Recent comments in /f/dataisbeautiful

por_que_no t1_j2e0jlz wrote

I'm surprised that none of the LIV golfers made the list. Maybe because most details of their contracts have been kept secret. Golf Monthly estimates Phil Mickelson's 2022 total earnings at $138 million, the bulk of that in the upfront payment of half of his $200 million signing bonus. They estimate Dustin Johnson's 2022 earnings at $97 million.

6

fosburyflop t1_j2e0ifd wrote

Ok now we're just arguing semantics. Yes, there probably are one or two black bears currently living in South Dakota; whether you want to call that a semi-permanent population is up to you.

Doesn't change the fact that the OP's data is completely laughable to anyone who's spent time outdoors in Wyoming or South Dakota, which is the real issue here.

0

Series_G t1_j2dzjo7 wrote

Fair enough. I just think it is the researcher's responsibility to understand if the definitions of "gun violence" and general reporting trends are directionally consistent across countries. If there are significant differences, then make some adjustments to the include/exclude rules and state them for your readers. If you don't do that, then we just spiral down into whataboutism in the thread. Also, we can't collectively draw any conclusions from your otherwise good work. Thanks for doing this.

1

Bmw-invader t1_j2dyzd5 wrote

0

pigecoin69420 OP t1_j2dyhe0 wrote

Numbers are important to understanding the world, though of course there could be bias in any data set. It would be really worthwhile if you could identify a potential cause for bias in the data set. When data seems strange, it could be a sampling artifact (bias), or it could be real and up to us to uncover the reason for the strangeness...
I'll put my tin-foil speculations hat on for a second to offer a pro gun explanation for the data: what if higher rates of gun ownership led overall to fewer crimes overall because some sort of deterrence from gun owning population?
The point is, it could be bias, however the differences are quite large, suggesting that it's more likely to be incomplete understanding of the factors at play, warranting research studies to investigate why such differences in crime might exist between two quite similar countries.

1