Recent comments in /f/explainlikeimfive
Busterwasmycat t1_j2e816i wrote
Reply to eli5: How big a crack does water need to leak through and does the material of the container impact the size required? by p2molvaer
This becomes more of a rate consideration. To have flow, the space has to be big enough to allow the molecule through essentially unimpeded, AND the open space has to be connected the entire distance. Unconnected pore space is not very useful to flow.
Down at the molecular scale (sub-micron size range, down near the nanometer (1/1000 of a micron, or 10 angstroms), there will be interaction of the liquid's molecules with adjacent neighbors of the container material, and this is a sort of friction (resistance to flow as the adjacent molecules attract or repel each other when close). With large open spaces, the resistance is only an issue at the edge of the open space, so flow is unimpeded toward the middle of a pipe or crack, but does drag along its edges (water moves slower at the borders of the space). Even rivers show the effects of drag at the edges and bottom (flow goes from free flow/max flow speed to no flow over a very short distance between pure liquid and the "wall" of the passageway).
When you get down to the size range of a few molecules thick, this resistance to flow (interaction with the walls) actually matters, can fill the entire tube or fracture, and to overcome it you need to provide a much larger force to impose the flow (increase differential pressure to overcome the resistance of near-molecule interactions).
The material of the "container" matters because each compound will have its own particular electromagnetic zone of influence (charge space). The materials can also affect the nature of the "pipes" (cracks/flow pathways), so clays, which stack like sheets upon each other, can have a lot of open space, more open space than a quartz silt would (as examples) but the narrowness of the interlayer space means all water is interacting with the clay surface, the entire route that it has to flow (and it is a longer route because it is back and forth, a switchback path rather than almost straight through). On top of the simple constriction and path length aspects, clay has a very strong charge distribution so grabs passing water molecules fairly strongly compared to quartz, which lacks that charge disparity in its structure. Clay is thus generally speaking way less "leaky" than a quartz silt of similar porosity and explains why clay is generally favored as natural seals for landfills or whatever storage we do not particularly want to see leaking.
Oh, I also forget to mention that different fluids have different viscosities (natural resistance to flow) so some liquids will not flow without a strong head (pressure differential) even if the space is pretty wide open: the liquid's molecules interact with each other and are a form of self-produced friction.
A crack is only a leaky one if the pressure (force on the liquid inside the container) is high enough to overcome all of the various forms of resistance that the container will present. Typically, there is a minimum gap width that has to exist for the situation before flow can commence freely. Part of this is due to the resistance to flow in small passageways, and part of it is simply a matter of unit volume per time (slow flow through a small hole cannot let much volume through it; just no room for it). The rate can be offset somewhat by pressurization, by pushing on the liquid inside the container, but there are limits.
As a general idea (and it varies depending on materials), the zone of flow resistance is a few molecules thick from wall into fluid. nanometer-sized passages tend to be pretty resistant to leakage. And even if there is leakage, the volumes of lost material will be extremely tiny. Free flow is not going to happen and what does manage to pass will be doing it very slowly. Faster than by diffusion (migration of molecules, one at a time, through random movement) but not fast in the way we look at things.
Strictly speaking, diffusion occurs in pretty well anything. Diffusion is the (extremely slow) movement of molecules from regions of high concentration to regions of low concentration. The occasional molecule changes place, or wheedles its way in somehow, into the walls of the container. Eventually, some luck molecule makes it the entire way across the barrier. But it is really slow.
Point is, nothing is truly impermeable. Time frames matter (keeps the liquid inside long enough for our needs, is the basic idea we look for). Many ceramics (like for coffee cups) have a lot of open space inside, but the spaces do not connect well at all, so the cup is impermeable. Some clay-based containers are leakier than others, and you might see some sweating if they are imperfectly sealed, but even then, the amount of liquid being lost is tiny so the user doesn't much care, usually.
