Recent comments in /f/history
[deleted] t1_j799gwv wrote
Reply to comment by RealVenom_ in Caribbean breadfruit traced back to Capt. Bligh's 1791-93 journey by Culturedecanted
[removed]
exorcyst t1_j7995qw wrote
Reply to comment by MyNameIsIgglePiggle in Caribbean breadfruit traced back to Capt. Bligh's 1791-93 journey by Culturedecanted
WTF I had no clue.. he didn't do well in his trial for mutiny iirc, he was brutal to his crew. The guy escaped mob rule death a few times apparently. Pure survivor though his 6500km journey in a banished skiff is incredible and likely never replicated. Very interesting character of history. Guys like him will never me made again. A mutant never considered for mass production
AngryBlitzcrankMain t1_j798i1e wrote
Reply to comment by ImOnlyHereCauseGME in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
I mean its not direct, but its one of the examples I am even aware of. Ivan III of Russia married the princess of Byzantine empire, niece of the emperor Constantine and started to use the title of gosudar (Grand Prince). His grandson Ivan the Terrible used his connection to the emperor of Byzantine empire and crowned himself the first Russian tsar, called Moscow the "third Rome", started to use Byzantine symbols as his own etc.
naughtabot t1_j797bex wrote
Anyone ever tried Mutiny vodka? It’s made from breadfruit, it’s super good, and gluten free! Cheap too.
theyfoundit t1_j7960f0 wrote
Reply to comment by en43rs in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Sorry - that part of my response was poorly worded, and you have quite clearly articulated what I had intended to say.
en43rs t1_j795ixv wrote
Reply to comment by Star-Lord0069 in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
That wrong. Rome didn’t impose its polytheism. According to Roman theology the Egyptian gods were basically the same as theirs. Traditional beliefs were kept in place with some Greek influences and some syncretism. The last traces we have of traditional Egyptian religion is around the 4th century AD.
When the Muslims arrived the country was Christian. And wasn’t imposed and neither was the shift quick. It’s only in the late Middle Ages that Islam became the majority religion.
Ok-Feedback5604 t1_j794yxz wrote
Reply to I'm the head of video at France’s leading newspaper Le Monde. Our team recreated Charles De Gaulle's lost 1940 recording for France to resist the Nazis using historical sources and artificial intelligence. AMA about our investigation. by LeMonde_en
How much you sure that this recreation is accurate?
sharksnut t1_j7949ua wrote
Reply to comment by infpTrojan in Caribbean breadfruit traced back to Capt. Bligh's 1791-93 journey by Culturedecanted
Or Shackleton to South Georgia
_MrSnippy_ t1_j7944fg wrote
Reply to Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Why didn't the Russian SSR not have a communist party of its own until Gorbachev made it happen?
_MrSnippy_ t1_j7941uu wrote
Reply to comment by PIGFOOF in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
can you provide a source on that wargame? I'm curious
ImOnlyHereCauseGME t1_j793tbt wrote
Reply to Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Are there any direct familial lines from any of the Roman/Byzantium emperors that later became leaders after those empires collapsed? Even if they were just puppets for others I would think the direct lineage with Rome might give them some legitimacy to rule.
negrote1000 t1_j793pv3 wrote
Reply to Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Did the police believe the Tate-LaBianca murders were done by black people or did they zeroed in on Manson immediately?
infpTrojan t1_j793ngp wrote
Reply to comment by RealVenom_ in Caribbean breadfruit traced back to Capt. Bligh's 1791-93 journey by Culturedecanted
Bligh’s journey after the mutiny is one of those incredible stories that’s almost impossible to believe. The Siege of Antioch during the First Crusade is another.
[deleted] t1_j79397y wrote
Reply to comment by canadianpastafarian in Caribbean breadfruit traced back to Capt. Bligh's 1791-93 journey by Culturedecanted
[removed]
Star-Lord0069 t1_j792x92 wrote
Reply to comment by en43rs in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Egypt had local polytheism (ancient Egyptian religion and mythology) before it was subjucated by Roman Empire. After which, the Roman polytheism was imposed on them. Egypt ultimately switched to Islamic faith when early Islamic empires conquered Egypt.
