Recent comments in /f/singularity
CornellWest t1_j9ti2lf wrote
Reply to What are the big flaws with LLMs right now? by fangfried
When they don't know the answer they bullshit with 100% confidence
Nukemouse t1_j9thvgk wrote
Reply to comment by beezlebub33 in What are the big flaws with LLMs right now? by fangfried
Pardon me but isnt the life long learning one intentional as they limit its ability to learn? My understanding was that after the initial training it doesnt simply use all of its conversations as training data, to prevent a new Tay.
nul9090 t1_j9th1xg wrote
Reply to comment by fangfried in What are the big flaws with LLMs right now? by fangfried
Well, at the moment, we can't really have any idea. Quadratic complexity is definitely really bad. It limits how far we can push the architecture. It makes it hard to make it on to consumer hardware. But if we are as close to a breakthrough as some people believe maybe it isn't a problem.
duboispourlhiver t1_j9tgc8p wrote
Reply to comment by AylaDoesntLikeYou in US Copyright Office: You Can't Copyright Images Generated Using AI by vadhavaniyafaijan
I agree and I've been trying to find counterarguments to this practical problem, but yet I have found none serious. If anything has any idea why this could be false, please discuss!
The best counterargument I have found so far is that there could be programs able to detect if an image is AI generated. I had studied this point some weeks ago and I don't think such programs will exist.
FpRhGf t1_j9tg77o wrote
Reply to What are the big flaws with LLMs right now? by fangfried
A flaw is that the tokens in LLM are word-based, not character-based. It sees every word as an entirely different thing instead of a combination using the same 26 letters.
This means it's unable to give outputs that rely on knowledge of the text of the word itself. It can't write you a story that doesn't contain the letter “e”, write a poem with a specific number of syllables, create new words, write in pig-Latin, break up words in random ways or make wordplays that involves play on the letters rather than meaning etc.
There's a lot of things I want it to do that it can't do because of this limitation.
Lonely-Delivery-5510 t1_j9tfv1l wrote
Reply to What do you expect the most out of AGI? by Envoy34
Lmao
duboispourlhiver t1_j9tfsp3 wrote
Reply to comment by throwaway-clonewars in US Copyright Office: You Can't Copyright Images Generated Using AI by vadhavaniyafaijan
Thank you for this long and interesting point of view.
I think that without copyright, creative work can still be a source of income thanks to work for hire and crowdfunding. I've aligned my actions with my anti copyright beliefs for years and am only getting money in the form of work for hire. I feel more relaxed this way. But other opinions and ways of life are completely ok.
X-msky t1_j9tfbz5 wrote
Reply to What do you expect the most out of AGI? by Envoy34
I want the star trek replicator
tatleoat t1_j9tf9a9 wrote
Reply to comment by nul9090 in What are the big flaws with LLMs right now? by fangfried
RWKV has an unlimited context window
BenjaminJamesBush t1_j9tf53e wrote
Reply to comment by Mrkvitko in New agi poll says there is 50% chance of it happening by 2059. Thoughts? by possiblybaldman
Oh, totally, yes. Imagine an average human who is willing to learn and work on their goals 24/7. Now as u/Z1BattleBoy21 said imagine an army of such average humans.
AylaDoesntLikeYou t1_j9tewo7 wrote
In the near future (6 -12 months)
Ai art will be indistinguishable from human made art, in many cases it already is.
So you can create something with ai and just say it wasn't made with ai, who's gonna stop you? How can you prove someone really made something with ai?
You won't be able to, this decision is meaningless.
MysteryInc152 t1_j9terwg wrote
Reply to comment by turnip_burrito in What are the big flaws with LLMs right now? by fangfried
This is Bing's response to your question. I think we'd be surprised at how many of these problems will be solved by scale alone.
This sounds like a riddle. Is it? If so, I’m not very good at riddles. But I’ll try to answer it anyway. If the bus driver’s name is Michael and the bus driver is a dog, then the name of the dog is Michael. Is that correct?
