Recent comments in /f/movies
Mahdahrah t1_j9isy0v wrote
Reply to comment by Streets-Ahead- in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
Right, Pixar dropped the ball. but I thought thats how Chris Evans described it initially like he's the man the toy is based on.
The unused movie within movie idea is still great regardless.
paulteegoldman t1_j9isxkn wrote
Reply to comment by Mestewart3 in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
Box office success doesn’t correlate with quality. Plenty of mediocre to good movies have bombed. You’re thinking in capitalistic terms
kiwi-66 t1_j9is3rc wrote
SPOILER ALERT:
Gladiator is literally a remake of a 1964 epic called The Fall of the Roman Empire.
Anyway, both movies take lots of liberties with the facts. The central plot is one example. In both movies, Commodus has a rivalry with Livius/Maximus and ends up duelling him to the death (this didn't happen in real life). Also, the rival has a romance with Lucilla (Commodus' sister) which is also fiction.
Nevertheless, both movies are worth a watch if you're not that interested about historical accuracy and just want a decent movie.
r2d_touche t1_j9iru3b wrote
Reply to comment by EldridgeHorror in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
I thought the same, then that cat surprised me as being the one fun part of the movie.
h00n23 t1_j9irrnq wrote
Reply to comment by R12B12 in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
I am Asian not even white why are you assuming my race? Thank you is my english good enough to sound like white American .
Most people here don't want to watch lgb shows or movie. I am just telling you truth. Nothing else what is my mistake if truth is bitter for you? Do you want me to lie? Lgbq is very big minority even in USA. I have family there lol
If you want to do huge business then you need to make something that conservative also enjoy. In many Asian countries conservative are majority. And big percentage of USA
I am seeing American media becoming less popular everyday in my and other Asian countries because of wokism.i myself mostly watch Asian media these days I don't care about race of actor as long they're attractive and good actor. Zendaya is brown and i like her she is cute.
jawise t1_j9irbr1 wrote
I really liked this movie. I can't imagine a kid liking it
Relative-Ad-87 t1_j9iqv2b wrote
Reply to comment by skarros in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
Easy. Time = distance + speed. Or something
It's all relative...
Mestewart3 t1_j9iquwy wrote
Reply to comment by paulteegoldman in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
It certainly wasn't good enough to get butts in seats.
The movie bombed, and it didn't do so because it was too challenging. Pixar made their name doing that shit. There is no way that Lightyear was a more challenging film than Up for example.
goliathfasa t1_j9iqq4i wrote
Watch them make a b&w Woody film in the John Wayne western style and wonder why it also bombs at the box office.
Auran82 t1_j9iqjr8 wrote
Reply to comment by OnlyMamaKnows in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
In my opinion, the plot is too complex for a kids movie, but the actual writing is way too toddler level for most adults to enjoy. Most of the time the resolution for any issues they came across (that were almost always caused by someone doing something dumb) were basically Paw Patrol level.
And I mean seriously, if Andy had watched that movie Woody would have been riding around on a Sox the Cat toy.
skarros t1_j9iqhc1 wrote
Reply to comment by Maskedcrusader94 in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
Well, it is Einstein‘s relativity theory. Who does understand that really? Explaining it to a six year old seems like a fun challenge though.
AloneCan9661 t1_j9iqeua wrote
Reply to comment by Anora6666 in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
You know what I mean and your violent reaction shows that you wouldn’t even listen to anything I had to say.
Two women kissing, let alone people kissing shouldn’t be in a movie geared for kids…Disney has gone all out on this and their results have proved to be disastrous.
Syhkane t1_j9iqba0 wrote
Maybe zerg being buzz was a dog shit twist and everything related to the cartoon for the nearly 100% of people this movie would have mattered to was invalidated
improvmama101 t1_j9iq6kk wrote
I loved Lightyear and think the general public have no taste.
securitywyrm t1_j9iq6bh wrote
Reply to comment by OnlyMamaKnows in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
A thought for a better movie
It's a movie about the actors FILMING the movie of Buzz Lightyear, a kinda stock childrens cartoon fare of the 80s. However the Buzz actor is a "method actor" and gets too much of an ego, tensions flare, and people have to pull together and have some heart to heart moments to get the movie finished, "because it's not about us, it's about the kids who will be inspired by it."
