Recent comments in /f/history
LateInTheAfternoon t1_j6b00q7 wrote
Reply to comment by Thibaudborny in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
The pre-Julian Republican calendar (dating back to at least 183 BC) had twelve months; it was not solar like the Julian one (it was lunisolar, like most of the calendars of its time). They are asking about the calendar which preceded that one.
Thibaudborny t1_j6azco2 wrote
Reply to comment by SteampunkDesperado in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
You're suggesting 12 months is a universal standard, when in reality, that only came about later. You can not disregard that which doesn't exist. It is Caesar who reformed the system to be more structured.
[deleted] t1_j6az15v wrote
[deleted] t1_j6aul3e wrote
[removed]
DontWakeTheInsomniac t1_j6anjrr wrote
Reply to comment by Constant_Count_9497 in What's the earliest case of iron-smelting with hard evidence? by Ok-Goose-6320
Yeah bloomeries were the earliest type of iron smelting furnaces (it's in the name!) so I don't understand it either.
vnth93 t1_j6aibqi wrote
Reply to Can someone explain to me why exactly Wu Tzu Hsu (6c. BC) was executed? by AlwaysBored10711
The king believed that Wu got embarrassed because of his advice not panning out and would sabotage the state to make it look like they couldn't succeed without him. The charge was that he was acting on his own interest, not the state's.
cphug184 t1_j6ae019 wrote
If you were an early 1800s agrarian far from urban life, what sort of personal hygiene did you practice? Please cover teeth, bathing, pooping and hair. I’ve read nothing about day to day hygiene.
LaoBa t1_j69zz7o wrote
Reply to comment by Scruffy725 in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
This was actually just what the Russians did in the Brusilov offensive in 1916, where they dug hidden trenches towards the Austro-Hungarian trenches to insure that the soldiers did not have to cross a wide no mans land.
I'm not sure, but maybe one of the reasons why this succeeded was that there was no vigorous patrolling of no mans land by the Austro-Hungarian army. If you detect such trenches, you are warned that an attack is imminent and you can direct artillery towards it.
cargo_run_rust t1_j69sjk9 wrote
Saqqara is very underrated historic site (overshadowed by the Great pyramid). It is the first stepping stone for large scale pyramid building.
Would always recommend to visit Saqqara to any history lover who travels to Egypt. Glad to see the site is making breakthroughs.
[deleted] t1_j69sauj wrote
Reply to comment by YsoL8 in Ancient statue of Hercules emerges from Rome sewerage repairs by Rob-Study-8562
[removed]
Larielia t1_j69o5on wrote
I started reading "The Japanese Myths" by Joshua Frydman.
What are some other good books about Japanese mythology?
Joy2b t1_j69iuje wrote
Reply to comment by NIDORAX in Ancient statue of Hercules emerges from Rome sewerage repairs by Rob-Study-8562
Insecure politicians didn’t always love statues that looked too much like political enemies.
[deleted] t1_j69d97j wrote
[removed]
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j69bb9h wrote
Reply to comment by DontWakeTheInsomniac in What's the earliest case of iron-smelting with hard evidence? by Ok-Goose-6320
I'm more confused with their idea about "blooming" because from what I can tell it's clearly an early smelting technique involving heating the ore to purify it while smashing it
YsoL8 t1_j69b2sz wrote
Reply to comment by StupidBeardedGiraffe in Ancient statue of Hercules emerges from Rome sewerage repairs by Rob-Study-8562
What is reddits obsession with doomerism
Rob-Study-8562 OP t1_j6995k5 wrote
Here are more detailed photos from the Facebook page of the archeological site https://www.facebook.com/100080444869192/posts/pfbid07fUcA5siZsxreas6E51yeZYYx1i8SoFVijz3Sf6V9WQ8HspUfciavbfKCmkGMFbbl/
LA_Musician t1_j69766v wrote
Reply to comment by iisbarti in Ancient statue of Hercules emerges from Rome sewerage repairs by Rob-Study-8562
Iusius and Tiberclaud.
