Recent comments in /f/history
[deleted] t1_itqjbcb wrote
Reply to Bookclub Wednesday! by AutoModerator
[removed]
tiramichu t1_itqhnp3 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
Because there is surviving historical record.
The 1600s were not as long ago as you think. People paid taxes. There were financial ledgers, and letters written, and paintings of significant things. And when the navy ordered an expensive warship there was certainly a contract with the shipyard.
It might seem like forever ago, but in the grand scheme it's pretty modern history.
And as well as records of when it was built, also records of how it was lost.
SeleucusNikator1 t1_itqfgy9 wrote
Reply to comment by rbajter in Thor’s hammer amulet discovered in Sweden - Arkeonews by GullyShotta
I wonder how old something has to be in order to be classified as a cultural relic owned by the state. How do you draw the line between "family heirloom great-grandpa gave me" and "artefact"?
SeleucusNikator1 t1_itqf1dy wrote
I wish these articles would be more clear in specifying that Samhain is a Scottish Gaelic name. For all we know, the Celtic Picts (who inhabited Scotland/Caledonia and were more closely related to the Welsh and Cumbrians) would not have called it that or necessarily celebrated in the same manner.
SeleucusNikator1 t1_itqeeny wrote
Reply to comment by Wwwweeeeeeee in Halloween in Scotland: 13 ancient customs and concepts of Celtic Halloween by MeatballDom
Gauls is a better term, "French Celts" is a bit weird since the name France derives from the Germanic Franks and French culture itself is a Romanized one at its core.
That being said, I find it unlikely to have been from Gaul. "Halloween" is a very North American and UK-Ireland type of thing, not something you find in the rest of Europe. The rest of the continent celebrates All Saints' Eve without costumes or apple bobbing and whatnot, instead they go to mass and pay their respects to dead family members.
In France, Spain, Portugal (all areas formerly inhabited by Celts the Romans conquered), Halloween traditions like trick or treating and costumes are seen as Americanisation and foreign.
SeleucusNikator1 t1_itqdlt5 wrote
Reply to comment by heinzbumbeans in Halloween in Scotland: 13 ancient customs and concepts of Celtic Halloween by MeatballDom
Would those Celtic territories celebrate Samhain in the same manner we think of? I think it's often understated that there was plenty of inner-Celtic diversity, for instance Irish and Scottish Gaelic are quite distinct from Welsh and Breton languages. The Romans largely only ruled over the Gauls, Britons, Iberians, etc. but never bothered with the Goidelic groups.
[deleted] t1_itqbxs4 wrote
trueslicky OP t1_itqay25 wrote
Reply to Katherine Swynford and the Illicit Affair That Birthed Centuries' Worth of British Monarchs by trueslicky
Interesting story about how a mistress with four illegitimate children can include amongst her descendants the House of Stuart, the Hanovers, and the Windsors--and also connected to six U.S. presidents.
ryschwith t1_itqad87 wrote
Reply to comment by Tidesticky in Archaeologists uncover Roman villa complex in Kent - HeritageDaily - Archaeology News by GullyShotta
I went to school for archaeology. Eventually decided it wasn’t for me. It’s a fascinating field but actually doing it involves many long, hot days hunched over in a hole and scraping at dirt with a trowel. It’s grueling. I’m glad others do it though.
grambell789 t1_itq9mh5 wrote
Reply to Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
I'm curious how ship building tech changed from about 1400 to 1600. I have read that steel for tools improved much during that period especially big rip saws that could cut the hull planks so they can be edge joined (carvel).
trueslicky t1_itq6fvl wrote
Mjolnr was found?
EzKafka t1_itq5eqh wrote
Reply to comment by fiendishrabbit in Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
Yeah, thats a big point to be honest. Sweden was mainly an inland sea. Danes had much more oceanic waters to handle. Also, the inclusion of British and Dutch navies screwing us both over to keep the balance was also a big help.
Cat5lover t1_itpx6vg wrote
Reply to comment by War_Hymn in Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
I believe it was also this. In spirit of collaboration, the Dutch did one side and the Swedes did the other. The unfortunate part was that the Dutch inch and the Swedish inch are slightly different which led to one side being heavier than the other causing it to lean too far to one side and take on water some few hundred meters from shore.
WoodAlcoholIsGreat t1_itpwocp wrote
Reply to comment by lurkarrunt in Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
I am sorry to hear of your suffering..
fiendishrabbit t1_itpurev wrote
Reply to comment by EzKafka in Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
The swedish navy has always played second fiddle to the swedish army.
Also, while the "örlogsflottan" (open water navy) frequently performed poorly the archipelago fleet (consisting of galleys, gunsloops and the smaller archipelago frigates) mostly performed quite well (like Frisches Haff, Nöteborg and the second battle of Svensksund).
rbajter t1_itpup4b wrote
Reply to comment by fredagsfisk in Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
Source is Krigshistoriepodden episode 123 so it might have been abused for effect.
rbajter t1_itpukui wrote
Reply to comment by fiendishrabbit in Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
Yeah, the source is Krigshistoriepodden episode 123 so I’m not surprised if it was generalised for effect.
War_Hymn t1_itpugjs wrote
Reply to comment by automatvapen in Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
If I recall, the designer (a Dutch master shipwright) was bedridden from illness during the Vasa's construction and his nephew or assistant took over the project. The ship ended more top heavy than it should had been, contributing to it's instability.
I'm sure the later sister ships were built with improvements and changes, keep in mind the Vasa was at the cutting edge of ship design at the time - they were trying build not only large, but fast.
Fleischer444 t1_itpttjj wrote
Reply to comment by VeryOriginalName98 in Thor’s hammer amulet discovered in Sweden - Arkeonews by GullyShotta
Neil Geiman has a new book has some fantastic stories of Norse Mythology. It’s also the name of the book. Audible has it as audiobook.
outerworldLV t1_itprk6k wrote
Reply to comment by Bentresh in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
Imo, it would have to do with the French and German archeologists that did a lot of work there.
outerworldLV t1_itpr737 wrote
Reply to comment by kojohn11 in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
What about the time of the Cathar’s ? And when the Knight Templars were there ?
outerworldLV t1_itpqqnr wrote
Reply to comment by Tidesticky in Archaeologists uncover Roman villa complex in Kent - HeritageDaily - Archaeology News by GullyShotta
I am so with you there. Always wanted to be an archeologist !!
EzKafka t1_itpqj4r wrote
Reply to comment by fiendishrabbit in Archaeologists have found the 17th-century warship Applet: Maritime experts believe wreck is sister-ship of Vasa, which sank off Stockholm in 1629 by MeatballDom
We had such a long coast but yet we had a horrible trackrecord on the sea. The Danes beat us to it many times.
SalsaForte t1_itqk95m wrote
Reply to comment by ryschwith in Archaeologists uncover Roman villa complex in Kent - HeritageDaily - Archaeology News by GullyShotta
It's not like being Indiana Jones? Screw it!