Recent comments in /f/history
LoR_RalphRoberts t1_j7xdtfx wrote
Reply to In 1942, the U.S. forcibly evacuated 881 Unangax̂ (Aleut / Native Alaskans) from the Island of Atka, near Russia. Many watched as their homes and Churches were burned to keep the Japanese from getting them. In spite this, they remained patriotic and many enlisted in the U.S. Military. by triviafrenzy
The japanese did invade alaska, so it's not wholly without reason.
johnn48 t1_j7xbx7h wrote
Reply to comment by Clio90808 in Skeleton reveals lifestyle of medieval woman - BBC News by Mundane_Practice1
It would definitely call into question that it was brought to Europe by Columbus and his crews. I had always been told that syphilis was a New World disease. It’s sounding like it was more a case of being endemic and not recognized.
CupcakeValkyrie t1_j7xad6t wrote
Reply to comment by DraMaFlo in Skeleton reveals lifestyle of medieval woman - BBC News by Mundane_Practice1
To be fair, they didn't say it revealed a fun lifestyle, just a lifestyle.
LateInTheAfternoon t1_j7xabq6 wrote
Reply to comment by chicken_nugget08 in Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
There are not many works by ancient sceptics that have survived intact, but one that did is by the Pyrrhonist Sextus Empiricus. Problem is he was not an older Greek philosopher but a younger one (2nd century AD) and he was not translated and published in the west until the early modern era (late 16th century) so after the middle ages. You might want to look into it in case you've misremembered...
[deleted] t1_j7x3vjm wrote
[removed]
SushiMage t1_j7wjv9n wrote
Reply to comment by Goetterwind in Why didn't Japan excise Chinese characters from the Japanese language, when Japan hated China so much? by 3cana
> they are not exactly the same nowadays and back then…very close to tradditional
What. They are exactly the same characters which is the only reason I can even recognize them as someone who can only read chinese and not japanese. The characters are identical to what I see in chinese signs/books/internet forums. This is going to give a blantantly false impression to people.
Also keep in mind there are less than 100 kokuji characters while kanji numbers in the tens of thousands. It’s a weak attempt to severe the connection.
Clio90808 t1_j7w9eh0 wrote
Reply to comment by Mechanisedlifeform in Skeleton reveals lifestyle of medieval woman - BBC News by Mundane_Practice1
putative?
cnut4563 t1_j7vnge9 wrote
Reply to comment by Shadowsole in Best condensed history works? by SintagmaNominalMan
Excellent, thank you for taking the time to do this. Hope others find it useful too. (love it when Reddit works like this)
Mechanisedlifeform t1_j7vmxjk wrote
Reply to comment by Clio90808 in Skeleton reveals lifestyle of medieval woman - BBC News by Mundane_Practice1
>In the Apple Down cemetery in West Sussex, UK archaeologists uncovered the skeleton of a young man with extensive damage to both his skull and long bones, a combination typical of syphilis. He died in the sixth century AD. Ref 16 - Cole, G. and T. Waldron (2011) “Apple Down 152: a putative case of syphilis from sixth century AD Anglo-Saxon England.” American Journal of Physical Anthropology Jan;144(1):72-9. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.21371. Epub 2010 Aug 18. PMID 20721939.
Accujack t1_j7vkeb4 wrote
Reply to comment by rbk12spb in Skeleton reveals lifestyle of medieval woman - BBC News by Mundane_Practice1
History shows us it's rarely a good time to be a woman.
elmonoenano t1_j7villd wrote
Reply to comment by No-Strength-6805 in Bookclub and Sources Wednesday! by AutoModerator
Yeah, I have that one in my TBR pile.
No-Strength-6805 t1_j7vig7l wrote
Reply to comment by elmonoenano in Bookclub and Sources Wednesday! by AutoModerator
Guelzo is a favorite of mine try his Robert E Lee biography sometime .
unknown_jane t1_j7vfbrr wrote
Reply to Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
Did Dirlewanger and Kaminski ever met?