Smashville66 t1_j2e7yuz wrote
Reply to comment by SDN_stilldoesnothing in ELI5: Why do companies require annual budget be spent 100%? by angrybird7677
Every. Damn. Year. But if I tried to “overspend” on something necessary—knowing full well that the budget wasn’t going to be compromised in any way—I’d be scolded.
explainlikeimfive-ModTeam t1_j2e7wjj wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in ELI5: How did we realise the mind is in the brain? by theembryo
Please read this entire message
Your comment has been removed for the following reason(s):
- Top level comments (i.e. comments that are direct replies to the main thread) are reserved for explanations to the OP or follow up on topic questions (Rule 3).
Anecdotes, while allowed elsewhere in the thread, may not exist at the top level.
If you would like this removal reviewed, please read the detailed rules first. If you believe it was removed erroneously, explain why using this form and we will review your submission.
explainlikeimfive-ModTeam t1_j2e7t5r wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in ELI5: What makes the rust on a rusty nail different from the rust on shaving razors to where one needs an immediate tetanus shot and the other happens daily by DrySyllabub2563
Please read this entire message
Your comment has been removed for the following reason(s):
- Top level comments (i.e. comments that are direct replies to the main thread) are reserved for explanations to the OP or follow up on topic questions (Rule 3).
Anecdotes, while allowed elsewhere in the thread, may not exist at the top level.
If you would like this removal reviewed, please read the detailed rules first. If you believe it was removed erroneously, explain why using this form and we will review your submission.
bkydx t1_j2e7pse wrote
Reply to comment by BuildANavy in ELI5: Why does putting one foot out from under the blankets bring so much relief of heat while laying in bed? by SirDuke6
Incorrect.
Soles and palms are made of glaborous skin design to let heat out.
Cutaneous skin keeps heat in.
A fan or creating airflow is airflow has absolutely nothing to do with biology.
explainlikeimfive-ModTeam t1_j2e7phe wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in ELI5 Why aren't we curing more degenerative diseases with stem cell research? by KaishiXYZ
Please read this entire message
Your comment has been removed for the following reason(s):
- Top level comments (i.e. comments that are direct replies to the main thread) are reserved for explanations to the OP or follow up on topic questions (Rule 3).
Very short answers, while allowed elsewhere in the thread, may not exist at the top level.
If you would like this removal reviewed, please read the detailed rules first. If you believe it was removed erroneously, explain why using this form and we will review your submission.
syzamix t1_j2e7pbo wrote
Reply to comment by fastolfe00 in ELI5. Why is honey and lemon a popular cure for cold like symptoms. What makes lemon more effective than say an orange or lime? by alexkid_in_realworld
Sorry. Are you confident that lemon has no effect? Because other answers seem to say that citric acid cuts mucus.
Who's lying? And who has any sources to back them up?
Full_Temperature_920 t1_j2e7j76 wrote
Reply to comment by Scuka1 in eli5: back then, before astronouts goes to space, how do we know about thing like nonexistent of oxygen & zero gravity? by zetasstra
I'm assuming planets and other celestial bodies don't experience drag in space, so those definitely will keep orbiting their star until it expands and swallow them then? Assuming nothing flying through space impacts them with enough momentum to shift the course
nrron t1_j2e7hbh wrote
Reply to comment by bandit69 in Eli5, how does food and liquid become separated in the body and never comes out the wrong “hole” by Huntercxle
Generally, an illness or eating something bad will trigger something in the stomach that tells the brain we need to empty the system now. The brain tells the intestines to fast track everything which doesn’t leave time for the water to be properly absorbed so it’s just along for the ride
TheLuminary t1_j2e7f4j wrote
Reply to comment by angrybird7677 in ELI5: Why do companies require annual budget be spent 100%? by angrybird7677
Businesses are not families, and I know lots of families that do spend their budgets like that. In fact my wife and I realized that we came in $5000 under our annual budget and are looking at things we could buy that would improve our life that we didn't think we could afford earlier.
Companies generally already have cash stores, but cash sitting is cash wasted. Cash can and should be invested, either back in the company, or elsewhere, used to pay down debt, or used to pay shareholders.
So if your budget is reduced because you didn't spend it. That money will not just sit for a rainy day, it will be transferred to another place where it can do work for the business.
