Recent comments in /f/history
Refreshingpudding t1_isk1po6 wrote
Reply to comment by Holidaywhobiewhatie in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
Warlord chronicles are better written and tighter paced. The alt king Arthur story is fun
Refreshingpudding t1_isk174m wrote
They were "migrants not invaders". Yeah I suppose the Celtic occupants just said hello welcome to Britain please take any land you want eye roll
[deleted] t1_isk07q2 wrote
Reply to comment by Dokutah_Dokutah in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
[removed]
dalitpidated t1_isjxqwl wrote
Cologne was the seat of the Agrippina family. Not far off was the site of Teuteborg Forrest 9BC and the Catalaunian Plains 451 AD. Germanicus moved his seat to Cologne. The family had be allies to the Sicambri for thousands of years, and the Sicambri held a bit of influence over the Belgae and the Germani.
dalitpidated t1_isjwryg wrote
Reply to Did the first crusade impact significantly the war-making capacity of states like england, west and east francia? And did later crusades impose equal burdens, or was the distribution of this burden different for the 2nd and 3rd crusades? by Qazwereira
If you look at the People's Crusade and the Children's Crusade it becomes apparent that all the Crusades were a farce intended to kill off Franks and replace them with Getae.
dalitpidated t1_isjvxdw wrote
Reply to comment by HDH2506 in Has metal ever been used in ancient/medieval fortifications or any equivalent by HDH2506
It is the definition of historical
Dokutah_Dokutah t1_isjumot wrote
Reply to comment by Bozee3 in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
Serpentine running back and forth to avoid trebuchet hits.
Bozee3 t1_isjsdnx wrote
Reply to comment by Dokutah_Dokutah in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
Trubuchet for your archers, wolowolo protecting the trubuchet.
Saxon2060 t1_isjqcu3 wrote
Reply to comment by Blueshirt38 in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
For a good introduction to basically any frigging thing you can think of, "A Very Brief Introduction to:" series from Oxford University Press. They're written by leading academics in their field and could fit in a front pocket of your jeans.
There is A Very Brief Introduction to The Anglo-Saxons.
Saxon2060 t1_isjpybo wrote
Reply to comment by Ripheus-33 in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
Hmm, I'm not sure if you've ever heard of the Venerable Bede or Asser of Wales or the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle 🤔
I guess "not much" is a vague statement that I might be massively misconstruing but there's masses of contemporary record of the Anglo-Saxons. They write extensively about themselves, they loved it, Anglo-Saxon England was a centre of wealth and learning.
Doctor_Impossible_ t1_isjpodx wrote
Reply to comment by PretendsHesPissed in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
Wind and water pick up enough sediment from the surrounding soil to cover sites, not counting things like buildings at low points, which will also accrue soil simply moving downhill very very slowly over decades via gravity. Sites higher up will be subjected to proportionately more weather effects via exposure, and will fairly quickly be worn down to ground level, especially after they fall into disrepair or are abandoned or destroyed, or all three.
PretendsHesPissed t1_isjmmyh wrote
Curious: How do these structures always end up buried underground? Did they bury them themselves? Is it just because they were abandoned for centuries/millennia and nature had its way with it?
Always make me wonder what history I'm walking over when I'm visiting the fam in Cornwall. I just assume there's history everywhere and seeing things like this makes me wonder even more.
Roselace t1_isjmdc7 wrote
Is that Anglo-Saxon Hall near the same place of the ‘Rendlesham Forest’ UAP incident involving USA military nuke site? Lovely coincidence.
[deleted] t1_isjm3uj wrote
Reply to comment by borednord in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
[removed]
thedudesews t1_isjm1zc wrote
Reply to comment by JensonInterceptor in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
Phil found some flint so he’s basically useless the rest of the day. We sent Stewart on a walk about. No reason, we just don’t like him.
Lil_Mcgee t1_isjlsr2 wrote
Reply to comment by Pepperonidogfart in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
The events depicted in Vikings are much more based in legend than real verifiable history anyway.
Not denying that the show goes off the rails a bit, it's just that the concept of a historically accurate Viking show isn't all that feasible in the first place. This is somewhat the case for any historical fiction but it's especially true when it comes to pre-modern societies who weren't known for writing down their histories.
[deleted] t1_isjk3cu wrote
[removed]
GOLDIEM_J t1_isjjz81 wrote
Reply to comment by AmosLaRue in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
By definition, "ancient" means everything before the Middle Ages, commonly understood as everything before 500 CE. So that includes ancient Egypt, Sumer, the Hittites, China, Greece and Rome, etc. On the other hand, when people mention "antiquity," they're generally talking about the period of ancient history circa 800 BCE to 500 CE. This is defined as the period coinciding with the Greco-Roman period, but it's important to note that there were other important developments going on in other parts of the world during this time as well.
jectosnows t1_isjih9h wrote
People back then where strange. They never have roofs over their buildings
PuerhRichard t1_isjigmh wrote
Reply to comment by Immortalbob in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
Interesting. I read I. The book American Nations that the English settlers built houses with wood while the Germans used stone.
Haverstahm t1_isjgbfm wrote
Reply to comment by TrulyIndepedent in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
My word! Is everyone here so sensitive?
borednord t1_isjfqqm wrote
Reply to comment by Trackmaster15 in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
There is no need for hostility my friend. I offered a question as your take on Lords providing some sort of service in return for goods from peasants is a take that is mistaken on many levels as regards to the concept of feudalism.
Simply put a lords "claim" to a peasants food was "I am instated by God" and "I let you work my land and you give me your food". Rather your take on peasants providing food for a ruling caste is better described as manoralism and really has nothing to do with the term feudalism, as that describes the relationship of vassalage and should be further distinguished by geographical constaints, as feudalism in England is different from France, and the rest of europe.
StatikSquid t1_isjd8a0 wrote
Reply to comment by Pepperonidogfart in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
Uhtred is based on Uhtred the Bold, who was an ealderman of Northumbria. But the big difference here is the Uhtred the Bold was born like 150 years after the events of the show.
I haven't seen vikings, but now I'm disappointed that it's not historical. Ironic given the show was basically the History Channel's small glimpse of redemption after they went all in on reality tv.
GOLDIEM_J t1_isjc6lb wrote
How far do you agree that in the English educational system, kings who generally fit in with the stereotypical "king" epitome (eg John, Henry VIII, Charles I) are given an unfair precedent?
Refreshingpudding t1_isk1vra wrote
Reply to comment by Pepperonidogfart in Anglo-Saxon hall where kings and warriors dined discovered in England by unheated1
Are we the baddies moment