Recent comments in /f/dataisbeautiful

ASK_IF_IM_PENGUIN t1_iymc829 wrote

How are you defining "Europe"?

If you mean the EU it didn't exist back when this graph started although arguably it's predecessor did in a very different form. More countries have since joined and one, notably, has left.

If you mean the continent there are parts of it where we simply don't have records because the countries themselves have changed a lot, are generally unhelpful or flat out lie (cough Russia cough), and the boundaries themselves are open to interpretation.

3

FITnLIT7 t1_iymc091 wrote

Thank god something I can show my fiancée. She really doesn’t understand it. I by no means need to have my next child in January but I just won’t plan to have a late year baby.. for girls it’s not much of an issue, but it makes a difference for boys early in life and sports.

−5

Pain_Free_Politics t1_iymb014 wrote

It might be more complicated but I’d be curious to see this data adjusted to ‘month of the school year’ rather than calendar year.

IE in the UK, a September birthday would be listed as a ‘month 1’ as it’s the first month in our school calendar, and how age for this sort of thing is calculated. I think varying school start dates by country explains a few of these random peaks, but it’s hard to be sure.

107

desfirsit OP t1_iym8ca6 wrote

Yes, and between countries. But I thought I would just do something simple here (most countries probably use January 1 as the cutoff), and I think the fact that it shows up despite the coarse analysis shows the importance of the phenomenon.

94

desfirsit OP t1_iym82xu wrote

The relative age effect is documented in a wide range of sports and also in academics. A child born in January will be 11 months older than a child born in December the same calendar year, which is a big relative difference at young ages. If coaches don't think of this, they will misperceive the older kid as being more mature and talented, and will then encourage the older kid more.

I took data on all players in the FIFA World Cup and checked their birth month. Just as expected, the most common months to be born are January, February and March.

Some countries may have other cutoff dates for starting school or sports teams than January 1, but despite this, the effect shines through.

Made in R using the ggplot2 package. Data from fbref.com.

227