And then after-credits scene of adult Andy working at NASA
BigBootyBuff t1_j9iq2ct wrote
Reply to comment by Pitiful_Pain2474 in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
That and the Hercules show are two Disney shows I never hear people talk about even though they were great fun. They aren't even on Disney+, at least where I live.
Thrug t1_j9ipyh8 wrote
Reply to comment by whitepangolin in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
> It's not the audiences' fault for not understanding the movie. It's Pixar's fault for not understanding their own character.
This reeks of "do you guys not have phones" arrogance. Sad to see Pixar go the way of Blizzard, but with this attitude it's almost guaranteed they won't recover.
R12B12 t1_j9ipw1l wrote
Reply to comment by h00n23 in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
Aah okay. There’s no need to hide behind the favorite code word of right wing bigots, “woke.” Just say you want to go back to the days when lgbtq, Black and brown people were marginalized and movies solely focused on straight white people.
longshot24fps t1_j9ipqt4 wrote
Better for them to have done this as a standalone movie with a new character at a lower budget. I Ben if it failed, they would have lost a lot less $$ and not punched a hole in their Toy Story franchise.
“We asked too much of the audience” reeks of condescension: it’s not our fault you didn’t want to buy tickets to our movie. Toy story is the gold standard of Pixar and Disney animated franchises. Lightyear was an ok movie, but they chose to cut ties with Buzz Lightyear, a character they’d spent decades building. For a beloved animated character, altering the look and replacing the voice is guaranteed to throw an audience. Nothing against Chris Evans, but imagine replacing Tom Hanks with him for Woody with similar changes. It’s just not Woody any more. Yes, Pixar says this is the movie Andy watched, but they’re not fooling anyone.
Pixar has made some of the best animated films ever. I hope they get their mojo back.
Emperor_TaterTot t1_j9ipqbn wrote
Reply to comment by SkilletBillet in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
That’s how I read this too. He’s blaming the audience but the movie just wasn’t great in reality. Looks like he can’t see past the work.
contaygious t1_j9ipozg wrote
Honestly none of the plot should matter. Kids don't go to a movie for the plot and no one really knows before they see it. The appeal is or buzz himself and thafs it.
My six year old daughter loves the movie so I dunno what to say lol
contaygious t1_j9ipla8 wrote
Reply to comment by OnlyMamaKnows in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
I still don't understand frozen 2 myself but my daughter seems to get it lol
boot2skull t1_j9ipfgd wrote
Reply to comment by _Gemini_Dream_ in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
I think you can have the serious Buzz or source material Buzz, but it had to be first, not the other way around. We love toy Buzz. We want toy Buzz. We want Buzz and Woody together. I don’t think we’re interested in source material Buzz now that we’ve had Toy Buzz. Besides, did Lightyear even match the tone of what we imagine the source material to be like to create a toy like Buzz?
Seems like a Star Wars problem, where you let the IP live in our heads too long, then add to it. You are going to have to be perfect to make most of the fans happy, and even then, not everyone will be happy. You can gauge how old a person is by how offended they are by each trilogy.
Barneyk t1_j9ipbau wrote
Reply to comment by Hi_Im_zack in Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
>He said they made the mistake of assuming enough people will understand the film
Yeah, and the problem isn't that we didn't understand it, the problem is that it wasn't very good.
We understood it fine.
(But I can understand why kids weren't that excited about it.)
IfYouWantTheGravy t1_j9itmnc wrote
Reply to Pixar head Pete Docter on why Lightyear failed by JannTosh17
It didn't feel like a 90s SF-action film - and definitely not one a kid would've considered his favorite movie.
My headcanon is Andy saw Strange Days instead.