I'm doing some research about Nazi war crimes and I read about those two who are labeled as the worst war criminals ever. Since they both fought during Warsaw Uprising, I was wondering if they actually came to know each other.
OdonataDarner t1_j7va0ns wrote
Reply to comment by encisera in Skeleton reveals lifestyle of medieval woman - BBC News by Mundane_Practice1
How? Be chained in a Christian church.
WeeklyIntroduction42 t1_j7v6yly wrote
Reply to Bookclub and Sources Wednesday! by AutoModerator
Does anyone know any good books on Catalonia? Specifically 20th century Catalan history
elmonoenano t1_j7v46ms wrote
Reply to comment by No-Strength-6805 in Bookclub and Sources Wednesday! by AutoModerator
I enjoy the period around the US Civil War, so my favorites are from that period. I really like the Walter Stahr bios. He has a recent one out on Salmon Chase and an older one on Seward, but the one on Stanton is my favorite. I also really liked Allen Guelzo's Redeemer President on Lincoln. I think that's my favorite bio on Lincoln I've read.
Outside of that period I would maybe check out The Fire Is Upon Us by Nick Buccola. It's not quite a biography. It's about the debate between James Baldwin and William F. Buckley at the Cambridge Union. It gets into both people's lives and is very biographical, but it also has a lot of implications for current politics and the beginning of media driven soundbites that really drive the reasoning of the right.
[deleted] t1_j7v36wn wrote
Reply to Weekly History Questions Thread. by AutoModerator
[removed]
elmonoenano t1_j7v2dzx wrote
Reply to comment by Sacesss in Bookclub and Sources Wednesday! by AutoModerator
Thomas Asbridge has a good one on William Marshal. It's pretty short, it's well written, and has good notes if you find an area you want to learn more about. Marshal is a goods subject b/c he's got a Forest Gumpy quality for that period of England. He was around all the big players, went on crusade, was a popular tourney knight, etc. It's called The Greatest Knight. It's a great place to start for English knights. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/23456467-the-greatest-knight
dropbear123 t1_j7v145h wrote
Reply to comment by No-Strength-6805 in Bookclub and Sources Wednesday! by AutoModerator
No I haven't. The only other thing I could find is Ernest Bevin: Labour's Churchill by Andrew Adonis which I haven't read. The author is a Labour politician/lord with strong views about certain areas of foreign policy so isn't really writing from a position of neutrality.
rbk12spb t1_j7uz96k wrote
Reply to comment by encisera in Skeleton reveals lifestyle of medieval woman - BBC News by Mundane_Practice1
Probably contracted it before, or was abused by someone with it before she became a nun. Lots of women that were victims of abuse were shuttered away in convents to hide what was done, or were sent there for their own protection. Not a good time to be a woman
encisera t1_j7uxzyc wrote
How do you get syphilis if you’re walled into a cell to live a life of prayer and contemplation?
Clio90808 t1_j7uxq5m wrote
well if this is correct, it is a huge discovery as afaik syphilis hasn't been verified in Europe this early. see link on history of syphilis: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_syphilis
No-Strength-6805 t1_j7uwgug wrote
Reply to comment by dropbear123 in Bookclub and Sources Wednesday! by AutoModerator
Have you heard anything on a biography of Ernest Bevin union leader,Labour's activest and later Foreign Minister only thing I've found is 3 vol. Biography by Alan Bullock from 60s or 70s?
[deleted] t1_j7uvpgt wrote
[removed]
Billy1121 t1_j7xk01c wrote
Reply to comment by johnn48 in Skeleton reveals lifestyle of medieval woman - BBC News by Mundane_Practice1
They often hypothesized that it was related to yaws, another new world spirochete. But syphilis could have been one of those diseases lumped in with leprosy and such. Poorly understood