Recent comments in /f/space
MaekusMikolous t1_jd5pqa6 wrote
Reply to comment by Majestic_Pitch_1803 in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
Okay, we can get up to the speed of the asteroid ourselves, we don't even need it!
Insteadly t1_jd5po8i wrote
Reply to comment by Majestic_Pitch_1803 in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
That’s true even if you’re on an asteroid. Everything is moving.
[deleted] t1_jd5p88o wrote
Reply to Is there another massive planet beyond Neptune? If so, why haven’t we found it? by Always2ndB3ST
[removed]
Always2ndB3ST OP t1_jd5p81w wrote
Reply to comment by reddit455 in Is there another massive planet beyond Neptune? If so, why haven’t we found it? by Always2ndB3ST
Man, the incomprehensible size of space never ceases to amaze me..
Majestic_Pitch_1803 t1_jd5ou5b wrote
Reply to comment by FallenShadeslayer in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
Wait, are you talking to me through your handheld computer? Please, the science fiction.
Majestic_Pitch_1803 t1_jd5osmc wrote
Reply to comment by FallenShadeslayer in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
Lmao, haven’t we landed a probe on an asteroid before?
FallenShadeslayer t1_jd5onoi wrote
Reply to comment by Majestic_Pitch_1803 in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
What are you even talking about? Turning an asteroid into a ship? What? You need to chill out with the science fiction.
[deleted] OP t1_jd5o4j1 wrote
Reply to comment by Majestic_Pitch_1803 in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
[deleted]
Majestic_Pitch_1803 t1_jd5nutv wrote
Reply to comment by hdufort in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
Indeed, though this would be easier since you could send multiple smaller payloads that coalesce on the object. Not only this, if you somehow managed to mine and create small scale industrial works, you could maybe even make the fuel to bloody get off asteroid.
If you decided to send humans they could live inside the asteroid as a fortress from the elements, as a place from which to further develop the asteroid as a spacecraft itself. Creating many of the sensory instruments and propulsion technology or fuel, spaces for living aka creating agriculture and processing essential gasses.
If you ask why would you send humans on such a journey? Why would you send them on a voyager 1 like journey? You wouldn’t, you’d send them to a desired location, like near a habitable planet. Only it seems easier to me to do it this way than to try and send a single manned ship.
pompanoJ t1_jd5nm6z wrote
Reply to comment by SaltyDangerHands in Is there another massive planet beyond Neptune? If so, why haven’t we found it? by Always2ndB3ST
There could also be a huge planet way out near the oort cloud. With an orbital period in the thousands of years and a temperature near the background, it might take a tremendous stroke of luck to find it before we have a flotilla of Webb class space telescopes dedicated to the topic of outer solar system objects.
Majestic_Pitch_1803 t1_jd5ng8u wrote
Reply to comment by kennedy311 in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
Indeed I like that the idea is challenged, but also the people answering must know that someone could revise my plan and make it better very easily.
Majestic_Pitch_1803 t1_jd5n0gv wrote
Reply to comment by Diesalotwpg in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
I mean we had Oumuamua it feels like yesterday. And I know it isn’t the only one of it’s kind.
[deleted] OP t1_jd5mvco wrote
Majestic_Pitch_1803 t1_jd5mu7u wrote
Reply to comment by DrSartorius in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
I mean we landed on Bennu.
Just saying, not me personally- just to clarify.
DrSartorius t1_jd5md4f wrote
Reply to comment by Majestic_Pitch_1803 in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
bus is passing you with speed 94000 mph
jump on it
[deleted] t1_jd5mbu9 wrote
Reply to Japanese lander enters lunar orbit by Afrin_Drip
[removed]
Majestic_Pitch_1803 t1_jd5maih wrote
Reply to comment by MaekusMikolous in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
Making the initial payload lighter so that you would be able to send a number of rovers to develop a more sophisticated operation, once actually on the object, rather than trying to land the entire operation there, all in one go. Which would require heavier payloads with = harder to get to such speeds.
Getting off the asteroid is just as much an issue as slowing down an independent spacecraft that has reached similar speeds and makes an interstellar journey. How do we slow down? Wouldn’t we need fuel and propulsion just as we got up to the same speed so to board the asteroid initially, or to slow down an independent spacecraft.
At least on an asteroid you can mine for the fuel and create a rocket.
Diesalotwpg t1_jd5m7k7 wrote
Reply to Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
Aside from all the other points raised here the odds of finding any body travelling through our system that will also interersect another system in any non-geological time scale is infinitesimal. Space is too empty and extra-solar objects are too rare.
kennedy311 t1_jd5m21h wrote
Reply to Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
You're asking the right kind of question, even if this particular set of answers don't prove encouraging.
Macktologist t1_jd5m112 wrote
Reply to comment by PigSlam in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
So you’re saying we would need the protomolecule?
[deleted] t1_jd5m0e9 wrote
Reply to comment by WholeSilent8317 in Is there another massive planet beyond Neptune? If so, why haven’t we found it? by Always2ndB3ST
[deleted]
DrSartorius t1_jd5lwmo wrote
Reply to Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
primitive question for you - what speed supposed to have that "asteroid" (which can leave solar system)
Majestic_Pitch_1803 t1_jd5lvrb wrote
Reply to comment by Insteadly in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
Everything else is also moving though, some coming towards us, some moving away.
MaekusMikolous t1_jd5ls68 wrote
Reply to comment by Majestic_Pitch_1803 in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
Dude how is prospecting minerals, processing them, and then manufacturing materials, and then making them into useful products a good idea to be doing on an interstellar mission.
Please just submit.
Majestic_Pitch_1803 t1_jd5ps3x wrote
Reply to comment by PigSlam in Couldn’t we land on an asteroid that is passing through our solar system and use that as a vessel for interstellar travel? by [deleted]
I mean I wouldn’t worry about steering it.