TheGreatOneSea t1_j6968i4 wrote
Reply to comment by Scruffy725 in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
Tunnels were very much used, generally to put explosives under defenses so the territory could be easily taken after the defenders were killed.
They weren't reliable though, because tunnel collapse was always a major risk, and defense in depth meant the enemy could pull back and make a new line of defense quicker than a massive tunnel could be made.
Nunya13 t1_j695tzh wrote
Reply to comment by YsoL8 in Ancient statue of Hercules emerges from Rome sewerage repairs by Rob-Study-8562
I always have trouble wrapping my brain around building cities on top of cities.
When we visited Seattle and took a tour, we went underground and saw all the structures that used to be above ground and were even still used when they rebuilt on top of it all. They even installed lights and glass in the walkways above so daylight would shine through.
It still trips me out to think about how people decide to just build on top of everything.
DontWakeTheInsomniac t1_j695pko wrote
Reply to comment by Constant_Count_9497 in What's the earliest case of iron-smelting with hard evidence? by Ok-Goose-6320
Anyone claiming the Romans invented iron is hardly worth debating history with in fairness.
jrhooo t1_j695b0l wrote
Reply to comment by Scruffy725 in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
there's many reasons why this wouldn't be practical, but for a start once your trench is within 50 yards of mine, how much further are you planning to dig?
Because anything within 40 yards, I can reliably toss hand grenades into your trench the whole time you're digging.
SteampunkDesperado t1_j694aes wrote
I appreciate how archaeologists keep pushing back the beginnings of human civilization. Take that, 6000-year Creationists!
[deleted] t1_j6943ob wrote
Reply to comment by Ancient_Boner_Forest in Archaeologists Uncover Oldest, And Most Complete Mummy Found In Egypt by Magister_Xehanort
[removed]
SteampunkDesperado t1_j6937kh wrote
What's the real story of the early Roman calendar? (The one that began in March and ended in December.) They didn't actually disregard two whole months, did they?
whyyoutookmyname t1_j6b2x52 wrote
Reply to Can someone explain to me why exactly Wu Tzu Hsu (6c. BC) was executed? by AlwaysBored10711
Wu Zixu (伍子胥) did not suggest the assassination. He helped Fu Chai (夫差), the King of Wu, by reforming their kingdom and building a formidable army. They defeated the Kingdom of Yue in the Battle of Fujiao (夫椒之战), and broke into the capital city of Yue. Gou Jian (勾践), the King of Yue, was trapped on the Kuaiji Mountain (会稽山) with his remaining force of 5000 soldiers.
At this point, Wu Zixu insisted on forming an alliance with the Kingdom of Qi, so they could wipe out the Kingdom of Yue and sentence the King of Yue to death. However, Gou Jian bribed Bo Pi (伯嚭), who managed the royal affairs in the Kingdom of Wu. Though Wu Zixu had more power in the kingdom, Bo Pi was much closer to the king.
Fu Chai was already content with the victory, so he followed Bo Pi's advice. Ignoring Wu Zixu's warning, Fu Chai accepted Gou Jian's surrender and withdrew from the Kingdom of Yue. Later, Bo Pi framed Wu Zixu and accused him of treason. Convinced by Bo Pi and deemed Wu Zixu guilty, Fu Chai sent Wu Zixu a sword and ordered him to commit suicide. Filled with anger, Wu Zixu took his own life.
In the end, Wu Zixu was correct. In 482 BC, Fu Chai defeated the Kingdom of Jin, the most powerful kingdom at the time. However, after Fu Chai brought most of his force to the war, the Kingdom of Wu was undefended. Gou Jian, after keeping his profile low for ten years, saw the opportunity and attacked the Kingdom of Wu. In 473 BC, Fu Chai was defeated in battle, and the Kingdom of Wu fell.