? by bunga_Berapi
Schedule time, just like how you would for watching videos or listening to music.
GraniteGeekNH OP t1_jeeeav3 wrote
Reply to comment by ItsBoughtnotBrought in Do you skip or skim when reading fiction? by GraniteGeekNH
Yeah, my comment was poorly worded; I didn't mean to be so didactic.
DancingConstellation t1_jeee8nz wrote
Reply to comment by cantspellrestaraunt in Bestselling author Brandon Sanderson challenges Audible over “poor” deal terms by HRJafael
Market dominance =/= monopoly. Monopolies are government creations. There’s nothing disgusting about it; no one is forcing people into these contracts.
GraniteGeekNH OP t1_jeee5yq wrote
Reply to comment by Quirky_Nobody in Do you skip or skim when reading fiction? by GraniteGeekNH
Yes, you may be right about the wording. I was trying to convey my belief, built up over decades of reading and talking to other people, that folks who think it's "wrong" in some sense to ever skim or skip, and thus who haven't built up any experience at judging when and how to do it, enjoy reading a lot less and do less of it.
[deleted] t1_jeedz9g wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Do you skip or skim when reading fiction? by GraniteGeekNH
[removed]
ramriot t1_jeedxyv wrote
Reply to Should I read The Martian by Andy Weir even if I’ve already watch the movie and remember most plot points? by CaregiverBig7228
Definately read the book, also the audible audiobook narrated by R.C.Bray is totally worth a listen too.
Something to note is that there is a ton of stuff that the screenwriter missed that created plot holes & scientific absurdities in the screenplay, that if I had not read the book 1st would have made the movie unwatchable.
Marks story in the book is also way more thrilling as the author throws a ton more things at him which need the shit scienced out of them.
BTW IMO there is only one humorous point in the written word that does not come through in the audiobook or movie. When Mark is told that he should watch his language as the world is trading his words he types I think:
>![12:15] WATNEY: Look! A pair of boobs! -> ( . Y . )!<
======================
[deleted] t1_jeedvx1 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Do you skip or skim when reading fiction? by GraniteGeekNH
[removed]
[deleted] t1_jeedt08 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Do you skip or skim when reading fiction? by GraniteGeekNH
[removed]
I-Kill-People t1_jeedreo wrote
Reply to Should I read The Martian by Andy Weir even if I’ve already watch the movie and remember most plot points? by CaregiverBig7228
Definitely a good read.. i liked Artemis also
books-ModTeam t1_jeedq3h wrote
Reply to Should I read The Martian by Andy Weir even if I’ve already watch the movie and remember most plot points? by CaregiverBig7228
"Is X worth reading?" or "Should I finish Y?" type posts are considered recommendation requests and should be posted in the weekly recommendation thread.
books-ModTeam t1_jeedn32 wrote
Reply to The Kite Runner by Nervous_Thought5442
"Is X worth reading?" or "Should I finish Y?" type posts are considered recommendation requests and should be posted in the weekly recommendation thread.
Bill_thuh_Cat t1_jeedhrb wrote
Reply to The Kite Runner by Nervous_Thought5442
It's a beautiful book. It will stay with you for a long time.
Forsaken_Slice7523 t1_jeedc66 wrote
Reply to comment by Nervous_Thought5442 in The Kite Runner by Nervous_Thought5442
It's worth reading for me one of the best books out there
S_Baime t1_jeedbkv wrote
Reply to Should I read The Martian by Andy Weir even if I’ve already watch the movie and remember most plot points? by CaregiverBig7228
I managed to read the book, but I struggled with it.
Continuous detail of what he is doing to accomplish a series of goals. I got tired of this. I'm assuming I'm in the minority on this.
Lazaruzo t1_jeed8ym wrote
Reply to I just feel so betrayed by "Adventures of Huckleberry Finn." Someone humble me as to what I am missing. by goodmorninga
It’s a book you needed to read when you’re young I feel , too young to notice the glaring racial problems and can just enjoy the adventure.
I read it young and coming back to it as an adult the nostalgia Carries it because some of toms behavior is appalling.
emmylouanne t1_jeeghll wrote
Reply to The Brontë Sisters by carrotwhirl
I still have to read Villette and the Professor. Wuthering Heights is my favourite book of all time (joint with the Bell Jar). The first time I read it I didn’t like it - didn’t understand why people thought it was such a good love story. Then I read it again with the knowledge that it’s not a positive example of what love looks like - it’s passion, jealousy, selfishness. Now I love it and reread it every few years.