Recent comments in /f/explainlikeimfive
ridingbicycle t1_j6fs9ch wrote
Reply to comment by yolofreeway in ELI5:Why is barbary slave trade never talked about in mainstream history? by yolofreeway
I think its easy to forget just how enormous the cultural influence of the US is. I live in the country next door so we obviously get it big time. But there's no escaping it anywhere in the world. Seems like almost everywhere you go, people know at least something about US history. Its kind of crazy.
BeefWillyPrince t1_j6fs8fn wrote
Reply to comment by yolofreeway in ELI5:Why is barbary slave trade never talked about in mainstream history? by yolofreeway
The Barbary Slave trade was thought to have peaked at 1.25 million… the transatlantic slave trade at 15 million.
xCreamPye69 OP t1_j6fs4gy wrote
Reply to comment by WeDriftEternal in ELI5: Why does the IRS want your illegal income declared on tax returns? by xCreamPye69
But asking people to report on their illegal income is a form of self incrimination isnt it?
Jammin-91 t1_j6fs2aw wrote
mmmmmmBacon12345 t1_j6fs0ev wrote
The IRS wants their cut, they always want their cut
In general though they don't send the feds after you because laws vary and its a question of what you did and what juridiction and they really don't care. The 5th amendment also protects you from having to say what you did to get that income.
But they can use failure to report illegal income as a way to get organized crime leaders like Al Capone. Some people clearly have significant income coming in yet only a small official income statement filed, the IRS wants their percentage off the rest of that pie
WeDriftEternal t1_j6frub6 wrote
The law is you must report ALL income regardless of source, otherwise you're breaking the law.
Yes, the govt wants their cut. You make money, they get their piece of it and you have to follow the law like everyone else
yolofreeway OP t1_j6frs3q wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in ELI5:Why is barbary slave trade never talked about in mainstream history? by yolofreeway
I think the reason number two is probably the main one. Thanks.
I now see the difference between "mainstream" history and "pop" history.
[deleted] t1_j6frpza wrote
yolofreeway OP t1_j6frouz wrote
Reply to comment by ridingbicycle in ELI5:Why is barbary slave trade never talked about in mainstream history? by yolofreeway
I think this is the most important reason. Thanks. I am not in the US and it is strange to me that in my country we do not talk about enslaving of our ancestors like it is talked about in the US
yolofreeway OP t1_j6frckw wrote
Reply to comment by TheJeeronian in ELI5:Why is barbary slave trade never talked about in mainstream history? by yolofreeway
Greece. My great grand parents were hunted even when they were going to get water. Many of their relatives were caught and sold in the empire.
My country and my people would have turned differently if their ancestors did not live in fear of being kidnapped. There is quite a lot of emotional abuse that was being passed down to generations because of the actions of the ottoman empire.
A cousin of mine told me about one of his grandparents who was kidnapped from his own home, while his family was watching. He fought back and was killed by the muslims who wanted to capture him
[deleted] t1_j6fr437 wrote
[deleted]
ridingbicycle t1_j6fr2nl wrote
Reply to comment by yolofreeway in ELI5:Why is barbary slave trade never talked about in mainstream history? by yolofreeway
Sure. But like I said, much pop history comes out of North America where it is felt much more than the Barbary Slave Trade.
Indercarnive t1_j6fr10y wrote
The Primary reason is because the Trans-Atlantic slave trade and the resulting institution of racial slavery had a profound and dramatic effect on the governments, cultures, institutions, and people of the Americas that continue to this day. If your media is coming from the point of view of people in North and South America, then the Trans-Atlantic slave trade is much more relevant.
yolofreeway OP t1_j6fqwe4 wrote
Reply to comment by ridingbicycle in ELI5:Why is barbary slave trade never talked about in mainstream history? by yolofreeway
> The Atlantic Slave Trade lead to hundreds of years of societal impact that is still very much present today.
The Barbary Slave Trade lead to hundreds of years of societal impact that is still very much present today in parts of Europe
TheJeeronian t1_j6fqw5k wrote
Reply to comment by yolofreeway in ELI5:Why is barbary slave trade never talked about in mainstream history? by yolofreeway
What country? When? How big is your country? What are the lasting cultural impacts?
yolofreeway OP t1_j6fqrdb wrote
Reply to comment by TheJeeronian in ELI5:Why is barbary slave trade never talked about in mainstream history? by yolofreeway
barbary slave trade has had an impact on millions of people in my country yet no one talks about it nowadays
Kind_Profession4988 t1_j6fqqx3 wrote
Reply to comment by milkytrizzle93 in Eli5....can you dig a well anywhere and hit water...and how did the early ranchers in the West know where to dig for water. Especially in the really dry areas? by pinkshrinkrn
FYI, I'm not autistic and typically have a pretty dry sense of humor, and I still had no clue that was a joke.
[deleted] t1_j6fqqf3 wrote
Reply to ELI5 Why do men pee in solid streams and women more or less gush out their pee? by Kaz3girl4
[removed]
ridingbicycle t1_j6fqoqy wrote
Define mainstream history.
The Barbary Slave Trade is absolutelty discussed in mainstream history. Just not pop history (i.e the History channel).
The Atlantic Slave Trade is likely more talked about because its impact is felt more in the present day, especially in North America where much pop history programming comes from. The Atlantic Slave Trade lead to hundreds of years of societal impact that is still very much present today.
BackRowRumour t1_j6fqomr wrote
Reply to comment by Diogeneselcinico42 in ELI5 - why body massage are always better when done by someone else? by Adventurous-Tour-981
Also: great word.
TheJeeronian t1_j6fqlwl wrote
Mainstream history tends to skim over anything before 1500, and most things after 1500 that don't have direct noticeable impacts on the modern day.
The atlantic slave trade has directly and memorably impacted the families of a solid 50% of my country's population (America having an enormous influence on popular culture and education). People to this day, en masse, try to pretend it was a good thing. It is clear that education has been insufficient.
CaptainAndy27 t1_j6fqlua wrote
The Atlantic Slave Trade has a more direct effect on US history and present than the Barbary Slave Trade, and the American education system and American discourse in general tends to focus on things that most affect Americans rather than things that affect other parts of the world.
autotelica t1_j6fqdme wrote
Reply to Eli5: Can someone explain Vogue dancing? by TheRunningMD
You might like the documentary "Paris is Burning." It goes into the history of vogueing and the NYC ballroom culture.
series_hybrid t1_j6fpmb9 wrote
If you get a book on "fluid dynamics" it covers liquids and gasses, which follow many of the same engineering principles. The major exception is the compressibility of gasses.
xCreamPye69 OP t1_j6fsa9m wrote
Reply to comment by mmmmmmBacon12345 in ELI5: Why does the IRS want your illegal income declared on tax returns? by xCreamPye69
> they really don't care
Is this true? What if you're a successful drug dealer/weapons smuggler and you reported an income of $20 million? Will they turn a blind eye as long as you file your taxes?