Recent comments in /f/philosophy
Fever_Raygun t1_iyi0cm7 wrote
Reply to comment by kaustickelpie in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Do you just like dioramas in general?
WoodenRain2987 t1_iyhzhh4 wrote
Reply to comment by Hedlundman in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Watch out, you just pissed off the post-structuralists
ExHaltzorocoaster t1_iyhz2jl wrote
Reply to comment by wintrysilence in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
They have Christmas songs for that too!
Chuckles52 t1_iyhyq0o wrote
Reply to Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
There is a physical connection. At some level we are aware that the Sun is returning (based on memory of experience). More than the fairly recent Christian meaning, it is tied to eons of animal experience in the northern hemisphere.
beingforelorn t1_iyhyjj0 wrote
Reply to comment by realchoice in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Indeed, what is?
realchoice t1_iyhydtl wrote
Reply to comment by beingforelorn in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Indeed, they are.
realchoice t1_iyhy7ux wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
I'm German, and coca-cola had nothing to do it with our Christmas celebrations or our nostalgia. Infact I grew up ok. A house where we didn't watch television and were expressly forbidden from drinking soft drinks.
beingforelorn t1_iyhy429 wrote
Reply to comment by WhatsUpMyBrothers in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
And in your eyes what makes Christmas awesome, engage in the philosophical inquiry of your feelings.
Do you feel its awesome because of your experiences or have you studied the history around Christmas and can include things that I may be ignorant of?
Simply saying its awesome doesn't provide anything for conversation, does it?
Hedlundman t1_iyhxsxs wrote
Reply to comment by Friendcherisher in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Our reality is limited by our senses. It doesn't make it less real but perception is fun.
WhatsUpMyBrothers t1_iyhxo9v wrote
Reply to comment by beingforelorn in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Christmas is awesome
FatassTitePants t1_iyhxfwp wrote
Reply to comment by wintrysilence in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
For me, it's bittersweet but in a good way. I'm likely past the midpoint of my life and I do feel nostalgic but sad about how much loss I've experienced simply as a product of getting older and " things just aren't the same anymore."
On the other hand, I see it as my duty to make Christmas as fun and magical for my kids and other younger people, and that brings me a tremendous sense of joy and purpose this time of year.
Dejan05 t1_iyhwsmv wrote
Reply to Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
What that's a thing? All I feel on Christmas is dread, just another reminder of the cyclic nature of life and its finite nature, but maybe I'm just weird lol
earthtochas3 t1_iyhwopr wrote
Reply to comment by terepede in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Not at all! Just haven't seen it written out in months probably and now I've seen it like three times in the past 24 hours.
earthtochas3 t1_iyhwlob wrote
Reply to comment by pinupgal in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
No, my girlfriend did and I thought it might be one of those Baader-Meinhof type things!
beingforelorn t1_iyhwgd5 wrote
Reply to comment by KingOfTheCaucasians in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
You shouldn't feel sorry, thats part of the oppressive nature of the season. We can all feel however we want about the season and none of those feelings are inherently wrong or sad or pitiful.
BernardJOrtcutt t1_iyhw7fy wrote
Reply to Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Please keep in mind our first commenting rule:
> Read the Post Before You Reply
> Read/listen/watch the posted content, understand and identify the philosophical arguments given, and respond to these substantively. If you have unrelated thoughts or don't wish to read the content, please post your own thread or simply refrain from commenting. Comments which are clearly not in direct response to the posted content may be removed.
This subreddit is not in the business of one-liners, tangential anecdotes, or dank memes. Expect comment threads that break our rules to be removed. Repeated or serious violations of the subreddit rules will result in a ban.
This is a shared account that is only used for notifications. Please do not reply, as your message will go unread.
beingforelorn t1_iyhw6qt wrote
Reply to comment by Butterfly_853 in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
The notion that the Christmas season as a whole is useful to offset the hardships that the year as a whole has held is likely close to the heart of Christmas, and the growth of the season to 2-3 months could be representative of the dismal and dreadful existences we have come to live in our day to day lives.
But why couple that with the religious theft and oppression that Christmas represents, why not dismiss Christmas and celebrate exactly what you said? That is the oppressive nature of Christmas, everyone is all too willing to ignore its ugliness and accept its boons.
Historically Christmas was made to pacify pagans through their indoctrination into Christianity, we have come to ignore the way Christmas has become what it is in a similar way to how white privilege is institutionalized in modern America. Ignorance is bliss I suppose, but such bliss is oppressive, zealous, and wasteful.
KingOfTheCaucasians t1_iyhw6ey wrote
Reply to comment by beingforelorn in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Sorry you feel that way
kaustickelpie t1_iyhvu2k wrote
Reply to comment by ThalesBakunin in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Lol I'm an atheist who fucking loves Christmas too and ironically my favorite thing to collect are nativity scenes. Fucking love those things and I have no good reason why lol
terepede t1_iyhvth0 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Is wistful a weird word or something?
Friendcherisher t1_iyhv419 wrote
Reply to comment by Critya in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
If you put it that way, reality itself becomes a social construct if we follow Baudrillard's and Goffman's line of thinking.
Butterfly_853 t1_iyhv2j9 wrote
Reply to comment by beingforelorn in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Christmas is about nostalgia and hope , not oppression or wastefulness . We use this period every year to celebrate the good experiences we’ve had with family and friends during what would ordinarily be a difficult time of year . When you think of Christmas you think of the magical feeling you had around it as a child , and that’s why it’s so nice as an adult to reminisce on that magic again . This is my take on Christmas anyway , that it’s a brilliant excuse to spend time with family and friends that we may not have seen much throughout the hustle and bustle of the year , and to make memories that aren’t clouded over .
beingforelorn t1_iyhucpl wrote
Reply to comment by EldritchAnimation in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Doesn't sound oppressive in the slightest, amazing point. Quote the grinch and prove my point further...
Lemmings to a cliff.
haveanotherdrinkray_ t1_iyhtzy2 wrote
Reply to comment by frecklesmcnerdy in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
Who's pressuring you?
cmilliorn t1_iyi14n9 wrote
Reply to comment by ThalesBakunin in Why “the Christmas feeling” is more profound than you think - some holiday themed philosophy by Melodic_Antelope6490
One of us, one of us!