Recent comments in /f/nyc

Dont_mute_me_bro t1_je1oie4 wrote

??? The non Jewish population of NYC is overwhelmingly Roman Catholic. I'm a native and with the exception of a few Scandinavians in Bay Ridge, have never met a native born WASP New Yorker. Since this is the UFT, and since it's about educators in the NYC public school system, whatever the "Dominant" history in America may be (and we disagree), it's not "White Protestant" here.

4

NetQuarterLatte t1_je1oi53 wrote

The gist is that you were trying to associate covid and crimes.

I get that you’re saying it’s not the sole cause, but even if factually true (your statement would still be technically true if Covid was not a cause at all), it’s still misleading in the overarching context of the conversation.

Even in the US, Covid didn’t hit every city at the same time. The staggered manner in which Covid hit US locations can be used to show a causal relationship of Covid and Crimes, if that exists. However there’s basically no evidence of that.

In fact, NYC got Covid waves earlier than most cities. But even in 2022 we had crimes still rising in NYC faster than other big cities like LA, Chicago and Miami.

0

movingtobay2019 t1_je1nwp7 wrote

Agreed.

But said housing does not have to be in the most expensive city in the world. You can house way more people up state and provide more services for the same budget.

There is literally no reason to house them in NYC. They are from NYC? Beggars can't be choosers - otherwise you introduce perverse incentives.

8

movingtobay2019 t1_je1l919 wrote

Solving homelessness doesn't have to involve housing them in the most fucking expensive piece of real estate in the country.

It's people like you who care less about homelessness and just want to stick it to people who are better off than you.

I'd easily support a bill where NYC raised my taxes to house homeless upstate where land is cheaper and get them in programs to help them integrate back in society. But not this shit.

17

movingtobay2019 t1_je1jxif wrote

Since when did living in NYC become a right?

But that's besides the point. You are too focused on the needs of one group of people.

What happens when there are no price signals in the market? Who determines where who lives? The corrupt NYC government?

What happens when capital flows out of real estate and no one builds anymore because you capped rental increases? Where are new people coming to the city going to live?

What happens when you limit rent increases to the point it doesn't cover taxes, utilities, or maintenance? What, LLs just going to eat the loss? Print money in their basement?

There are so many factors and stakeholders that advocates like you gloss over.

31