Recent comments in /f/history
OMightyMartian t1_iyw7j1p wrote
Reply to comment by Mark7A in Meet a medieval woman named 'Tora' who lived 800 years ago in Norway by patatesogan
When 800 years old you reach, look as good as her you will not!
Mark7A t1_iyw714j wrote
She looks fantastic for being 800 years old
[deleted] t1_iyw70n8 wrote
[removed]
elderforest t1_iyw6n4d wrote
I’ve read that there is 6 shared powers between the United States federal government, and state governments but couldn’t find what the 6 are! Anyone have any ideas?
[deleted] t1_iyw6lx5 wrote
Reply to comment by Daripuff in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
[removed]
bangdazap t1_iyw5r4l wrote
Reply to comment by sciguy52 in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
Following the fall of (Western) Rome, the economy cratered and the money that went into maintaining the academies where copies of written works were made disappeared. Books do not last forever, and in those days they had to be copied by hand, an expensive and time-consuming enterprise. The people who were literate in those days were Christian scholars who didn't have much interest in preserving historical and scientific tracts.
recoveringleft t1_iyw3eri wrote
Reply to comment by Drops-of-Q in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
It doesn’t help that there are many movies and tv shows relating to ancient Egypt like the mummy movies, yugioh and moon knight
La_danse_banana_slug t1_iyw2wzv wrote
Reply to comment by ItsAll42 in What was history class like before the modern era? by SunsetShoreline
You're honestly better off Googling it, sorry. I read this in bits and pieces ages ago and don't remember where.
Drops-of-Q t1_iyvy4nn wrote
Reply to comment by Trackmaster15 in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
That is the sort of question any decent historian or archeologist ponder.
But I'll also say that it is more in popular science that Egypt is the greatest civilization of all time. That goes back to when the ancient Egyptian culture was rediscovered. It was the first to be studied scholarly to any degree which is why Egyptology was an entire field of study, but not Indus-Valley-Civilizationology
Thibaudborny t1_iyvxbz5 wrote
Reply to comment by Peggy_Sue_Johnsen in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
There are only a finite amount of routes any large group of men can take. Mountains? They'll take the pass. Rivers? They'd take the crossings. Swamps? They'd go around. Forests? They'd go around (if possible) or take the few roads available. And so on. Then, it becomes a case of scouting those limited options.
Trackmaster15 t1_iyvwbr2 wrote
Reply to comment by Daripuff in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
Could this maybe imply that other ancient civilizations were as advanced as Ancient Egypt, but we just give more credit to Egypt because it was so much better preserved?
koloquial t1_iyvv8lf wrote
Reply to comment by LateInTheAfternoon in What was history class like before the modern era? by SunsetShoreline
What was your point then?
Also just because MDs and JDs are not PhDs, does not remove both medicine and law from the metaphysics (philosophy) umbrella. In fact you can get a PhD in both those disciplines.
koloquial t1_iyvuwxz wrote
I_might_be_high_rn t1_iyvrr8w wrote
Reply to comment by ObeseBackgammon in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
Yeah I didn't see any references or allusions to Christianity either. Idk what that person was talking about
Choppergold t1_iyvr0l8 wrote
Reply to comment by acm2033 in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
The end of the Hellenistic age and the beginning of the Roman. Cleopatra was not only Egyptian but descended from the Ptolemy who served Alexander the Great himself. Gets forgotten, that Macedonian Greek heritage in Egypt from 300 BC to when Cleopatra killed herself
thedudeslandlord t1_iyvpzcw wrote
The one thing they don’t teach about in history class
Haffrung t1_iyvpa0h wrote
History was what we consider Classics today: Herodotus, Homer, Thucydides, Livy, Plutarch. Up until well into the 20th century, the works of Plutarch were probably the most read history in the West. They're essentially mini-bios of famous leaders and generals of antiquity, with an emphasis on their moral character.
These bios were instructive to Western elites, who were encouraged to champion the values demonstrated by Plutarch's nobler subjects - courage, loyalty, civic-mindedness. If you were an educated man in the 19th and early 20th century, you were expected to be able to talk about Pericles, Alcibiades, Caesar, etc.
acm2033 t1_iyvowy9 wrote
Reply to comment by PitoPlankton3415 in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
Instead of being a Roman settlement, Egypt was largely left alone for a while under the Ptolymies. They already had agriculture (which was very different than the rest of the Roman world), language, a system of government, and economy that worked. No need for the Romans to come in and establish things that were already there.
That changed after Cleopatra backed Mark Antony in the civil war, and lost. Octavian made Egypt a province to be governed through Rome, rather than an independent state.
The whole blog is about a 30 min read, well worth the time.
MoogTheDuck t1_iyvofay wrote
Reply to comment by PartySquirrel1 in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
I've read his whole blog. Its excellent.
[deleted] t1_iyvoc5d wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
[removed]
[deleted] t1_iyvnirt wrote
Reply to comment by ObeseBackgammon in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
[deleted]
Daripuff t1_iyvmqv1 wrote
Reply to Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
Point number 1 is very interesting.
Egypt is the only place in the Roman Empire with a "full" urban infrastructure (with a large and culturally complex population centers) "in" the fully arid desert (the only greenery was provided by irrigation, both natural (annual floods) or artificial), which allowed commoner's trash to be preserved for archeologists in a way that couldn't manage elsewhere. Thus we got insights into the day to day life of a commoner in Roman Egypt in a way that we have never gotten anywhere else in the empire.
ObeseBackgammon t1_iyvkk5b wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
Where does it do that? I didn't notice anything like that, other than a fairly sober and normal discussion of Egyptian-Roman religious syncretism
[deleted] t1_iyvkhy9 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Why Roman Egypt was such a strange province by oni64
[removed]
girnigoe t1_iyw7me0 wrote
Reply to comment by Mark7A in Meet a medieval woman named 'Tora' who lived 800 years ago in Norway by patatesogan
yeah, I thought the picture was ridiculous, why show her as an old person rather than in the prime of her life? But I guess (after reading the article) that that’s what skeletal info they had.