A last example. Microsoft purchased Minecraft, because it had too much cash in the bank, and the interest return on that cash was less than they would get by buying Minecraft, so they did.
chriswaco t1_j2e79fn wrote
Reply to comment by agate_ in ELI5 why do people refer to it as the pacific northwest rather than simply the northwest? by Longshot_Louie
UMich’s fight song, The Victors, still refers to the team as “Champions of the West”.
bandit69 t1_j2e779a wrote
Reply to comment by nrron in Eli5, how does food and liquid become separated in the body and never comes out the wrong “hole” by Huntercxle
Which poses the question, what can cause the intestines to not absorb the water?
ho-tron t1_j2e775l wrote
Reply to comment by KlzXS in Eli5 How exactly does Noise cancellation work? That too in such small airbuds by Professional-Ad3441
Thanks, makes sense
MyFavDinoIsDrinker t1_j2e6yy7 wrote
Reply to comment by ShadowV97 in eli5 Why is being barefoot unsanitary? by GoodLittleTerrorist
That's pretty much it. The big thing about diabetes and feet is that it makes it so any wounds you do get on your feet are much harder to heal, so the most simple preventative measure is to just try not to get wounds on your feet.
bkydx t1_j2e6wvh wrote
Reply to comment by SirDuke6 in ELI5: Why does putting one foot out from under the blankets bring so much relief of heat while laying in bed? by SirDuke6
Except its wrong.
PckMan t1_j2e6ucr wrote
It's to prevent misuse of funds and overspending. In a big organisation like a company not every single person working in that company is aware of how much money they have and how its being spent, there's departments whose jobs it is to do that but the rest of the people working in the company don't know, aside from some management positions who usually get an abridged run down of expenses. Smaller branches of bigger companies or organisations have their own accounting departments that are in charge of tracking expenses, making the budget and requesting money from the central accounting department.
So from the point of view of central management they prefer not giving out more money than is needed because that could lead to misuse, or at the very least unnecessary spending. From the point of view of smaller subdivisions though they prefer their budget not being reduced because in the off chance they have unexpected expenses their budget doesn't cover, requesting money and getting it approved is a long drawn out process. Also it's less work for them to receive lump sums and allocate them as they see fit than having to individually calculate and predict all expenses to a near zero margin of error, because that's pretty much impossible but also a lot more work for them. So the general tactic is to track spending for some time and once they get an average of yearly spending to request a bit more than that which gives them more leeway with spending, and is less work for them. The year goes by and expenses are covered and catalogued, and when the year is nearing its end if they see they have left over money they simply find ways to spend the money which justifies them receiving it in the first place, so that to central management it will seem like they need that amount every year so they'll get it next year too. If they find themselves short on cash it gives off the impression that either their accounting department/management is incompetent or that they're overspending, even if that's not the case.
TL;DR, it looks better when a smaller subdivision requests the same amount of money every year. If they request more than they initially got it seems like they're incompetent or overspending. It's less work for them and easier to operate with a budget that allows leeway instead of trying to fine tune it to be exact, which is impossible since there's always unexpected expenses popping up throughout the year. Central management on the other hand does not want to overspend because that cuts into profits and of course they want to prevent embezzlement, so all money allocated has to be accounted for and spent on something with the receipts and invoices to prove it.
bkydx t1_j2e6ucd wrote
Reply to comment by ImReverse_Giraffe in ELI5: Why does putting one foot out from under the blankets bring so much relief of heat while laying in bed? by SirDuke6
Palms and feet and forehead all work better.
Glabrous skin is designed for heat transfer and only located in these 3 spots.
The skin on your wrist does not transfer cold as effectively beneath the skin surface.
Other suggested locations are Neck/arm pits because they are thinner cutaneous skin similar to wrist but the blood flow is direct to your brain.
De-oxyginated blood from your wrist goes to your heart and not your brain and there would be little cooling effect and less benefit then using any of the medically recommended cooling areas.
geek_fire t1_j2e6pm2 wrote
Reply to comment by drafterman in ELI5 why do people refer to it as the pacific northwest rather than simply the northwest? by Longshot_Louie
>I mean, you would agree that we wouldn't ever give two states the same name, right?
Washington State / Washington DC is annoyingly close.
