Recent comments in /f/dataisbeautiful
Confusion-Neat t1_iymnr95 wrote
Reply to [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
Many people are suggesting you should take into account the country of the player, but I'd say to take into account the BIRTH country of the player. Many players are "imported" from other countries.
[deleted] t1_iymn3ek wrote
Reply to comment by Analyst214 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
[deleted]
diamond280779 t1_iymm4uo wrote
Reply to comment by desfirsit in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
England, Wales, Belgium, France, Germany, Croatia, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Serbia, Spain and Switzerland all start in September (academics)
Analyst214 t1_iymm0gz wrote
Reply to comment by FITnLIT7 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
And that’s why your child won’t make it far, most athletes are dictated by genetics and discipline. If we go by chance and your Reddit history we can assume your offspring won’t make it far
DRamos11 t1_iymm09f wrote
Reply to comment by Klumber in [Topic][Open] Open Discussion Thread — Anybody can post a general visualization question or start a fresh discussion! by AutoModerator
It’s a Sankey diagram.
DammitAnthony t1_iymlpig wrote
Reply to [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
This should not be done by calendar month but rather relative to school year start depending on their country. A September child in a September school year is relatively the same age as a January child in a January school year.
Individual_Divide333 t1_iymleaf wrote
Reply to [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
I immediately thought of Benford’s law Considering the months as their numbers 1, 2, 3..
“A logarithmic scale bar. Picking a random x position uniformly on this number line, roughly 30% of the time the first digit of the number will be 1. A set of numbers is said to satisfy Benford's law if the leading digit d (d ∈ {1, ..., 9}) occurs with probability[10]”
A really cool episode of Connected: The Hidden Science of Everything on Netflix, explains the law really well, and has IRS help explain (elusively) how it’s used to detect fraud in real life.
Esarus t1_iymk2gx wrote
Reply to comment by data_n_stuff in School Shootings in the US 1970-2022 Committed by Students [OC] (interactive version in comment) by data_n_stuff
Yeah no worries, we can disagree. It's a pretty visualization, just not clear (for me personally!)
Kriskao t1_iymjodr wrote
Reply to [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
This would make sense in the Southern Hemisphere where school is February to December, but makes less sense in most of the world, where school begins in August or September.
furomaar t1_iymje3p wrote
Reply to comment by Totale-Substanz in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
I was born in the beginning of february and my parents sent me to school a year early. Good job parents.
FITnLIT7 t1_iymj7vu wrote
Reply to comment by Analyst214 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
Having a semi-professional sport background and a cushy desk job that allows me to surf the web definitely indicates a child that will be unable to perform well in sports you are right.
desfirsit OP t1_iymiz5r wrote
Reply to comment by diamond280779 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
It depends on the country. In Sweden where I live January is the cutoff for both schools and most sports.
Analyst214 t1_iymi9a8 wrote
Reply to comment by FITnLIT7 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
It is what it is the truth hurts us all my friend
[deleted] t1_iymi98c wrote
Reply to comment by FITnLIT7 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
[deleted]
FITnLIT7 t1_iymhxuw wrote
Reply to comment by NitsuguaMoneka in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
Sad to want to give your child the best possible life with as many advantages as you can provide?
NitsuguaMoneka t1_iymht2n wrote
Reply to comment by FITnLIT7 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
This is sad.
FITnLIT7 t1_iymhsqi wrote
Reply to comment by Analyst214 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
So you just woke up and chose violence? Perhaps one of the most useless comments I have ever read, thanks for the invaluable input.
LSeww t1_iymhr0p wrote
Reply to comment by data_n_stuff in School Shootings in the US 1970-2022 Committed by Students [OC] (interactive version in comment) by data_n_stuff
I think what's really important is motivation.
Analyst214 t1_iymhmz4 wrote
Reply to comment by FITnLIT7 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
Well good news is if you are perusing Reddit and not busy doing something else then your child most likely won’t advance far into competitive sports so feel free to have it whenever
[deleted] t1_iymh8eh wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_iymglri wrote
Reply to [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
My twin brother and I repeated 1st grade and I always wonder if that was responsible for our academic success. Always being a year older is a huge advantage when you're a kid. Definitely helped in sports too because I hit puberty a grade early and was like 6in taller than my peers in middle school.
data_n_stuff OP t1_iymg1xj wrote
Reply to comment by Esarus in School Shootings in the US 1970-2022 Committed by Students [OC] (interactive version in comment) by data_n_stuff
Sorry man, I appreciate the feedback however I don't agree. If you are making any visualization which is not a "conventional" one like a pie chart or bar chart, it's a good idea to include a "how to read" or some explaining legend as people have different data literacy skills. It's very common even for the best creators in the industry (I'm obviously not in that group) to include a how to read section. With your last point I agree though, there is always room for improvement :)
data_n_stuff OP t1_iymfjt5 wrote
Reply to comment by LSeww in School Shootings in the US 1970-2022 Committed by Students [OC] (interactive version in comment) by data_n_stuff
That's true, however, I specifically filtered to incidents where there were victims (injuries or death) plus the person who committed was a student or former student and the cause of shooting was NOT accident. This was I tried to filter the "actual" intentional school shootings from the very extensive database.
diamond280779 t1_iymf8t6 wrote
Reply to comment by desfirsit in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
For academics September is the relative age effect start point. Most sports in Northern Europe work the same way Football 100% does so here in the UK
Frog23 t1_iymns43 wrote
Reply to comment by Individual_Divide333 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
Benford's law doesn't apply here. It is (best) for numerical values that is spanning multiple orders of magnitude. But instead we have a fixed set of values (Jan-Dec) with no positional notation. If we were to convert the month to their numerical values and try to apply Benford' law, we would need to group the numbers for January, October, November and December to the groups of values starting with 1. That would be a bit more "benfordy", but really overshoot in other direction.