Recent comments in /f/history
Forsaken_Champion722 t1_j6hkp7h wrote
Reply to comment by akuthia in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
In a way, it's kind of like a reverse theocracy. Instead of the church telling the state what to do, the state is telling the church what to do.
lappy482 t1_j6hevch wrote
Reply to comment by LegionXIX in Bookclub and Sources Wednesday! by AutoModerator
The [David Rumsey Map Collection] (https://www.davidrumsey.com/) is superb for looking up specific maps from specific time periods - hopefully you should be able to find what you're looking for there!
Also - it's a bit more modern, but one map that absolutely fascinates me is the National Library of Scotland's digitalised [Ordnance Survey map of London from the 1890s] (https://maps.nls.uk/geo/explore/#zoom=10.0&lat=51.53214&lon=-0.12000&layers=188&b=1). It's incredibly detailed and shows you on a street-to-street level what London looked like 130 years ago. Plus, they also have a similarly detailed OS map of the city from the 1950s/60s, which lets you see how much the city changed over 60-70 years.
Thibaudborny t1_j6hdn4d wrote
Reply to comment by Gerasans in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
Probably not, why makes you think that? Bronze is indeed better than iron, but consider that the differences relate to usage/application. You can't, say, build skyscrapers with bronze, rather you'd need steel alloys for that. Similarly, there is a reason weapons are steel and statues are bronze. So sooner or later you'll hit a bottleneck in terms of usage, making it very unlikely we'd stick around with bronze forever.
geokek t1_j6hc60h wrote
Reply to comment by sundayscome in Bookclub and Sources Wednesday! by AutoModerator
I’m reading ‘The Shortest History of India’ now by John Zubrzycki. It covers India’s entire history so only the first half or so takes place before Britain arrives, but I’ve found it to be a good introduction which covers a lot of ground.
[deleted] t1_j6hbjkx wrote
[removed]
Mortar_Maggot t1_j6h74yi wrote
Reply to comment by SoLetsReddit in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
Because it was in the mud. The exposed parts did get obliterated, but a significant portion was actually protected by the silt and mud that encased it.
KombuchaBot t1_j6h521m wrote
KombuchaBot t1_j6h51jz wrote
Reply to comment by -mudflaps- in The Chickens and the Bulls: The Rise and Incredible Fall of a Vicious Extortion Ring That Preyed on Prominent Gay Men in the 1960s by PhillipCrawfordJr
Yeah but it was an important case because some Feds and some of the NYPD and the DA's office actually overcame their prejudices to help some gay men rather than victimising them and it happened before Stonewall.
Which is not to say it was an unmitigated success for justice.
I_AM_AN_ASSHOLE_AMA t1_j6h0b33 wrote
Reply to comment by why_did_you_make_me in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
Saw it last year. The size of it is astonishing. I knew it was big before going there, but was still surprised at how large it was, especially for the time period it’s from.
[deleted] t1_j6gxvns wrote
-mudflaps- t1_j6gxsq6 wrote
Reply to The Chickens and the Bulls: The Rise and Incredible Fall of a Vicious Extortion Ring That Preyed on Prominent Gay Men in the 1960s by PhillipCrawfordJr
Let me guess, a few scumbags setup prominent men to gather evidence they can use to extort money by threatening to expose them as homosexual?
amsterdam_BTS t1_j6fxxzl wrote
Reply to comment by DeRuyter67 in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
Done. Thanks.
It's very odd. I grew up speaking Dutch at home, and both my parents speak not just fluent but eloquent Dutch (university professor and literary translator) so my Dutch is very, very good, but has a weird accent and I know next to nothing about the history and political system. Gets me free beers and strange conversations whenever I'm in NL.
DeRuyter67 t1_j6fuxzb wrote
Reply to comment by amsterdam_BTS in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
Np haha. You can follow my account if you want to learn a bit more about it
amsterdam_BTS t1_j6fubb7 wrote
Reply to comment by DeRuyter67 in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
Ah. I grew up in the USA, so Dutch history is not my forte despite it being my first language.
why_did_you_make_me t1_j6fqoqx wrote
Reply to comment by qtx in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
I'll admit to not knowing if the condition of this particular wreck is such that it could be raised - it would be pure speculation on my (and I'd imagine your) part.
My point (poorly made) was that saying there's nothing left but dust is untrue. The Mary Rose was raised (and not from the Baltic), though she's in nowhere near the condition of the Vasa, and the article states that much of the hull here is intact as well.
Can and should this vessel be brought back up - I have no idea. Is it within the realm of possibility given what I know and what the article states? Yes.
GSilky t1_j6fqf6g wrote
Reply to comment by LateInTheAfternoon in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
Gotcha, now I'm going down the rabbit hole on this lol
DeRuyter67 t1_j6fq00g wrote
Reply to comment by ignoroids_triumph in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
The war would have happened anyway. This was just the first action and before the official Declaration of war. The English hoped to capture a very valuable merchant convoy while the Dutch were unprepared but it was still unsuccessful
DeRuyter67 t1_j6fpp34 wrote
Reply to comment by CopprRegendt in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
It was a smaller warship (just 44 guns) so I guess it fits. And no, it didn't carry colonists.
DeRuyter67 t1_j6fpgsz wrote
Reply to comment by amsterdam_BTS in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
That was during the War of the first coalition, more than a century later
DeRuyter67 t1_j6fpb6c wrote
Reply to comment by NorthOfTheBigRivers in Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
The French also contributed a fleet to the war at sea. The Ruyter defeated both fleets at the same time. In the action in which it was taken, the French however didn't participate
Gerasans t1_j6focs3 wrote
Would humanity still be in the bronze age if the tin would be widely available?
JasonRudert t1_j6fo8qs wrote
Reply to Mysterious shipwreck identified as Dutch warship that sank after surprise attack in 1672 - identified as the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia by ArtOak
Dutch King (or prime minister or whatever they had back then, idk): “It is as though a tiny version of our country has sunk. Sunk beneath the waves.”
Acceptable_Wall4085 t1_j6fl9i9 wrote
Reply to What proof is there that Dr. John Kellogg (that Kellogg) circumcised himself at age 37? by dazzlingupstairz
I read somewhere that he invented graham crackers to stop kids jerking off.
cphug184 t1_j6fjn6j wrote
Reply to comment by jezreelite in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
Well that was perfect! More advanced than I thought. And glad I didn’t live then. Thank you!
double-you t1_j6hnp7s wrote
Reply to comment by KombuchaBot in The Chickens and the Bulls: The Rise and Incredible Fall of a Vicious Extortion Ring That Preyed on Prominent Gay Men in the 1960s by PhillipCrawfordJr
Well...
> “We had all these big people around the country thinking our guys were really doing this, and it was starting to make us all look bad,” former rackets investigator Tobias Fennel explains. The class backgrounds of the victims certainly didn’t hurt,[...]
So had they not been rich and influential, they might have not gotten any help. But indeed they ended up helping gay men.