FrankDrakman t1_j2e6l7y wrote
Reply to comment by Generallybadadvice in ELI5: Why do companies require annual budget be spent 100%? by angrybird7677
Incentive pay systems are a bitch to design, because people are so good at gaming them. One call centre I worked at had contests on Friday if weekly sales had been down. One woman, no matter how bad she was doing by lunch, always pulled out a bunch of sales in the afternoon, and was given the $50 cash prize.
I was the data analyst, and got suspicious. Sure enough, all most of those 'sales' would be cancelled on Tuesday or Wednesday of the next week. We listened to the tapes of her sales calls, and heard "I'll put the order in to reserve your spot; if you change your mind over the weekend, you can cancel." She didn't deny any of this when confronted with the evidence; she also didn't come back to work the next day, or ever after.
Also, the top performers on each team seemed to win week after week, which makes sense. They are the best sales people, so they generally sell more at all times. But an incentive that goes to the top performers most of the time only reinforces an "us vs them" mentality on the sales team, where the top performers are seen as getting the best leads (they do), and getting the most slack for things like being late, etc. (they did). As I said, designing a good, fair, working incentive system that can't be 'gamed' is not easy.
Ansuz07 t1_j2e6kvh wrote
Reply to comment by 808RedDevils in ELI5: If money today is all digital, why can't all the countries governments just go on the computer and add like five more zero's to their account and fix everything? Same principal is 100 years ago too I guess, why not just print more cash? by ss89898
That's somewhat easy to say in hindsight when we don't have the ill effects of a more surgical program to compare. Its the key problem in economics - true experiments with control groups are incredibly rare, so we can rarely say which option was "best" with certainty.
A surgical program would have likely stemmed the inflation issue, but would also have likely taken much longer to execute, leaving people who needed funds without them for potentially months. It also would have "false negatives" - denying money entirely due to bureaucratic errors.
Whether or not that would have been worse than the partial impact it had on inflation is impossible to say.
Much_Difference t1_j2e6g62 wrote
Reply to comment by agate_ in ELI5 why do people refer to it as the pacific northwest rather than simply the northwest? by Longshot_Louie
Fun fact: Alabama, Mississippi, etc were once The Old Southwest for similar reasons.
borg286 t1_j2e6cvc wrote
Reply to comment by Scoobysmith44 in ELI5: Why does putting one foot out from under the blankets bring so much relief of heat while laying in bed? by SirDuke6
Where is this trunk on a person? Honest question.
MildThinness t1_j2e6bby wrote
Reply to comment by angrybird7677 in ELI5: Why do companies require annual budget be spent 100%? by angrybird7677
Different way of looking at it. Budgets are more like setting enterprise or department-wide financial targets.
If you want something more comparable between a company's spending and a family's budget (where they account for every dollar), look at the Statement of Cash Flow. Money comes in from operations (work), some comes in through financing (loans), some goes out the door when you buy new assets to make more money later on (car) then whatever is left over can get put into retained earnings (savings).
phiwong t1_j2e67cs wrote
While steel melts at a relatively high temperature relative to other metals like copper, aluminium, gold, silver and tin etc, it is not at a temperature that is unimaginably high. (maybe 1.5x to 3x).
Things like stone, ceramics, clay and sand can easily withstand the melting temperature of steel. All you need is to make the container out of this kind of materials. (This is why the forge doesn't melt when steel is melted)
There are also other metals that have higher melting points than steel - titanium for example. But titanium is way too expensive to make into forging containers - a simple clay container is sufficient.
MyFavDinoIsDrinker t1_j2e82n4 wrote
Reply to Eli5, how does food and liquid become separated in the body and never comes out the wrong “hole” by Huntercxle
In your stomach, food and liquid gets churned and processed with acid and enzymes, so by the time it moves into your intestines it is basically just liquid.
As it passes through your intestines, a lot of the molecules in it will go through the membrane and into your blood. This includes most of the water and most of the small nutritional molecules like sugars, but leaves behind other things like large non-digestible molecules like fiber.
What doesn't leave your intestines ends up forming your feces. Your urine, on the other hand, is blood that has been filtered by your kidneys.