Recent comments in /f/history

Bentresh t1_j9k8at5 wrote

They are very dated, and I wish people would stop recommending them. It’s extremely insulting as an ancient historian to see so many people apparently believe that we’ve learned nothing of interest in the last 90 years. I wrote more about the first volume here.

Susan Wise Bauer’s History of the Ancient World is probably your best bet. For ancient Egypt in particular, I recommend Temples, Tombs, and Hieroglyphs and Red Land, Black Land by Barbara Mertz.

6

Businessinthedesert t1_j9k6c7o wrote

Currently reading “Hitler’s War” by Thomas Weber. A cumulative history of Hitler’s World War I military service. Only book I could ever find on the subject. It aims to disprove the myths expressed by Hitler in “Mien Kampf” about his WWI service as well as the common myth that it was the war itself that radicalized him.

3

haevy_mental t1_j9k0oig wrote

Currently reading Rise and Kill First. The Secret History of Israel's Targeted Assassinations by Rogen Bergman. It's very dense and dry but has a massive wealth of information on the Israel's response to constant threats of terrorism both within its borders and abroad.

2

Doctor_Impossible_ t1_j9jxm12 wrote

>medieval

When, because that's about a thousand years.

>to wear a leather vest+skirt combo over a full chainmail suit?

I don't think I've ever heard of such a thing.

>Or would it be more common to just wear some clothes over the mail if they wanted to show the colors of their master?

You might be thinking of a surcoat, jupon, or tabard, depending upon the era. These could be simple colours or embroidered, and while a squire would want to show his allegiance, for most of that era a man-at-arms wouldn't get the same sort of consideration, and many of them would be lucky to get a 'uniform'.

3

lyingcats t1_j9jx6zq wrote

I'm getting near to the end of Genghis Khan and the Making of the Modern World by Jack Weatherford, I'm really enjoying so I am wondering what I could read next?

I don't mind who it's about as long as it's a page turner like this is

4

panoplyofpoop t1_j9jwuja wrote

I'm also reading "the wars of reconstruction" which provides a more black centric viewpoint of all the challenges directly before and after emancipation. I feel like so much of the Civil War and wiring on slavery comes from the white viewpoint without considering the challenges individuals faced in the black community.

7

GhostfaceChase t1_j9jvfo2 wrote

Yes, thank you, that looks exactly like something I need to read next! I think it’s very interesting looking at how minorities in America reacted to America’s wars and I imagine the Civil War being one of the biggest moments of differing opinions on that matter. I’m also aware that during the Vietnam War there was a huge movement of black people refusing to serve even when drafted, I suppose that’s something I’ll need to read up on too.

It also brings into question whether or not someone should have to serve in the military to be a citizen. The idea of not being able to truly take part in your country’s institutions/government/etc unless you’re willing to fight and die in wars you had no say in starting is..troubling. Interesting, but troubling.

1

Micaiah4FEH t1_j9juzhh wrote

Best comprehensive single volume history of Spain (in English)?
I was hoping to find an overview history of Spain. There are a lot of them, and I'm not sure which one to read.I saw quite a few in my search:

The History of Spain by Peter PiersonSpain A Unique History by Stanley G. PayneA Concise History of Spain by Phillips

Any thoughts or recommendations?

5

Ranger176 t1_j9jn05d wrote

I’m currently reading a study about the roots of the Iraq War in preparation for the 20th anniversary of the invasion next month. Also on the shelf is Michael Holt’s book on the 1860 election, Adrian Brettle’s Colossal Ambitions about Confederate dreams of empire, and Erica Dunbar’s Never Caught about Washington’s pursuit of Ona Judge.

3

hergonthegreat t1_j9jkfqw wrote

This is the first time I've seen this thread...it's awesome! I'm not sure if it's been brought up yet, but there's a podcast called "battles of the first world war" by Mike Cunha. He goes in depth with major battles of WW1, and it's a great listen!

11

Crestedknight17 t1_j9jk74g wrote

I need a book on the Ancient world and very early civilization, places, and people's like Mesopotamia, Assyrians, Indus River valley civilization, and Babylonia, etc, But I need it to be entertaining, I am not a historian to me history is a fun hobby so I will lose focus and give up if I start reading the equivalent of a textbook, Basically I need a history book written like fan-fiction while still maintaining reality if anyone has a book that fits this description but not the time-frame feel free to still recommend it as I'll probably want to read eventually.

7