[deleted] t1_j791f5o wrote
Reply to comment by canadianpastafarian in Caribbean breadfruit traced back to Capt. Bligh's 1791-93 journey by Culturedecanted
[removed]
richvide0 t1_j7919b2 wrote
Reply to comment by flavortown_express in Caribbean breadfruit traced back to Capt. Bligh's 1791-93 journey by Culturedecanted
Oh God yes. With mayo-ketchup mmm.
We have have a breadfruit tree (we call it pana in Puerto Rico) but the damn thing hardly produces any fruit and when it does it's too high to harvest. Then I drive down the street and I see a tree teaming with them.
I was told to hit a rusty nail into the tree to help it produce. I did it. Haven't seen any results so far.
MeatballDom t1_j790v7k wrote
Reply to comment by avalon1805 in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Well there are a couple of different ways you can have this transfer of power (and this is by no means an exhaustive list).
You can have a complete territorial wipeout/genocide, population exchange, what have you where you're bringing in your own people and the old people are gone from the land. In such a case, you're really only bringing over the problems you already had, but the support as well.
You might chose to enslave the locals, which again, helps your problem of trying to win them over, but you do then risk a revolt.
You could try to intermarry, combine local and introduced populations.
Or, you can simply keep existing power structures in place with a new figurehead at the top. Instead of fighting for Emperor so and so, you now fight for me, when I call for you, you're marching for me. I might make you give up a certain amount of your army, or take some of your sons hostage where they will live in luxury in my home city just so you know there will be strong consequences if you try anything, but overall you get to keep the same local politicians, the same local bankers, businessmen, and the guy who ran the city previously now just listens to me, or maybe another big and respected member of the population who everyone already likes. You maintain your culture, your language, your art, and so forth.
Under the latter system, the common person probably wouldn't notice much of a change, but the more the conquering person interferes, the more effect it will have on you -- but also the greater chance you have of revolt, unless you just kill everyone. But if you kill everyone, you lose people to work the land, businesses that already thrived and could make money for you, specialised military units, and so on and so forth.
Sunnyjim333 t1_j790sqw wrote
Reply to comment by talltatanka in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Thank you, I was working off of transcriptions of Slave Narratives from the 1936-1938 WPA records and that is what was transcribed. Interesting reading if you get a chance.
one_salty_cookie t1_j78zvzf wrote
On Tobago, I've had it roasted and it is pretty bland. I think it would be better fried with some spices added. Nonetheless, I can see how it is a valuable starch for the diet.
phillipgoodrich t1_j78wmpr wrote
Reply to comment by xander_C in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Watch for map references to "licks." These are natural salt sources, typically from springs/brooks that are partially dry. In central Missouri, there are "Booneslick" everything: roads, trails, libraries, etc. All refer to a natural "salt lick" owned and operated by Daniel Boone and his kin through Nathan, just west of present-day Columbia, MO. But "licks" are found all over the forest lands of the midwest.
avalon1805 t1_j78wlm8 wrote
Reply to Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
How were the periods between changes of power? For example, I've been reading about alexander the great, how he conquered a lot of territories. What would happen to the common people in, let's say, central asia when Alxendar defeated the former power?
I know it would be different for every place and for every moment, such as when the western roman empire fell, or the ptolemies went to egypt.
xfjqvyks t1_j78vi5c wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Caribbean breadfruit traced back to Capt. Bligh's 1791-93 journey by Culturedecanted
See now, that’s just how they snare you. One minute you’re professing how immune you are to the charms, next minute you’re on the open seas committing multiple types of high treason
Well_why_not1953 t1_j78ut6s wrote
Reply to comment by xander_C in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Just to add what others are saying, don't forget trade. Pre-Columbian Indians had extensive trade networks to obtain what they could not get locally. Items from the great lakes area have been found all the way to the Gulf Coast and vice versa. Trade in the southern plains extended all the way to South America and the Pacific coast Salt was a great trade item.
exorcyst t1_j799jo8 wrote
Reply to comment by infpTrojan in Caribbean breadfruit traced back to Capt. Bligh's 1791-93 journey by Culturedecanted
Thanks for my next rabithole