Recent comments in /f/dataisbeautiful
marriedacarrot t1_iyp045e wrote
Reply to comment by enny_el in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
Come to think of it, I don't remember providing a copy of the birth certificate when I enrolled my kid in kindergarten. I think most American parents are so eager to get their kids out of the house and into free childcare (er, I mean school) that the deception would be more likely to go the other way (pretending your kid is older than they really are).
Santacroce t1_iyozwai wrote
Reply to comment by ExiledToTerminus in [OC] Results of 50,000 World Cup Knockout Simulations by mathsTeacher82
So you're telling me there's a chance?
marriedacarrot t1_iyoztd2 wrote
Reply to comment by zedfrostxnn in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
Yes, according to my co-workers from India. They're pretty upfront about it, too (and pretty upfront about being in arranged marriages).
Tordoix t1_iyozcnq wrote
Reply to Analysis of satellite imagery shows how the war in Ukraine has affected crop harvesting along the front lines [OC] by Geographist
This is really well made. A good selection of data that tells a story and a very clean and easy to understand visualization of it.
classybroad19 t1_iyoz72j wrote
Reply to comment by factorialfun in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
That's what the relative age effect is.
classybroad19 t1_iyoz3ms wrote
Reply to comment by Anachronism-- in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
He didn't, in the podcast he talks about the Canadian researcher's wife who noticed it.
lilydlux t1_iyoypv1 wrote
Reply to comment by BullCityPicker in [OC] Educational attainment by US state (and DC) by USAFacts_Official
I was going to suggest a red/blue overlay
BreakfastSpecials t1_iyoynvd wrote
Reply to comment by cheezitsofcool in [OC] Number of Union Army Units/Companies during the American Civil War. by BLAZENIOSZ
The phrase brothers vs brothers was literal in some cases.
AspireAgain t1_iyoymrv wrote
Reply to comment by Slipper_Sleuth in [OC] Number of Union Army Units/Companies during the American Civil War. by BLAZENIOSZ
I appreciate the comment and it’s true what you say, but the map actually shows they had at least 40. As it turns out they didn’t get creative with the numbering system for their infantry regiments. As it turns out they had about 50 regimental sized units depending on how you count them. I think units like the 82nd Airborne and 101st names derive from their original associations (its been awhile so I'm not sure), but I do know in WWII in the Pacific the 3rd Fleet and 5th Fleet were comprised of the same ships, with the Fleet changing names depending upon whether Halsey or Spruance was in charge.
ExiledToTerminus t1_iyoy7ad wrote
Your simulation gives the U.S. a 1/25 chance (in the long run) of winning the whole thing? That seems...optimistic...
Atechiman t1_iyoy1rj wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in [OC] Number of Union Army Units/Companies during the American Civil War. by BLAZENIOSZ
It is effected by how voting is setup. For instance reducing the number of urban voting locations.
Slipper_Sleuth t1_iyoxzrf wrote
Reply to comment by AspireAgain in [OC] Number of Union Army Units/Companies during the American Civil War. by BLAZENIOSZ
I’m sorry to jump on this post but your assessment may not be entirely true. War is deception. In World War Two we created the 10th mountain division. In fact we only had one; but didn’t want the axis powers to know how many others may be around.
Atechiman t1_iyoxu78 wrote
Reply to comment by jeffh4 in [OC] Number of Union Army Units/Companies during the American Civil War. by BLAZENIOSZ
Judging by coloration 40-80
navetzz t1_iyoxtdx wrote
It has been long since the last: "Why do the simple computation when I can run simulations and get an approximation of the result" posts.
SmilgaNir OP t1_iyoxg6d wrote
Reply to comment by european_hodler in [OC] FIFA World Cup Winning Bets Dist: Qatar 2022 is the world cup with the most upsets among the last 7 tournament's Group Stages. Link to interactive viz in the comments by SmilgaNir
and yes y-axis is a random number to spread the results
fredinNH t1_iyox9kh wrote
Reply to comment by the_bear_paw in [OC] Canada GDP growth change % 2017-2021 by Kep_
I think that’s great that Quebec is doing well. I’ve read that when they last almost seceded, Montreal lost some big companies who moved to Toronto, and since I have a kid who lives in Montreal I know the rents are cheap compared to comparably awesome cities in North America.
SmilgaNir OP t1_iyox7bf wrote
Reply to comment by european_hodler in [OC] FIFA World Cup Winning Bets Dist: Qatar 2022 is the world cup with the most upsets among the last 7 tournament's Group Stages. Link to interactive viz in the comments by SmilgaNir
Upsets mean unexpected results, it is taken from the betting to measure how big was the surprise. For example, the winning bet on Saudi Arabia vs Argentina was 25.5 (which is a lot) so for each $100 you put on Saudi Arabia you would win $2550 meaning it is a big surprise
paulbieniek t1_iyowvsq wrote
Reply to [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
The book "Outliers" by Malcolm Gladwell dives into this phenomenon. Great read.
Hunzelmann t1_iyowrg7 wrote
Reply to [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
https://i.imgur.com/ML9zrvi.png
so i ran a quick calculation on this website: https://www.graphpad.com/quickcalcs/grubbs2/ thats an outlier test and according to the result the 94 isn't an outstanding value, i'd assume then its just a random effect
schrodingers_pp t1_iyownpb wrote
Oxford predicted Belgium will go to the final and lose to Brazil, they are out in first round.
These simulations are cool and all, but basing your simulation on ranking only doesn’t generate accurate predictions. You need to consider players recent form, team chemistry, injuries etc.
[deleted] t1_iyowk7f wrote
SmilgaNir OP t1_iyowhtq wrote
Reply to comment by SunnyDayInPoland in [OC] FIFA World Cup Winning Bets Dist: Qatar 2022 is the world cup with the most upsets among the last 7 tournament's Group Stages. Link to interactive viz in the comments by SmilgaNir
Thanks! fixed (in the viz can't edit here)
EscapedCapybara t1_iyowcz5 wrote
Reply to [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
It also doesn't help if you're late going into puberty. I'm a November and never hit puberty until late in my 14th year. I was smaller in the first part of 10th grade than some of the kids entering 8th grade. It's hard to gain any skills in sports if you're never played because of your size.
Easter_1916 t1_iyow7x6 wrote
Reply to comment by FITnLIT7 in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
Or you could do what they do in the southern USA and have them early in year AND hold them back a year. I started college at 17 and my roommate turned 20 freshman year.
marriedacarrot t1_iyp0d30 wrote
Reply to comment by enny_el in [OC] Birth months of FIFA World Cup players. The top three are January, February and March, possibly due to the "Relative age effect" by desfirsit
In my neck of the woods (California) the cutoff is September 1, but it used to be December 31. You had a lot of kids going halfway through Kindergarten as 4-year-olds. Now those Sept-Dec babies go to "transitional kindergarten" first.