Recent comments in /f/history
BattleofPlatea OP t1_iwykfyd wrote
Reply to comment by frenchchevalierblanc in What was life in the Balkan Front during ww1 like? by BattleofPlatea
I'll give it a watch thank you
fishkrate t1_iwyj7jh wrote
Reply to comment by Slow-Season-310 in What was life in the Balkan Front during ww1 like? by BattleofPlatea
Actually, they kept suffering.
frenchchevalierblanc t1_iwye6bd wrote
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4neKuY0i9rI
"Capitain Conan" is a french movie in WW1 in the Balkans, from a famous 1920s french book writen by a former soldier that fought on the "orient front".
Slow-Season-310 t1_iwy9gx7 wrote
Reply to comment by DirectCaterpillar916 in What was life in the Balkan Front during ww1 like? by BattleofPlatea
I guess the only laughter they get is when they know the war is over and they won't have to suffer any longer.
MeatballDom t1_iwy870t wrote
Reply to comment by swagonflyyyy in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
It's fairly complicated, but here's a good rundown of the issues here https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2jhahz/who_is_the_first_historically_verifiable_pope_of/
ExxKonvict t1_iwxmfb3 wrote
Should watch the Serbian movie King Petar or something. It’s Serbian point of view of WW1 against the Austrian-Hungarian Empire (which consisted of other Balkans such as Croats, Slovenes, and Bosnians).
swagonflyyyy t1_iwxgncz wrote
Who was the actual first pope?
torustorus t1_iwxgaf2 wrote
Reply to comment by Al-Pharazon in What was life in the Balkan Front during ww1 like? by BattleofPlatea
At least earlier on there was the see saw of Austrian invasion, fumbling, and retreat. Battle of Cer and all that.
YoungLefebvre t1_iwxcdjo wrote
Reply to Bookclub Wednesday! by AutoModerator
Currently reading David Herbert Donald
Pakislayer71 t1_iwwowl4 wrote
I imagine very difficult. Lol.
Since the Balkans were part of the ottoman empire, which was losing its hegemony, it lost not just the morale but other forms of support. At least that's what I perceive.
Al-Pharazon t1_iwwm5hg wrote
Reply to comment by torustorus in What was life in the Balkan Front during ww1 like? by BattleofPlatea
And before reaching Salonika it also was very static. The Austrians where not exactly successful in pushing through the mountains in Serbia and Montenegro, so for a long time the front moved very little.
Then Serbia did collapse and then came Salonika, which was the very definition of drôle de guerre
Important_Collar_36 t1_iwwlihn wrote
Reply to comment by erinraspberry in Hundreds of mummies and pyramid of an unknown queen unearthed near King Tut's tomb by IslandChillin
I wasn't gonna give it away, but yeah
erinraspberry t1_iwwfgwk wrote
Reply to comment by Important_Collar_36 in Hundreds of mummies and pyramid of an unknown queen unearthed near King Tut's tomb by IslandChillin
Not just the cat mummies but a MF LION CUB MUMMY!!!!! The little kid in me who was obsessed with ancient egypt as a child just about died from excitement
torustorus t1_iwvvvwh wrote
Reply to comment by BattleofPlatea in What was life in the Balkan Front during ww1 like? by BattleofPlatea
Ok so I have to tell you the Balkan front when it gets to Salonika, was very static. Alled forces had problems with malaria if I recall correctly.
Some of the other responses here have confused Balkan front for Eastern Front where the warfare was somewhat more dynamic due to the size of the front and some geologic restrictions that prevented trench fortresses like were found on the western front.
Doubelo7 t1_iwvvtv7 wrote
Reply to comment by pulpogigante in Bookclub Wednesday! by AutoModerator
Good suggestion! Didn’t realize he had a prequel so thank you for that. I’ve read a bit further and with the help of the included list of characters I’m able to start understanding now. The switching between nicknames, first names, and surnames for the same character threw me off a lot but it’s coming together now. Definitely reading the prequel next, should’ve started with that.
Understanding the way the old Tsarist and then the Bolshevik govt works also helped a ton. Spent a few days reading about that and the power struggles start to make more sense now.
Thank you!
BattleofPlatea OP t1_iwvuf9f wrote
Reply to comment by Think_History_5682 in What was life in the Balkan Front during ww1 like? by BattleofPlatea
There was also a bit of trench warfare in the end.
But that's an interesting thing about ww1. I've never understood how it would work in a mobile way. I can't seem to picture troops not charging out of trenches and I don't know why.
Think_History_5682 t1_iwvu2g4 wrote
It was more mobile than the western front a lot of taking and retaking of territory
Southern2002 t1_iwvt5z8 wrote
There was extremely cold mountain warfare in the carpathians for example. Some of the things you see in the alps apply, though the Russia had more supply problems. Miserable, frigid warfare.
[deleted] t1_iwvk81b wrote
[removed]
Proof-Operation5913 t1_iwvjbe7 wrote
What does everyone believe about the reichstag fire? Was it van Der Lubbe,or something bigger?
DirectCaterpillar916 t1_iwuycww wrote
My grandfather fought in the Balkans as a Sargeant with the South Wales Borderers. He was gassed and taken prisoner in 1917 and sent to a POW camp in Bulgaria. He said they were very badly treated and he suffered from ill health for the rest of his life. So... Not a lot of laughs, really.
[deleted] t1_iwtvbg8 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Hundreds of mummies and pyramid of an unknown queen unearthed near King Tut's tomb by IslandChillin
[removed]
TheTankiest t1_iwtgsyp wrote
Reply to Bookclub Wednesday! by AutoModerator
I'm not sure if I'm allowed to make a second comment here, but: any resources on Britain's colonization of India and life during/after the colonization process?
Larielia t1_iwstt2b wrote
Reply to Bookclub Wednesday! by AutoModerator
What are your favourite books about the ancient Near East?
I'm also looking for books about ancient Asia Minor.
[deleted] t1_iwyq1jk wrote
Reply to A Medieval Gold Wedding Ring Found in the Mud Worth Is Thousands by max-venum
[deleted]