ktpr

ktpr t1_ivoev3k wrote

The scientific process is typically undertaken within context of scientific venues. The authors can not be realistically expected to respond to ICLR and arm chair ml geniuses on the internet. Scientific venues aim to provide minimally acceptable quality control.

1

ktpr t1_iso1ef2 wrote

If you already graduated then do what what you value the most for the time involved and offer authorship to your adviser. Explain this is what makes sense for you and they can have a paper on their CV or not.

It’s clear they’re pushing for an alternative journal because that’s what valued by their field.

1