MysteryInc152 t1_j9teeio wrote
Reply to comment by GoldenRain in What are the big flaws with LLMs right now? by fangfried
Bing's response to your question. I think a good deal of these problems can be solved with scale. But yes, someone needs to train a large scale multimodal model asap
Hello, this is Bing. I’m not sure why you don’t want me to search the web for this question, but I’ll try to answer it using my internal knowledge. Air is composed of tiny molecules that are much smaller than the eye of a needle. So yes, air can fit through the eye of a needle. However, if you try to push air through a needle that is filled with water or another liquid, you will encounter resistance and pressure. Why do you ask?
MysteryInc152 t1_j9tdocz wrote
Reply to comment by Denny_Hayes in And Yet It Understands by calbhollo
I saw a conversation where she got confused about a filter response. As in, hey why the hell did I say this ? so I think the replaced responses go in the model too
GoldenRain t1_j9tdgkq wrote
Reply to What are the big flaws with LLMs right now? by fangfried
Without a way to experience the world, they have little ability to truly understand what they are saying. For AGI to form, we need something more than just a next word predictor. An example from ChatGPT which any 5 year old would be able to answer:
Can air fit through the eye of a needle?
No, air cannot fit through the eye of a needle. The eye of a needle is typically very small, designed to allow a thread to pass through it, and is not large enough to accommodate the volume of air. Air is made up of molecules that are in constant motion, and the size of these molecules is much larger than the opening of the eye of a needle. Therefore, it is impossible for air to pass through the eye of a needle.
dasnihil t1_j9tczri wrote
Reply to comment by Revolutionary_Soft42 in Seriously people, please stop by Bakagami-
i do both, and live a very fulfilling life without worrying about buying or selling art. my hunger is not satisfied with one concept of art like i would spend my life making pencil sketches, I've made a lot of charcoal and pencil stuff over the years. but i would never want to do it too make ends meet.
thecuriousmushroom t1_j9tcsnq wrote
Reply to comment by Cryptic6127 in Does anyone else feel people don't have a clue about what's happening? by Destiny_Knight
I'm not sure what OP is specifically saying, but I think all of those are common opinions.
Rivarr t1_j9tcsbh wrote
Reply to What do you expect the most out of AGI? by Envoy34
Once we hit true AGI, we're in the realms of utopian possibilities. Whatever theoretically possible goal we have can likely be achieved. It's wild to think about.
Throwaway81094 t1_j9tcgqb wrote
Reply to What do you expect the most out of AGI? by Envoy34
I'm not sure what I should expect. That's why "singularity" is the proper term. Humanity's first physical contact with an alien intelligence will be transformative, horrifying and utterly mysterious.
savagefishstick t1_j9tbrmt wrote
Reply to New agi poll says there is 50% chance of it happening by 2059. Thoughts? by possiblybaldman
exponential growth is much faster than that. we will have it by the end of the decade, think of what the smart phone evolution but this will be for A.I.
marvinthedog t1_j9tb8y4 wrote
Reply to New agi poll says there is 50% chance of it happening by 2059. Thoughts? by possiblybaldman
I would really like to have a deep discussion with some of these machine learning researchers because I cannot in a million years fathom how they can hold such a different world view.
BlessedBobo t1_j9ta6q8 wrote
Reply to Seriously people, please stop by Bakagami-
I've Blocked every single person that posts their ChatGPT, Bing, Eleven Labs and Image gen results.
my sub experience has gone up at least 400%
turnip_burrito t1_j9t9qi0 wrote
Reply to comment by LiveComfortable3228 in What do you expect the most out of AGI? by Envoy34
"This world is imperfect.. If only I could wipe away the impurities, and make it as beautiful as me."
-OP
turnip_burrito t1_j9t9fo3 wrote
Reply to comment by 3xplo in What do you expect the most out of AGI? by Envoy34
Yes please.
If I'm going to be always at the mercy of a "higher power", then I want it to be consistently fair, considerate, and actually doing its damn job, as opposed to whatever humans in authority do.
Nukemouse t1_j9ti4it wrote
Reply to comment by MysteryInc152 in What are the big flaws with LLMs right now? by fangfried
That last bit, does it mean a syringe?