Recent comments in /f/space
OSFrog2023 t1_j8as584 wrote
Reply to comment by simcoder in This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
Indeed... that's why we have lines that are clearly defined and don't lead to whataboutisms...
HungryLikeTheWolf99 t1_j8as37g wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
Ok, so a breakdown of what happened:
Starlink provided internet in Ukraine to help keep their people informed and keep their economy running. No other company is prepared to provide this service at the level Starlink can.
Ukraine wanted to use the Starlink connections for military purposes.
Starlink was not prepared to become a military target (including their satellites). Surely there was an internal memo from the risk management department that said, in more words, "I told you so."
Starlink tries to protect the service they're providing to Ukraine and their own infrastructure in literally the only way they can: declare neutrality. (Edit: Except not neutrality, since they aren't offering the same service to Russia.)
People already upset about Elon Musk, in general, express their frustration about Starlink.
No one is upset with Hughesnet or Viasat for not providing their vastly inferior service for Ukraine.
Odd-Lynx-4313 OP t1_j8arrpa wrote
Reply to comment by jdobem in Small-Talk with ChatGPT about black hole as the universe by Odd-Lynx-4313
For bored people to read. :-)
[deleted] OP t1_j8arnk0 wrote
Reply to Cried tonight. by [deleted]
[removed]
simcoder t1_j8arksk wrote
Reply to comment by OSFrog2023 in This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
Well, but couldn't you come up with a scenario where the various comms capabilities delivered by Starlink resulted in some amount of violence and possibly other stuff that wouldn't be that different from what the drones do?
New_Poet_338 t1_j8ariy6 wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
The title of the article has nothing to do with the article itself. The article is interesting. The title is unhinged.
OSFrog2023 t1_j8arho3 wrote
Reply to comment by sirchief99 in This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
Some aint, more vocal ones tend to be tho 😞
sirchief99 t1_j8arbon wrote
Reply to comment by OSFrog2023 in This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
Leave it dude. These people are morons.
OSFrog2023 t1_j8arbij wrote
Reply to comment by simcoder in This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
No, eaponized drones aren't the same as Intel. One kills outright, another leads to killing. You can't supply the thing that is coordinating the killing, unless your the government that is.
jdobem t1_j8aqyqb wrote
We invented chatgpt to make summaries, not to write even longer than any human will care to read :)
unlimited_mcgyver t1_j8aqrl9 wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
When it first broke I thought he may have suspended the service because the use of it by Ukraine makes starlink, spacex, and musk himself, a military target for Russia to take out.
simcoder t1_j8aqr3c wrote
Reply to comment by OSFrog2023 in This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
But couldn't that apply to any military application of Starlink involving combat?
New_Poet_338 t1_j8aqpm9 wrote
Reply to comment by Ras82 in This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
Bravo. Right on the money. Also what they are suggesting breaks US arms export laws because SpaceX is not licensed to export weapon systems.
OSFrog2023 t1_j8aqers wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
You know how illegal it would be if he didn't do what he did? It would make him an Arms Dealer. A space arms dealer. Thats the only reason why he stopped them from linking drones. Because international law forbids it. Morons.
P.s. you realize musk and Russia compete right? And that he is their number 1 competition to a monopoly they've held for a while.
[deleted] OP t1_j8aqdob wrote
Reply to comment by manicdee33 in This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
[deleted]
manicdee33 t1_j8apu3t wrote
Reply to comment by 2FalseSteps in This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
It's not a rant. It's an English translation of a German blog post.
Posting the full text of an article that's otherwise inaccessible is a thing that Redditors do from time to time.
SirHerald t1_j8apo8n wrote
Did the prompt include "in the style of a long winded bore"?
manicdee33 t1_j8apn2z wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
Ukraine switched from using Starlink for CCC to using Starlink as the communications mechanism for drones flying far behind enemy lines.
SpaceX has simply disabled the use of terrestrial Starlink for drone communications. You want in-flight internet, you subscribe to the in-flight internet service.
The rest of this article is a decent run-down of the operation of Starlink in the Ukrainian defense against the Russian invasion.
Ras82 t1_j8ap7q0 wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
Yeah, the guy who spent countless millions of his own money to maintain internet for Ukrainian civilians and military is a bad faith actor... That makes total sense.
Or, since NATO is throwing billions of dollars at the Ukraine military, Musk wants them to bankroll Starlink for military purposes because as rich as he is, he doesn't have infinite capital.
Ras82 t1_j8ap6sr wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
Yeah, the guy who spent countless millions of his own money to maintain internet for Ukrainian civilians and military is a bad faith actor... That makes total sense.
Or, since NATO is throwing billions of dollars at the Ukraine military, Musk wants them to bankroll Starlink for military purposes because as rich as he is, he doesn't have infinite capital.
[deleted] t1_j8aoh4x wrote
Reply to comment by stiegosaurus in This is what the sky looked like during the spacex rocket launch by Zommerfeld
[deleted]
simcoder t1_j8aobv1 wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
I've always wondered if Putey called him late one night to discuss all the folks accidentally falling out of windows and such. And then suddenly Elon had the brainstorm to buy Twitter and step out of the starlink limelight.
2FalseSteps t1_j8ao3u3 wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
You do know subs have rules, right?
This isn't the sub for posting rants.
[deleted] OP t1_j8anvup wrote
Reply to This week Elon Musk blocked Starlink for "military purposes" in Ukraine. He is clearly a bad faith actor and/or compromised. Europe should build an alternative as soon as possible. This new space race will have huge geopolitical consequences. Deep analysis translated from German: by [deleted]
[removed]
cote112 t1_j8as6mm wrote
Reply to comment by Hustler-1 in This is what the sky looked like during the spacex rocket launch by Zommerfeld
Well I think they planned on doing the boost back somewhere around Hawaii to land in the water for the first orbital launch. Don't know if that's changed.